Homepage / Technology / Amazon faces a tax fight in South Carolina that could change how online sellers do business
China urges restraint amid war of words between Trump and North Korea Britain's Deliveroo is now worth over $2 billion after raising $385 million Unilever to buy Carver Korea for $2.7 billion Japan PM Abe announces $17.8 billion economic stimulus package Europe's most important economic policymaker may soon be losing his job Japan's Abe will reportedly announce snap elections for next month Fitch: Some of China's first local government bonds are likely to default European markets seen lower on German election result; Brexit talks resume Trump-like politician will get final say on New Zealand's next government China banned new cryptocurrencies, but a Macau company still plans $500 million token sale Schneider Electric CEO: Aveva acquisition combines software and engineering strengths Kushner used private email to communicate with White House colleagues, his lawyer says White House issues updated travel ban, with fresh restrictions on who can enter US Asian shares to focus on German, New Zealand election results Italy's anti-establishment party is softening its stance on Europe as a new leader is appointed Euro slips after German election reveals surprising far-right support Mazda's new MX-5 Miata retractable fastback is pint-sized perfection Merkel on track for fourth term as German chancellor; far-right party set to enter parliament for first time Diners are on the hunt for Instagram-worthy experiences, and restaurants embrace the moment Silicon Valley's men are embracing 'men's rights' as pushback against gender equality movement The new Apple Watch finally freed me from my phone The CEO who pulled the plug on a neo-Nazi site says he did it to protect his company Uber is reportedly ready to make concessions to reverse London license decision Trump tweets threats to North Korea after UN speech by rogue nation's foreign minister Six injured in London after group of males spray a substance thought to be acid Why the Rolling Stones hope fans will buy a $72 version of an album Mick Jagger once 'rubbished' US bombers fly off North Korea's coast in show of force This robotic smart glove is like wearing a bionic hand I'm perfectly happy with the iPhone 8 I bought — there's no need to wait for the X UK credit rating downgrade based on 'outdated' Brexit view, government says China bans refined oil product exports to North Korea as part of UN economic sanctions Japan needs to also push for dialogue with North Korea, not just sanctions: China's top diplomat Mark Zuckerberg is handling Facebook's Russian meddling issue by following a familiar playbook Investor group seeks probe into SEC hack, urges data rules delay After losing a massive deal with Apple, chip company Imagination will sell itself for $742.5 million Uber CEO on losing London license: 'There is a high cost to a bad reputation' Facebook’s Frankenstein moment: Facebook may have created something it can't fully control Mark Zuckerberg will sell up to 75 million Facebook shares, now worth $12.8 billion, over 18 months Facebook cancels plan to change ownership share structure Facebook settles investor lawsuit over Zuckerberg's control of the company Some people are learning to code in their 60s, 70s or 80s Apple's shed $50 billion — more than eBay, Target or Ford — since it unveiled the new iPhone How 2 young guys went from the brink of bankruptcy to selling their business for $300 million Amazon's restaurant delivery service still needs to solve one major problem Boeing sees more ‘excitement about space’ now than in the last few decades New drug test can detect cocaine in a fingerprint in seconds Strategist predicts bitcoin, digital currency trading volume will 'soon surpass' Apple's Apple CEO Tim Cook: iPhone 8 and Apple Watch Series 3 are sold out in some places Josh Brown: Here's what should keep Facebook shareholders up at night The lines for new iPhones at the Apple Store are getting shorter every year Billionaire investor Jim Breyer on why big technology growth stocks will keep surging Sleep pods are becoming increasingly common at airports PRO Talks: Billionaire tech investor Jim Breyer on how A.I. will change everything Art Cashin: Kim Jong Un faces 'dire straits' without Chinese financial backing Goldman downgrades Tiffany shares on ‘fresh weakness’ in sales of higher-priced jewelry Top VC deals this week: Electric scooters, Slack, and a Chinese self-driving car firm Uber slams London regulators for caving in to a 'small number of people', launches petition Amazon Restaurants aims to simplify food delivery, sending GrubHub shares lower In major new speech, UK leader Theresa May says UK hoping for a 'creative and practical' Brexit Finish Line shares sink on underwhelming earnings, as same-store sales wane Gene Munster: Expect a 'rocky day' for Apple's stock; shorter lines for the iPhone 8 Uber's biggest UK competitor is celebrating the company's ban by offering massive discounts Your first trade for Friday, September 22 Alibaba is much more than just China's e-commerce platform Walmart tests delivering groceries straight to fridge An inside look at the Museum of Ice Cream Lyft thinks it can forge a business in helping low-income seniors Apocalyptic emergency alert flashes on TVs, freaking out Californians London police charge 18-year-old man over Parsons Green bomb attack Gatorade pays California $300,000 and promises to not badmouth water Buy Apple because more expensive $1,000 iPhone X will boost its profit: Analyst ‘We don't want a fat Europe, we want a fit Europe,’ says German politician Early movers: TMUS, S, AAPL, FB, TSLA, CAG, WMT & more UK fintech start-up looks to raise $54 million investment for global expansion White House softens trade stance as tax reform fight approaches: 'We need the votes there' Wireless carriers T-Mobile, Sprint are close to agreeing to merger terms Uber loses its licence to operate in London Russia steps in to prevent 'domino effect' in its banking sector — but confidence concerns linger Jamie Dimon lays into bitcoin again, says it’s ‘worth nothing’ Euro zone businesses end the third quarter on a high note 'I am afraid': First far-right party set to enter German parliament in over half a century Aston Martin CEO: Green vehicle regulations are meaningless and 'just spin' China state media: Pulling out of Iran deal would set 'bad precedent' for North Korea European stocks seen lower on geopolitics; Brexit speech from UK PM on the radar Bitcoin is fiat money, too German elections: Why hungry stock traders should be wary of Sunday's vote German elections — here's all you need to know about Sunday's vote South Korea approves $8 million aid for the North even as Kim and Trump trade insults and threats North Korea foreign minister says may detonate nuclear bomb in Pacific Ocean, reports South Korea media China's about to get its first new central bank head in 15 years Hewlett Packard Enterprise said to be slashing 10% of its staff Cramer points to stocks that become money magnets during a correction Cramer finds a new way to look at 'broken stocks' in a sell-off North Korea leader Kim says 'deranged' Trump 'will face results beyond his expectation' Software company MongoDB seeks to raise $100 million in IPO Here's what really terrifies Wall Street about the SEC hack Read Mark Zuckerberg's full remarks on Facebook's efforts to 'protect election integrity' Trader bets against Apple — here’s how low he thinks it will go SEC system that was breached is decades old, says former SEC attorney Facebook provided suspected Russian-linked election ads to Congress

