Homepage / Currency / Richard Thaler’s work demonstrates why economics is hard
Bond market flashing warning sign even as stocks rally to new highs Mohawk Tribe sues Microsoft, Amazon for patent infringement Bitcoin plunges nearly 9% on fears of greater oversight from US regulators US 10-year yield flashes possible warning: Dallas Fed's Kaplan Chinese fintech company Qudian spikes more than 40 percent in IPO 'The housing market can't take the shock of a natural event,' real estate economist warns The Apple Watch is finally taking off, says analyst By selling now, investors risk missing an additional 'melt-up' in the market Amazon's next big bet is letting you communicate without a smartphone, says Alexa's chief scientist Cramer: IBM is not a Warren Buffett story anymore but about 'reignition of earnings' IBM sees biggest jump in 8 years after earnings beat Rising seas threaten nearly $1 trillion worth of US homes, says Zillow Germany's Hochtief confirms $20 billion bid for Spain's Abertis Amazon's $13.7 billion bet on online grocery ordering hasn't convinced shoppers to stay home The same federal lawmakers who regulate Amazon are wooing the company in the race for HQ2 OPEC reportedly favors 9-month extension to output cut deal in bid to boost oil prices Stephen Curry’s new shoe will spark an Under Armour turnaround: Analyst Apple and GE are writing software to help detect when jet engines could fail Merck shares jump after Citi upgrade on stronger cancer drug sales US investors should get some international exposure Elon Musk is 'fixated on Mars' but Bezos and I want space to better Earth, says Richard Branson Hurricanes Harvey and Irma drive housing starts down to a one-year low When the revolution eats itself Stocks making the biggest moves premarket: CVX, MGM, ANTM, IBM, CREE, AMZN & more Hillary Clinton says US threats of war with North Korea are 'dangerous' and 'short-sighted' Twitter’s new user rules crack down on nudity and 'unwanted sexual advances' The only thing scary about the Dow is that nothing seems to scare it Economist lays out a ‘concerning’ trend for Apple stock 1 billion users could be using 5G by 2023 with China set to dominate, study says The big question for US cities: Is Amazon’s HQ2 worth the price? Google and Goldman Sachs are two of the most active investors in blockchain firms Iraq calls on BP to 'quickly' develop disputed oilfields after seizing areas of Kirkuk Amazon, eBay accused of ‘profiting’ from tax fraud in UK JPMorgan buys fintech start-up WePay WhatsApp is blocked in China and VPNs are being hit as the Communist Party Congress begins Xi Jinping makes big promises for China's economic future Akzo Nobel issues profit warning after third-quarter earnings miss Boeing says Bombardier jets could still face hefty duties even if they are assembled in Alabama European shares expected to open on a positive note as earnings season picks up the pace InterContinental is bringing two new hotel brands to Asia India's troubled banks desperately need more money — but government help just isn't coming An upcoming fintech IPO is set to be 2017's largest Chinese listing in the US Amazon has brought benefits—and disruption—to Seattle Mobileye: Without safety standards self-driving cars risk being an 'expensive science experiment' Chinese President Xi Jinping touts successes of socialism at Communist Party Congress Former Tesla factory workers allege racial harassment in new lawsuit Crypto venture firm Blockchain Capital is raising $150 million for two funds Asia markets to keep an eye on China's Party Congress as dollar firms Cramer Remix: The big problem that triggered Netflix’s decline A.I. company CEO: Big data is not a visualization problem, it's a human scale problem Cramer pushes back against 'peak earnings' theory with 4 cheap stocks This family bet it all on bitcoin IBM set to report earnings after the bell Magic Leap gets another $502 million in funding for its mysterious product Here are 4 top software stock ideas from Cowen Alphabet says Sidewalk Labs unit will build a model urban district in Toronto Don't doubt Elon Musk, says astronaut who spent a year in space Traders bet on obscure e-commerce stock in speculation over bitcoin's blockchain technology Billionaire Mark Cuban on running for President in 2020: ‘If I was single, I would do it. For sure’ Facebook executive Regina Dugan leaves experimental hardware group after 18 months Tech's 'winner take all' system is making valuations spike, says NYU professor Market-beating value investor Bill Nygren on why he's bullish on Netflix, General Electric Biggest risk to Netflix is a $7-per-month Amazon streaming service, analyst Mark Mahaney says Not every Wall Street analyst is gaga over Netflix Rally continues, but 'this is kind of how bull markets end,' Bank of America strategist says Fund managers bet on rising interest rates but not on tax-cut boost for stocks A track record of success: The 5 stocks that have crushed it year after year Tesla employees detail how they were fired, claim dismissals were not performance-related Volvo unveils Polestar 1 electric sports coupe, its bid to take on Tesla Why Google is terrified about Alexa, and what it's doing in response ChargePoint hires Uber EMEA policy chief as its top Europe exec Analyst says ‘nobody can compete’ with Tesla in China Microsoft's big new Windows 10 update rolls out today, here's what's new Cramer: Analysts wonder whether Netflix's strong growth can last Mexico's tech industry is booming as Trump's anti-immigration stance pushes workers abroad Economic optimism drives stockmarket highs Homebuilder confidence jumps to 6-month high in October GM's Cruise will test self-driving cars in New York in 2018 Google just unveiled its first custom smartphone chip that helps you take better pictures Netflix's Reed Hastings joins Forbes list of rich Americans for the first time This former Soviet nation plans to launch its own cryptocurrency Google is rolling out advanced Gmail security for government officials and journalists Wall Street gushes over Netflix, says it has reached ‘escape velocity’ Google Maps is discontinuing a feature that converted walking directions to calories Google's new Pixel phones are kind of boring and you can get more for your money elsewhere Microsoft is rolling out a bunch of new PCs, including a laptop with a charge that lasts 17 hours Goldman: Bet against GE, dividend cut is coming Garmin’s Speak puts Alexa-powered navigation in your car Trump may open US wallet for debt-ridden NATO ally Greece at urgent time Stocks making the biggest moves premarket: UNH, MS, JNJ, HOG, CMA, NFLX & more Trump's fortune drops to $3.1 billion, ties Snap's Evan Spiegel on new Forbes 400 rich list Goldman sees US-Iran tensions presenting long-term threat to global oil supply Bitcoin is a 'speculative bubble' and unlikely to become a real currency, UBS says More airlines are offering free Wi-Fi for messaging services Bad news for the bulls: There are now more bulls Boeing versus Bombardier: Here’s what happens next Morgan Stanley shares jump to 9-year high after earnings beat the Street on strong wealth management Theme park owner sees its shares tank after warning that terrorism is hitting profits Snap teams with NBCUniversal in drive for TV shows on Snapchat Hillary Clinton says she will 'not run again' for president but will continue to call out Trump

