Homepage / Currency / Richard Thaler’s work demonstrates why economics is hard
GoodRx, a service for finding bargains on prescription drugs, is in sale talks for up to $3 billion The 4 fastest-growing job skills of the next three to five years: LinkedIn Buffett, Bezos and Dimon's health-care pick is known as a thought leader, not a business leader Alexa goes to college: Northeastern is giving students Amazon Echo Dots Disney-Comcast bidding war for Fox will go up to $45 a share before Disney wins: media expert Tesla's alleged rogue employee is exactly what Congress is worried about with self-driving cars Former Citrix chief Mark Templeton takes over at cloud start-up DigitalOcean Apple makes a big push into kids' content with creators of Sesame Street A year later, what Uber has done to revamp its troubled image The United States just built the world's fastest supercomputer — here's what that means Instagram crosses 1 billion monthly active users, unveils long-form video Microsoft acquires Bonsai to help with its artificial intelligence push Stitch Fix shares pop on speculation of Oprah taking stake in the company The AT&T-Time Warner ruling is making the Murdoch family billions of dollars richer Here's why Google and Amazon probably will never be included in the Dow Chinese investment in the US drops 90% amid political pressure Tesla sues former employee for allegedly stealing gigabytes of data, making false claims to media Nasdaq CEO says ICOs are 'taking advantage' of retail investors JP Morgan is unleashing artificial intelligence on a business that moves $5 trillion for corporations every day This health tech start-up refused to take money from VC firms unless they had a female partner General Electric shareholders should rejoice at the Dow removal US existing home sales fall for second straight month Silicon Valley has an Achilles’ heel that threatens its supremacy in innovation Threatened by coalition partner, Merkel seeks to break migration deadlock China has an Iran oil lever over Trump and it's all playing out at OPEC meeting How tech companies conquered America's cities Nantucket home prices break record highs Oracle reduced visibility into its cloud business, and some analysts aren't happy Buffett, Bezos, Dimon appoint Dr. Atul Gawande as CEO of their newly formed health care company AMC will offer its own MoviePass-like subscription AT&T Advertising CEO: We need to buy more technology to make ads less obtrusive and more relevant Buy beaten-down Citi shares ahead of stress test results and earnings, Deutsche Bank says Disability applications plunge as the economy strengthens A ‘day of reckoning’ is coming for stocks. Here’s what could spark it, says market watcher Disney raises bid for Fox assets to $71.3 billion in cash and stock Morgan Stanley downgrades Starbucks due to its China sales growth stumble Trump wages trade conflicts during historically difficult time for the stock market A cruel summer for stocks is likely upon us, Federated's Phil Orlando warns OPEC set for a collision course over production policy ahead of landmark meeting Stocks making the biggest moves premarket: WGO, GE, FDX, ORCL, SBUX & more GE shares drop after the blue chip gets booted from the Dow, ending a 110-year run EU to hit $3.2 billion of US imports starting Friday in response to Trump's tariffs Mortgage applications jump 5.1% as interest rates settle Kroger, on a 'wild ride' in the last year, reports earnings this week. Here's how to play it Hopes are rising of a breakthrough in one of Africa's longest conflicts Bitcoin is 'not for me' but it's too 'arrogant' to say it won't have a future, Goldman Sachs CEO says High oil prices are a massive headache for India as economy gets 'pinched' The ECB has lost its independence in the wake of the debt crisis, a former member claims The ‘crypto sculpture’ and how hyped things have become Asian economies have a lot to lose in a US-China trade war CEO explains why his Australian company just announced 8,000 job cuts European stocks seen higher amid rising trade war fears; OPEC in focus White House says China's 'economic aggression' is a global threat The inspiration for tech titan Jack Ma's Alibaba was an unlikely politician Microsoft's Nadella: Trump administration policy separating children from families is 'abhorrent' A major cryptocurrency exchange says it was hacked and $30 million in coins was stolen Canada approves recreational use of marijuana Lapses at many levels of bank led to India's huge PNB fraud, internal report shows Australia's largest telco says it will cut 8,000 jobs over the next three years China-based hacking campaign is said to have breached satellite, defense companies Kim Jong Un and China's Xi discuss 'a new future,' North Korean media says Worst isn't over for General Electric, predicts ex-GE transportation CEO Asian shares set for mixed open after trade fears spook markets worldwide Cramer: Tesla's stock still has more upside—just use the right chart Cramer points to the trillion-dollar question about US-China trade: What about Apple? Elon Musk: If I can help kids at the border, I will SNAP CEO on Innovation and Imitation Oracle reports strong fourth quarter results and stock edges up Start-up that uses polymer science to make avocados last longer just scored a deal with Costco Here's a map of every Whole Foods where you'll get an Amazon Prime discount The CEO of agency giant IPG welcomes challengers to Facebook and Google: 'The more the merrier' Traders bet one soaring tech stock is about to lose steam Facebook takes another shot at grabbing social media stars from YouTube UK says it is happy with Rupert Murdoch's Sky News commitments related to bid for parent company Apple CEO Tim Cook says separating immigrant children at US border is 'inhumane' In the short history of Trump trade conflicts, it has paid to buy the market dip Danny Meyer stands by cashless push: 'We're unaware of any federal law' that requires accepting cash Express Scripts boots another online pharmacy — CareZone — from its network Home Depot and two other Dow stocks look ripe for a buy, says technician Snap shares plunge after analyst says users are less engaged White House's Navarro on China trade talks: No knowledge of Apple iPhone exemption Merkel, Macron agree on euro zone budget Walgreens and Humana are partnering to create senior health hubs Sarepta Therapeutics shares soar 50% on positive preliminary results for muscular dystrophy gene therapy Verizon pledges to stop some selling of phone-location data There's one Dow stock having a great day: Verizon Europe's IPO market heats up, and unicorns are getting in line Amazon wants a hand in all your deliveries, unveils last-step option for FedEx, UPS and private mail Soybean prices drop to two-year low on US-China trade war fears Cramer: US-China trade fight 'is not serious' right now; Trump has upper hand China has a limited number of weapons to use in a trade war with the US Laws governing medical marijuana could soon be relaxed in the UK The flip phone is about to make a big comeback as foldable screen nears reality Here is what a student could have made if they invested their 2014 summer earnings in FANG stocks VW names interim Audi boss, seeking to steady brand after its CEO's arrest Here’s the fundamental error in Trump’s trade strategy Chip stocks dive on trade war fears as industry gets a majority of its revenue from China New home construction booms to a near 11-year high in May A dangerous dot-com era phenomenon is back and it's going to inflict pain, Jim Paulsen warns Netflix gets a $500 price target, the highest on Wall Street

