Homepage / Technology / How Google CEO Sundar Pichai decided to fire James Damore
Facebook slams former exec Palihapitiya, saying it 'was a very different company back then' 80% of Wall Street economists, strategists believe bitcoin is a bubble: Survey Facebook to book advertising revenue locally amid political pressure Strategist Tom Lee: Young people will drive bitcoin gains just as boomers boosted stocks in the '80s This founder started in his parents' garage—now his company does over $100 million a year Activision shares to get a boost from Overwatch, Diablo sequels, Goldman says Verizon will launch over-the-top service before year-end with NFL as key piece, analyst predicts Chamath Palihapitiya: Apple is 'no different than Louis Vuitton or any other luxury good' Passport's flagship fund to close after 'unacceptable' returns Apple's powerful new computer launches December 14 Despite a deluge of criticism, Mark Zuckerberg had a bountiful year Chamath Palihapitiya says Elon Musk is the 'most important entrepreneur of our generation' Senior Australian politician resigns over China ties scandal Forget bitcoin, one of its biggest cryptocurrency rivals is up nearly 5,800 percent this year Bitcoin futures fall on second day of trading on very low volume as interest wanes Bitcoin millionaire: Don't buy bitcoin Stocks making the biggest moves premarket: PEP, MAT, VZ, MYL & more Tech high flyers could soar 10% or more next year, investor Paul Meeks says Goldman Sachs predicts bumper returns for commodities next year Amazon is not a monopoly but there's no question why it's so dominant, tech investor Palihapitiya says Starbucks customer laptops hacked to mine cryptocurrency Fed Survey: Tax cuts and rate hikes on the way Social Capital's Palihapitiya says bitcoin is going to $1 million in the next 20 years Bitcoin bulls looking to diversify can now put money in a crypto-index fund Ex-Facebook executive Chamath Palihapitiya: Social media is creating a society that confuses 'truth and popularity' More American jobs? Broadcom deal might mean the opposite The bull case for gold as bitcoin captivates America One person reported dead after Austrian gas hub explosion Bitcoin bubble could lead to 'destructive' consequences, UBS says While you were watching bitcoin, the world’s second-largest cryptocurrency hit a big milestone French retail giant to buy mall operator Westfield in the biggest takeover of an Australian company ever Bitcoin futures launch is not taking away demand from gold, Goldman Sachs says Germany outpaces UK for commercial real estate investment, survey finds UK inflation comes in at 3.1 percent, highest since March 2012 Amazon expands its cloud presence in China as it battles the country's internet giants Robert Gates says a North Korean nuclear warhead will soon be an accepted reality European markets set to open higher as investors look ahead to Fed, ECB meetings Cryptocurrencies could be rocked by major hacks next year, expert warns Trump's 'ill-advised' move over Jerusalem has set back peace process, former secretary of defense says Four charts from Google make the argument for a growing, $50 billion e-commerce bloc Corporate deals slowed dramatically in 2017, but at least one country bucked the trend The 'alt-right' created a parallel internet. It's a holy mess Google eclipses Facebook as the top source of traffic for online publishers Cramer Remix: Acadia is the most volatile stock I’ve ever covered — and it’s worth speculating on Topgolf CEO sees 'real growth' in golf, says he's 'winning' with millennials Cramer: Auto parts stocks like O'Reilly wrongly sold off and are buys Asian markets look to follow Wall Street's strong lead, and New Zealand dollar firms Cramer tackles the question of why the market has been so positive for 2017 Electric vehicle demand is driving huge jump in number of battery factories around the world Bitcoin has aspects of a bubble, but it's OK to 'play' with it: Economist Robert Shiller Icahn wages new fight with Xerox with plans to nominate 4 to board Cisco CEO Chuck Robbins thinks he's finally found the key to growing in China Why Apple just spent up to $400 million on song-identification app Shazam Trump orders NASA to send American astronauts to the moon, Mars People are taking out mortgages to buy bitcoin, says securities regulator Here are JPMorgan’s favorite chip stock picks for the next year Ford says hybrids beat electric for self-driving cars Zuckerberg's purchase of Instagram was the perfect 'teen and millennial hedge' for Facebook Shares of retailer-turned-bitcoin-play Overstock.com rocket higher after Morgan Stanley reveals stake Amazon has sharply curtailed hiring in Seattle as it seeks second headquarters Start-up Fuzzy offers house calls for your pets for $468 a year Manufacturing CEO survey shows record high optimism on prospect of tax reform A top VC explains which technologies will change society the most in 10 years American Express is getting rid of signatures for credit card purchases Bitcoin futures up and running but trading is light Apple to buy music recognition app Shazam The smart play on bitcoin: Don't mine the gold, sell the picks and shovels Cramer: Bitcoin's futures launch is a 'very big victory' for the digital currency If Tim Cook is right about AR, Lumentum is a buy On Main Street the bigger you are, the better tax reform looks: CNBC/SurveyMonkey Ethereum creator compares crypto mania to world’s biggest art auction UBS: Cryptocurrencies like bitcoin are ‘the bubble to end all bubbles’ Google's high-end smart speaker, which rivals a Sonos, is now available Bitcoin futures launch could be bad for bitcoin’s price, tech analyst Gene Munster says Bank of America analyst predicts EA will bring back 'Star Wars' micro-transactions despite uproar European finance ministers call for US tax reform rethink Goldman upgrades ADP, says it will be 'outsized beneficiary' of GOP tax cuts iPhone X supply has improved, with most models now shipping in 2-5 days Former Facebook exec Chamath Palihapitiya says social media is ripping apart society Investors 'haven't missed the train' on bitcoin yet, but it could be a wild ride, analyst says Stocks making the biggest moves premarket: ADP, FIT, X, LKQ & more Vladimir Putin orders Russian forces to start pulling out of Syria NFL and Verizon strike a mobile deal to expand live game streaming Fueled by investor taste for liquid alternative investments, hedge fund conversions skyrocket Uber’s fight for survival in London is pushed to 2018 but another key Europe ruling is imminent Bitcoin price jumps $2,000 after Cboe futures launch Contenders emerge for the No. 2 Fed job as search narrows Investors are dumping gold to buy bitcoin, says strategist Currency expert says there's one fundamental reason behind bitcoin's runaway rally Global arms sales rise for first time since 2010 Trader who called bitcoin rally says cryptocurrency will surge above $100,000 in 2018 Chinese drone maker wants to fly people around, and it says it will turn a profit in two years European markets set to start week higher ahead of Fed, ECB meetings New Zealand's central bank just got a new governor How Chinese spies used LinkedIn to snoop on German politicians Instant noodle giant aims to boost paltry market share in China with healthy ramen Rohingya curries and Syrian sweets from refugees are making start-up a hit A Muslim country that isn’t even in the Middle East says it’s willing to send troops to Jerusalem One of the world's largest shipbuilders names a new CEO days after dire warning on losses Rubber farmers are getting slammed by low prices — but one company wants to fix that

