Homepage / Technology / What Russia's Facebook war didn't do
Facebook takes another shot at grabbing social media stars from YouTube UK says it is happy with Rupert Murdoch's Sky News commitments related to bid for parent company Apple CEO Tim Cook says separating immigrant children at US border is 'inhumane' In the short history of Trump trade conflicts, it has paid to buy the market dip Danny Meyer stands by cashless push: 'We're unaware of any federal law' that requires accepting cash Express Scripts boots another online pharmacy — CareZone — from its network Home Depot and two other Dow stocks look ripe for a buy, says technician Snap shares plunge after analyst says users are less engaged White House's Navarro on China trade talks: No knowledge of Apple iPhone exemption Merkel, Macron agree on euro zone budget Walgreens and Humana are partnering to create senior health hubs Sarepta Therapeutics shares soar 50% on positive preliminary results for muscular dystrophy gene therapy Verizon pledges to stop some selling of phone-location data There's one Dow stock having a great day: Verizon Europe's IPO market heats up, and unicorns are getting in line Amazon wants a hand in all your deliveries, unveils last-step option for FedEx, UPS and private mail Soybean prices drop to two-year low on US-China trade war fears Cramer: US-China trade fight 'is not serious' right now; Trump has upper hand China has a limited number of weapons to use in a trade war with the US Laws governing medical marijuana could soon be relaxed in the UK The flip phone is about to make a big comeback as foldable screen nears reality Here is what a student could have made if they invested their 2014 summer earnings in FANG stocks VW names interim Audi boss, seeking to steady brand after its CEO's arrest Here’s the fundamental error in Trump’s trade strategy Chip stocks dive on trade war fears as industry gets a majority of its revenue from China New home construction booms to a near 11-year high in May A dangerous dot-com era phenomenon is back and it's going to inflict pain, Jim Paulsen warns Netflix gets a $500 price target, the highest on Wall Street Apple is the big tech firm most at risk from a US-China trade war AT&T promises fewer ads, tailored programming after merger with Time Warner Stocks making the biggest moves premarket: VZ, TSLA, AAPL, WFC, T, SIRI & more Billionaire Howard Marks: Computers won't put the best human investors out of business CVS introduces prescription drug delivery as it braces for Amazon's possible entry Former turnaround exec Bozoma Saint John: Uber was 'the poster child for everything gone wrong' Trump told Tim Cook that US would not place tariffs on iPhones, but Apple's still worried Amazon's Alexa will now be your butler at Marriott hotels Billionaire investor Jim Mellon: Sharp sell-off in US stocks is the start of a 'very major correction' South Africa will avoid a ‘knee-jerk’ reaction to currency weakness, central bank deputy says Dow futures tumble as China responds to latest Trump threat North Korea's Kim visits Beijing as South Korea and the US halt military drills 'Belligerent' US trade stance could hurt America's iconic companies the most, Jim O'Neill says Irish central banker says it's too early for the ECB to discuss future rate hikes All global currencies will become cryptocurrencies, Circle CEO says Abu Dhabi Financial Group unit offers to buy Abraaj's investment management arm Beijing subways could get facial recognition and palm scanning tech, Chinese media reports Roche agrees to pay $2.4 billion to buy the rest of Foundation Medicine Japanese e-commerce company Mercari surges more than 70% in Tokyo debut European markets seen sharply lower as Trump threatens new tariffs China's central bank delivers surprise stimulus as trade spat with US worsens Shares of China's ZTE sink 23% after US Senate targets company in new bill Has a US-China trade war begun? Experts weigh in North Korean leader Kim Jong Un is in China on a two-day visit: Chinese state media China pledges it will fight back firmly if Trump goes ahead and publishes list of additional tariffs Trump reportedly told Apple's Tim Cook that iPhones will be spared from China tariffs Smartphone maker Xiaomi to postpone mainland China listing until after Hong Kong IPO Asian shares poised to edge higher despite trade jitters; oil prices rise Senate