Homepage / Investment / Wal-Mart's buyback is huge, but here's why you should not be chasing buybacks
Les Gambling establishments en Ligne en France 2024 200% Reward + 300 Free Rotates LevelUp Internet casino Melbourne En İyi ve Güvenilir Casino Siteleri Canlı Casino Siteleri 2023 Listesi En İyi ve Güvenilir Casino Siteleri Canlı Casino Siteleri 2023 Listesi Le meilleur casino en ligne franзais Extra Casino avec le dйpфt minimal le in addition bas Yeni Casino Siteleri ᐈ Çevrimiçi Kumarhaneler Mart 2024 Les gambling establishments en ligne proposent une grande variйtй de jeux de internet casino gratuits. Türkiye’deki Resmi Web Sitesi Google Play, Türkiye’de kumar oyunlarına izin verecek Her Gün Tatil Olsa ORDU’DA PAZARTESİ GÜNÜ FINDIK FİYATI NASIL? كازينو اون لاين الكازينوهات الممتازة على الإنترنت ألعاب الكازينو المباشرة مينا كازينو العر Google Play, Türkiye’de kumar oyunlarına izin verecek Domain Sorgulama & Domain Fýrsatlarý Canlı Casino Siteleri: 2024 Güvenilir Siteler Seçilmiştir Golden Easter Slot İncelemesi 2024, Demoyu Ücretsiz Oynayın Golden Easter Slot İncelemesi 2024, Demoyu Ücretsiz Oynayın 1xbet Türkiye Giriş Empieza Kayıt 202 Kumar Ve Kumarhaneler Hakkında Pek İlginç 21 Bilgi Kumarhane Doğru Yazımı Nedir? Tdk Ile Kumarhane Kelimesinin Doğru Yazılışı! Mobilbahiste En İyi Kumar Bonusları Ve Kazançlar Mobilbahis Giriş Sayfası On Line Casino Siteleri En Iyi Casino Siteleri 2024 Mostbet: Türkiye’de Internet Casino Mostbet Online Slotlar Ve Canlı-casin Pin Up Casino Oyna Türkiye, Pinup’un Sah Web Sites Ifade Haberleri Son Dakika Ifade Hakkında Güncel Haber Ve Bilgiler “önceliğimiz Transferin Önünü Açmak, Görüştüğümüz Yerler Var” On Line Casino Nuh’un Gemisi Deluxe Resort & Spa, Kıbrıs Bonus Veren Siteler 3 000 Den Fazla Online Oyunu Ücretsiz Oyna En Tehlikeli Kumar Oyunu Ekşi Sözlük Deneme Bonusu Veren Siteler Deneme Bonusu 2024 Explore the Magic of WildCardCity Güvenilir Bahis Siteleri En İyi Kumar Siteleri Balıkesir Triatlonuna Avrupadan Ödül Tricks of the Aviator gambling establishment game by Spribe Çevrim Içi Kumar Siteleri “bonus” Yalanıyla Kandırıyor En Güvenilir Canlı On Line Casino Siteleri Xbetting-tips Com Uncovering the Abundant Tapestry of Ozwin Gambling establishment Evaluating Board Portal Providers Uncovering the Wealthy Tapestry of Ozwin On line casino Electronic Data Area Providers Evaluation Cobra Internet casino: Raising the Australian On the internet Video gaming Practical experience 4 Things to Search for in Safeguarded Cloud Safe-keeping Fastpay On line casino Australia – Simple and No-Taxation Wagering Web page officielle franзaise de Joka Gambling establishment The Software Development Universe Game Woo Internet casino – Enjoy Slot machine games around australia Ostdeutsche Biersorten What Are Virtual Data Rooms? Vitamin D Receptor Polymorphisms Revue du Casino BlackLabel Faktory, kterй ovlivnujн hodnocenн ceskэch online kasin How to Make the Most of Your Web Development Organization and Advertising Efforts L’essor des casinos en ligne en France Boost Meeting Efficiency With Boardroom Technology Developments WildJoker Casino WildCardCity On line casino – Guaranteed Australian Gambling Portal WildCardCity Casino – The Ideal On the internet Gambling establishment within australia Modern Technologies Produce Sharing Documents Online Faster and More Protect Free Virtual Info Room pertaining to Speedy Due Diligence A Review of Data Area Software For people who do buiness Five Board Bedroom Features Which will help You Acquire a More Productive Boardroom Electronic Systems To your Business Understanding Legal Terms and Laws in Today’s World The Laws and Contracts of Hollywood: A Sunset Blvd. Tale Legal Discussion Between Johnny Cash and Antonin Scalia Legal Insights: What Teens Should Know Legal Issues and Exceptions: What You Need to Know Legal Insights and Expert Analysis Celebrity Dialogue: Legal Matters in the 21st Century Famous Personalities Discuss Legal Issues The Boys in the Boat: Legal Advisors and The Quest for Legal Knowledge Understanding Legal Matters: Q&A on Criminal Law, Joint Ventures, and More Enticing Title The Departed: Understanding Basic Work Requirements and Legal Rights Youth Slang Blog Article Legal Insights: A Journey into the World of Law The Ins and Outs of Legal Matters: Everything You Need to Know Legal Insights and Trends: A Rap Guide Mysterious Legal Matters Unveiled Insights and Information: Understanding Various Laws and Regulations Famous People of the 21st Century The Circle of Legal Life The Intersection of Fashion Law, Legal Translation, and THC Oil: A Modern Legal Guide Legal Q&A: Understanding Joinder Federal Rules and More Understanding Legal Terms and Conditions: A Comprehensive Guide Understanding Legal Documentation in a Fun Way! Understanding Legal Aspects: From Islamic Law of Inheritance to Farm Law Protests Understanding Legal Rights: A Guide to Legal Regulations and Requirements Understanding Legal Guidelines and Agreements Famous 21st Century People in Conversation Mysterious Legal Matters Unveiled Legal Matters and Real Estate: A Conversation Between Cameron Boyce and Donald Trump Understanding Legal Expertise and Why It Matters Legal FAQs and Expert Services Understanding Legal Ramifications: Common Law Ontario Health Benefits and More The Ins and Outs of Legal Requirements: From FBI Academy Physical Requirements to Silver Lake Fishing Rules The Legal Underworld: Understanding the Significance of Laws and Rights Legal Conversations: A Dialogue Between Jon Jones and Chadwick Boseman Legal Beats: Bobcats, Real Estate, Babysitting, and More