Technology

How Google CEO Sundar Pichai decided to fire James Damore

Let’s all assume Google CEO Sundar Pichai has a really hard day ahead of him.

That’s because at 4 pm PT, the tech giant will hold an all-hands meeting to discuss the firing of James Damore and the controversial internal memo he wrote about women and their biological weaknesses related to tech that got him canned.

The gathering will take place at Google headquarters in Mountain View, Calif. today and streamed live to its global offices, reaching the 60,000 employees that the Alphabet unit employs. Since many will not be at work when the meeting takes place, it will also be available for replay.

More from Recode:

And what a topic to discuss: Damore’s essay has resulted in massive and sometimes ugly debates inside and outside Google about diversity, gender issues and free speech, about which many disagree.

One thing is clear: It will be one of the biggest public challenges the cerebral, soft-spoken and — in my experience — unfailingly thoughtful executive will face in his 13 years at Google (and almost two as its CEO), as he seeks to calm the muddy and sometimes ugly waters that Damore has churned up via his post titled “Google’s Ideological Echo Chamber.”

Pichai made the final decision about Damore’s fate, after what several sources characterized as a tough debate by top management, with initial disagreement over how to handle the situation. It took place Monday in person and via phone after a weekend of trying to corral top staff, many of whom were on vacation, including Pichai.

According to those familiar with the discussion, his dozen direct reports whom he consulted were initially at odds about what to do about Google’s continual and complex balancing act between free speech and fostering a safe workplace.

“Just like all of Google is struggling with this, we were not unanimous at first about whether what [Damore] wrote merited firing, although we all came around to it,” said one top exec, “But Sundar had to make a call about what kind of Google he wanted to stress and he did.”

Others in the meeting said it centered on how much latitude employees should have to express their opinions — one of the central tenets of Google since its founding — versus creating a culture that is trying to become attractive and safe to a broader range of people.

“I think the problem and also benefit of Google has been that we’ve created and encouraged an environment where everyone thinks they can say what they want, because that is what has always been the way it has been,” said another top exec. “But, at some point, if we really want to change, we have to think harder about what impact that has, especially when it makes women or others feel unsafe in the environment we have created.”

It’s a split reflected at the very top of Google’s owner, Alphabet, where its top lawyer, David Drummond, has been one of the most vocal advocates of free speech over the years. He was not part of Monday’s decision-making meeting, as an Alphabet exec.