Currency

Richard Thaler’s work demonstrates why economics is hard

RICHARD THALER has won the Nobel prize in economic sciences this year for his contributions to behavioural economics. It’s a well-deserved prize and a clarifying one, as far as economics is concerned. For a very long time, economists hoped to treat individuals a bit like particles in physics, whose activity can be described by a few well-understood rules, which allow researchers to model and understand complex interactions between particles. The rules, they reckoned, were things like perfect information, forward-looking reasoning and rationality. Of course economists understood that individuals didn’t always behave according to those rules, but the idea was that, in aggregate, the rules would allow for a pretty good approximation of reality.

Then came the behavioural economists, who made it their task to find ways in which human activity systematically diverges from models using those basic assumptions. For many of them, the goal was probably to come up with an alternative set of principles describing human behaviour, so that economists could get back to the job of modeling the economy. That new set of principles never really emerged, just a bunch of behavioural oddities. As this week’s Free exchange column notes, one of the big achievements of the behavioural revolution has been to get economists as a whole to back away a bit from grand theorising, and to focus more on empirical work and specific policy questions.

  • The middle-income spread

  • Why gene drives may never eradicate diseases or pests

  • Scott Pruitt signs a measure to repeal the Clean Power Plan

  • The Catalan leader puts independence on hold for talks

  • Richard Thaler wins the Nobel prize for economic sciences

  • When investors get stuck in the past

Along the way, behavioural economics made some meaningful public-policy contributions; for instance, the way in which nudges can be used to help people save more or use less energy. Nudges probably won’t save the world, but whenever economists manage to deliver an actual improvement in real-world policy we should celebrate it. In some ways, however, behavioural economics is underappreciated: as in the way it reveals how difficult it is to understand all the factors affecting human behaviour—well enough, at least, to have a hope of explaining it.

I’ll give you an example. In one of Mr Thaler’s famous experiments—the “dictator game” undertaken with Daniel Kahneman and Jack Knetsch—one player (the dictator) is given $20 and told that he can split the sum evenly between himself and another student or keep $18, leaving the other player with $2. A rational utility-maximiser would be expected to keep as much of the money as possible. The authors found, however, that the vast majority of students chose the even split: strong evidence that concerns about things such as fairness can be as important in human decision-taking as cold rationality. That, alone, is a pretty striking challenge to economics-as-usual.

The experiment was subsequently repeated and replicated many times, often using slightly different formulations. One particular version, conducted by John List, turned up a fascinating result. If you expand the options available to the dictator to include taking money from the other player, then few participants opt to share the money with the other player—though, importantly, neither do most players exercise their ability to take from the other.

What does that tell us? It means that fairness concerns matter a great deal. But it also tells us that people are constantly looking for social and institutional cues as to what the socially acceptable courses of action are. Present someone with a circumstance in which a very selfish individual could take money from another participant, and the player adjusts his ideas about what sort of behaviour counts as fair. Behavioural decisions are not made independent of the setting; worse, even seemingly fundamental notions of fairness shift depending on the situation.

It’s a simple lesson but one which massively complicates the work of economists. Perhaps we can understand how people behave within a particular market. But that understanding does not necessarily mean we have learned something fundamental about human behaviour, because the choices people make within the market reflect their evolving beliefs about what constitutes appropriate behaviour within that narrow setting. A different setting, with different cues, leads to different behaviour. And even in one particular market slight tweaks to the environment will affect people’s judgments about what they should and should not do.

It is as if economists are working to understand the strategies people play within a game. But it is a game in which every player is constantly updating his ideas about the rules and even the objectives in response to what every other player is doing. It’s a vitally important job that economists have set themselves. But it truly is a dismally frustrating one.

NextThe Nobel in economics rewards a pioneer of “nudges”

Source: economist
Richard Thaler’s work demonstrates why economics is hard

Comments are closed.