Technology

Amazon faces a tax fight in South Carolina that could change how online sellers do business

President Trump has repeatedly attacked Amazon and its CEO Jeff Bezos for dodging financial obligations, tweeting as recently as June that the company avoids “paying internet taxes.”

While the president’s claims have remained vague, at least one state is now making a similar allegation — and providing some substance to back it up.

In June, South Carolina filed a complaint alleging that Amazon failed to collect taxes on sales made by third-party merchants on the company’s marketplace. These are products where Amazon is not the seller, but rather is connecting other businesses to consumers and providing the payment processing for the transaction as well as some customer support.

The state claimed that for the first quarter of 2016, Amazon owes $12.5 million in taxes, penalties and interest, an amount that “will continue to accrue until this matter is resolved.”

In the complaint, obtained by CNBC, South Carolina’s Department of Revenue said Amazon is responsible for collecting taxes on behalf of the businesses that used the marketplace to sell products to residents of the state. A spokesperson for the state declined to comment on why the audit was limited to that three month period.

The dispute is the latest in Amazon’s long history of complicated tax issues and threatens to become quite the headache for the e-tailer should South Carolina succeed and set a precedent for other states. Not only would Amazon have to put more controls in place, but costs would rise for consumers and sellers would lose a pricing advantage they currently have over physical retailers.

“Going after the online marketplace facilitator is certainly a recent door that’s been opened,” said Jeff Glickman, a tax expert and lawyer at business advisory firm Aprio. “I certainly do expect more states to follow suit.”

Don’t expect Bezos to back down. In Amazon’s latest quarterly report, the company said, “we believe the assessment is without merit,” and that such a change could be costly.

“If South Carolina or other states were successfully to seek additional adjustments of a similar nature, we could be subject to significant additional tax liabilities,” Amazon said. “We intend to defend ourselves vigorously in this matter.”

A spokesperson declined to comment further.

As of early 2017 — contrary to some of President Trump’s tweets — Amazon collects sales tax in every state where it’s required for products the company actually sells. Retailers have to charge sales tax in any state where they have a nexus, which generally means a physical presence like an office or warehouse. Amazon has three warehouses in South Carolina.

But when it comes to third-party merchants, who now account for over half the volume of goods sold on the site, Amazon maintains that the seller is responsible for determining if sales tax is required and for collecting and remitting it.

South Carolina is fighting that premise, arguing that under state law, Amazon is considered the seller because the company controls a large part of the sales process for its third-party merchants.

For example, Amazon handles shipping and storing for some sellers who pay fees for the Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) program. Even sellers who store inventory at home or in their own warehouse rely on Amazon to manage some elements of the transaction, like payment processing and customer support, according to the complaint.

Amazon also has strict policies on third-party sellers related to things like shipping times and refunds.

South Carolina isn’t alone. According to Avalara, a provider of tax automation services, Minnesota, Rhode Island and Washington have passed legislation to tax marketplace sales, while Virginia and Arizona have their own sets of rules. New York and Texas have considered imposing taxes.

The Multistate Tax Commission, which recently rolled out a tax amnesty program for online merchants, estimates that Amazon sellers owe about $2 billion a year in uncollected sales taxes.

Darien Shanske, a law professor at the University of California, Davis, said that South Carolina has a plausible case because it’s clear that Amazon and its sellers have more than a “passive” relationship. He said Amazon would likely be deemed responsible for tax collection if the state can prove the company is “sufficiently important” to helping out-of-state merchants’ sales within the state.

“Third-party sellers are clearly choosing Amazon because of its own particular setup and benefits, beyond just passively having their things for sale on Amazon,” Shanske said. “It looks to me that there’s some kind of a relationship, approaching an agent or an independent contractor.”

One reason for the complexity is that laws vary by the state, and the ruling can come down to statutory interpretation. Utah, for example, recently ruled that sellers are not required to collect taxes.

“It’s an issue that state taxing authorities are going to pursue vigorously if they feel they have authority under their statute to do so,” said John Swain, a law professor at the University of Arizona. “But it’s very difficult to generalize.”

Shanske said that should the opportunity arise, many states will certainly be looking to bolster tax revenue.

“If one state is successful in pioneering a strategy that might be successful, I’d expect other states to pursue it as well,” he said.

Source: Tech CNBC
Amazon faces a tax fight in South Carolina that could change how online sellers do business

Comments are closed.