Meanwhile, another longtime Google leader, YouTube CEO Susan Wojcicki, who was, penned her own essay that appeared in Fortune this week, with an opposite take:

“While people may have a right to express their beliefs in public, that does not mean companies cannot take action when women are subjected to comments that perpetuate negative stereotypes about them based on their gender. Every day, companies take action against employees who make unlawful statements about co-workers, or create hostile work environments.”

It’s all against a backdrop of a company that — contrary to Damore’s contention that he had been “shamed” into silence — has allowed its employees an unusual amount of latitude to air their opinions on a myriad of online platforms and in offline gatherings on everything from the quality of the food at its many free cafeterias to the political stances of the company.

(Sorry, young James: But, IMHO over nearly two decades of covering the company, Google workers never seem to shut up about anything. In fact, I seen low-level engineers insult its founders, Larry Page and Sergey Brin, at public events with the pair insulting right back. My takeaway: Good lord, they all talk too much for techies.)

And talk I am certain they will do today, with Pichai facing a buzzsaw of differing opinion about that on both sides of an ever-complex debate about gender and diversity.

Some inside Google think it took too long for bosses there to react to what they consider a fatuous screed; while others disagree with their decision to eject Damore from the company altogether for speaking his mind.

And some want the company to do even more to fix persistent statistics that show around 80 percent of its technical staff is male that might have led to such musings; even as others think Google’s diversity programs to help improve the numbers are deeply flawed and even discriminatory toward men.

For those not paying attention, Damore posted a 10-page, 3,000 word thesis in which he began simply enough:

“I value diversity and inclusion, am not denying that sexism exists, and don’t endorse using stereotypes. When addressing the gap in representation in the population, we need to look at population level differences in distributions. If we can’t have an honest discussion about this, then we can never truly solve the problem.”

But then, in what is pretty much the main premise, Damore went on in detail: “I’m simply stating that the distribution of preferences and abilities of men and women differ in part due to biological causes and that these differences may explain why we don’t see equal representation of women in tech and leadership.”

What followed was a list of those differences, including a claim that women were more social and artistic and could not take the stress of high-pressure jobs. Hence, “neuroticism,” or higher anxiety and lower stress tolerance, which he claimed was backed up by studies.

Perhaps most disingenuously, Damore also claimed that he had no voice, even after penning a long memo that he was able to send companywide and also was read by millions more.

In fact, Damore posted the essay earlier in one of Google’s smaller discussion platforms — not one like its massive “eng-misc” one — before it finally bubbled up this past weekend and was finally noticed by top execs.

Alerted to it, sources said Pichai then started off gathering opinions from his direct reports — such as Wojcicki, HR head Eileen Naughton, top lawyer Kent Walker, cloud leader Diane Greene, communications head Jessica Powell and business head Philipp Schindler. Not all were physically present at Google’s Silicon Valley HQ, where the group debated the issue, and were at first split.

“It was a cordial discussion, considering the topic, and you could see how you could argue both sides on the face of it,” said one source. “But I think Damore’s focus on biology really made it clear that he had crossed the line.”

What turned the tide, said sources, was when it was noted that if Damore’s dubious contentions about women’s skills were replaced by those about race or religion, there would be no debate.

In fact, Wojcicki said has much in her essay:

“For instance, what if we replaced the word ‘women’ in the memo with another group? What if the memo said that biological differences amongst Black, Hispanic, or LGBTQ employees explained their underrepresentation in tech and leadership roles? Would some people still be discussing the merit of the memo’s arguments or would there be a universal call for swift action against its author? I don’t ask this to compare one group to another, but rather to point out that the language of discrimination can take many different forms and none are acceptable or productive.”

Damore has insisted he was “smeared” by top execs after the post went viral. “There was a concerted effort among upper management to have a very clear signal that what I did was harmful and wrong and didn’t stand for Google,” Damore said in an interview with Bloomberg. “It would be career suicide for any executives or directors to support me.”

Numerous Google execs and employees I spoke to scoff at that notion, who gave his first interviews to an alt-right site, which has lessened support of him inside Google. Said one flatly: “He cannot spew his dubious biology arguments — you can find any study to justify any crazy notion — and not pay a price for it.”

Pichai wrote to employees on Monday and said as much, but much more politely: “To suggest a group of our colleagues have traits that make them less biologically suited to that work is offensive and not OK.”

In other words, the CEO of Google has spoken. And now, Googlers will get their chance.

Source: Tech CNBC
How Google CEO Sundar Pichai decided to fire James Damore

Comments are closed.