Currency

Richard Thaler’s work demonstrates why economics is hard

RICHARD THALER has won the Nobel prize in economic sciences this year for his contributions to behavioural economics. It’s a well-deserved prize and a clarifying one, as far as economics is concerned. For a very long time, economists hoped to treat individuals a bit like particles in physics, whose activity can be described by a few well-understood rules, which allow researchers to model and understand complex interactions between particles. The rules, they reckoned, were things like perfect information, forward-looking reasoning and rationality. Of course economists understood that individuals didn’t always behave according to those rules, but the idea was that, in aggregate, the rules would allow for a pretty good approximation of reality.

Then came the behavioural economists, who made it their task to find ways in which human activity systematically diverges from models using those basic assumptions. For many of them, the goal was probably to come up with an alternative set of principles describing human behaviour, so that economists could get back to the job of modeling the economy. That new set of principles never really emerged, just a bunch of behavioural oddities. As this week’s Free exchange column notes, one of the big achievements of the behavioural revolution has been to get economists as a whole to back away a bit from grand theorising, and to focus more on empirical work and specific policy questions.

  • The middle-income spread

  • Why gene drives may never eradicate diseases or pests

  • Scott Pruitt signs a measure to repeal the Clean Power Plan

  • The Catalan leader puts independence on hold for talks

  • Richard Thaler wins the Nobel prize for economic sciences

  • When investors get stuck in the past

Along the way, behavioural economics made some meaningful public-policy contributions; for instance, the way in which nudges can be used to help people save more or use less energy. Nudges probably won’t save the world, but whenever economists manage to deliver an actual improvement in real-world policy we should celebrate it. In some ways, however, behavioural economics is underappreciated: as in the way it reveals how difficult it is to understand all the factors affecting human behaviour—well enough, at least, to have a hope of explaining it.

I’ll give you an example. In one of Mr Thaler’s famous experiments—the “dictator game” undertaken with Daniel Kahneman and Jack Knetsch—one player (the dictator) is given $20 and told that he can split the sum evenly between himself and another student or keep $18, leaving the other player with $2. A rational utility-maximiser would be expected to keep as much of the money as possible. The authors found, however, that the vast majority of students chose the even split: strong evidence that concerns about things such as fairness can be as important in human decision-taking as cold rationality. That, alone, is a pretty striking challenge to economics-as-usual.

The experiment was subsequently repeated and replicated many times, often using slightly different formulations. One particular version, conducted by John List, turned up a fascinating result. If you expand the options available to the dictator to include taking money from the other player, then few participants opt to share the money with the other player—though, importantly, neither do most players exercise their ability to take from the other.

What does that tell us? It means that fairness concerns matter a great deal. But it also tells us that people are constantly looking for social and institutional cues as to what the socially acceptable courses of action are. Present someone with a circumstance in which a very selfish individual could take money from another participant, and the player adjusts his ideas about what sort of behaviour counts as fair. Behavioural decisions are not made independent of the setting; worse, even seemingly fundamental notions of fairness shift depending on the situation.

It’s a simple lesson but one which massively complicates the work of economists. Perhaps we can understand how people behave within a particular market. But that understanding does not necessarily mean we have learned something fundamental about human behaviour, because the choices people make within the market reflect their evolving beliefs about what constitutes appropriate behaviour within that narrow setting. A different setting, with different cues, leads to different behaviour. And even in one particular market slight tweaks to the environment will affect people’s judgments about what they should and should not do.

It is as if economists are working to understand the strategies people play within a game. But it is a game in which every player is constantly updating his ideas about the rules and even the objectives in response to what every other player is doing. It’s a vitally important job that economists have set themselves. But it truly is a dismally frustrating one.

NextThe Nobel in economics rewards a pioneer of “nudges”

Source: economist
Richard Thaler’s work demonstrates why economics is hard

Comments are closed.