Investment

Wal-Mart's buyback is huge, but here's why you should not be chasing buybacks

Wal-Mart trading volume was huge today, more than three normal as investors love the emphasis on e-commerce and another massive $20 billion buyback.

You can buy a lot of Wal-Mart stock for $20 billion. It’s about 8 percent of the shares outstanding at the current price, but it doesn’t even come close to the biggest buybacks ever announced:

Biggest buybacks ever

GE (2015) $50 b
Apple (2017) $50 b
Apple (2015) $50 b
Apple (2013) $50 b
Microsoft (2013) $40 b
Microsoft (2006) $40 b
Microsoft (2008) $40 b

Still, what’s important is that Wal-Mart is part of an elite group of large-cap companies I call “buyback monsters” who have bought back huge amounts of their stock in the last decade or so. Their ranks include IBM, Microsoft, Kohl’s, Target, and Boeing:

Buyback monsters
(% of shares bought back)

Wal-Mart (since 2002) 30 percent
ExxonMobil (since 2000) 41 percent
IBM (since 1998) 53 percent
Kohl’s (since 2006) 50 percent
Target (since 2004) 40 percent
Boeing (since 1999) 39 percent

What does it mean? It means that these companies have dramatically boosted their earnings, not by selling more stuff, but by buying back stock. It means that all other things being equal, Wal-Mart, for example has improved its earnings by 30 percent since 2002 just by buying back stock.

This sounds like a great deal for stock holders. But does buying back stock really cause stock prices to outperform? If it really does help boost earnings, why don’t we just buy the companies that have bought back the most stock?

It’s a tough question to answer, but, as with everything, there’s an ETF for that. And the evidence is it can be a big help, but without improvement in fundamentals, investors are not going to be fooled.

There are two ETFs that specialize in buybacks: The Powershares BuyBack Achievers Index (PKW) is comprised of US securities issued by corporations that have effected a net reduction in shares outstanding of 5 percent or more in the trailing 12 months. And the SPDR Buyback Index (SPYB) is designed to measure the performance of the top 100 stocks with the highest buyback ratios in the S&P 500.

OK, so far so good. What’s the verdict?

Buybacks vs. the markets
(YTD)

S&P 500 up 13.8 percent
SPDR Buyback (SPYB) up 11.0 percent
PowerShares Buyback (PKW) up 11.3 percent

Well, that’s underwhelming. There is no outperformance. It’s the same if you go back two years.

It’s possible there are too many companies in the ETFs, both have over 100. But I think there’s a bigger problem. Buybacks do not guarantee stock price hikes.

Just look at General Electric, which has bought back 15 percent of its stock just since the start of 2016. It’s down 20 percent in that same period.

And look at Kohl’s, Target, and IBM. Buyback monsters, all of them, but the fundamentals are awful, and buybacks did not save them. All three are down double-digits this year.

In contrast, Apple’s business has been great, as has Microsoft. Both are also buyback monsters, and they are up huge this year.

The lesson: Stock buybacks can boost earnings, but without underlying fundamentals, it’s not worth chasing them. Wal-Mart’s buyback was certainly a big help, but without the added bonus of additional investments in the e-commerce business, it wouldn’t have been a long-term boost.

Source: Investment Cnbc
Wal-Mart's buyback is huge, but here's why you should not be chasing buybacks

Comments are closed.