passes military funding bill that would reimpose sanctions on Chinese telecom ZTE Cramer Remix: Tariff headlines have investors flocking to these stocks Cramer's warning on recent tech IPOs: Be careful with their sky-high valuations Elon Musk sends company email about 'extensive and damaging sabotage' by employee Elon Musk sent an email to Tesla employees about another fire in its factory on Sunday Microsoft condemns 'forcible separation' of children from families after criticism of work with ICE Snap CEO Evan Spiegel says even his wife, Miranda Kerr, hated the app’s redesign UBS CEO: Blockchain technology almost a must have for business Bitcoin jumps after New York approves Square's Cash app for crypto trading Apple is worried about Chinese tariff retaliation that could hamstring its supply chain Elon Musk tells shorts on Twitter they have 3 weeks to cover Watch these drones string power lines along poles high above the ground SurveyMonkey confidentially files for IPO President Trump signs space junk directive aimed at cleaning up the cosmos Dropbox rises more than 8% adding to last week's gains President Trump directs Defense Department to 'immediately begin the process' of establishing 'Space Force' as sixth military branch Elon Musk hung out in the Netscape lobby in the '90s hoping to get a job Square gets regulatory green light for cryptocurrency trading in New York Domo drops below billion-dollar valuation in lead-up to IPO Russia cuts Treasury holdings in half as foreigners start losing appetite for US debt With Twitch, Amazon tightens its grip on live streams of video games This fitness app wants you to have a personal trainer in your pocket Intel shares fall after small Wall Street firm downgrades chipmaker, predicting slower growth Rent-A-Center shares surge 22% in single day on buyout Snap CEO Evan Spiegel on Facebook imitations: 'The innovators win in the long run' Amazon to add over 1,000 jobs in Ireland in country's biggest staff boost this year Supreme Court mulls Apple's App Store commissions in antitrust case JP Morgan says buy Micron into earnings due to ‘robust’ cloud computing spending Germany's Merkel given two weeks to reach EU deal on migrants Disney is expected to add cash to its bid for Twenty-First Century Fox assets: Sources How to play rising interest rates based on your age Microsoft acquires education start-up Flipgrid in latest challenge to Google BJ's Wholesale expects its IPO to price at $15 to $17 a share Don't even think about investing without a diversification strategy: Advisor Boeing sell-off looks like the beginning of a correction, technical analyst says Mass facial recognition boom led by the Chinese government will mean big money for Nvidia, UBS says Goldman Sachs still sees oil rallying over $80 despite market concerns over key OPEC meeting Disney shares downgraded to sell on concern the battle for Fox has placed company in an unwinnable situation Chipmaker Mellanox nears truce with activist investor Starboard over board seats Rates are on the rise, but don’t fear for the stock market — yet We’re seeing the greatest asset inflation bubble in 20 years, fund manager warns Apple will automatically share a user's location with emergency services when they call 911 Investors still love equities but ‘market fragility’ could be ahead in the second half of 2018 Munich prosecutors say Audi CEO arrested on risk he may suppress evidence

Technology

What Russia's Facebook war didn't do

For those Democrats waiting for some evidence that will prove the Russians stole the 2016 presidential election, it’s not much but better than nothing: The revelations that Russian agents ran hundreds of fake Facebook accounts trafficking divisive stories as well as similar activity on other platforms such as Google and LinkedIn give us some idea about how a hostile foreign power run by a dictator thinks it can manipulate American public opinion. The fake accounts posted inflammatory stories, pictures, and videos that, in the words of the New York Times’ deep dive into the matter, “harvested American rage to reshape U.S. politics.”

That seems to back up a narrative of Russian responsibility for Trump‘s victory even if it does nothing to show collusion with the GOP. But those looking to this as an excuse for Hillary Clinton’s loss are deluding themselves.

There’s nothing particularly new about Russian efforts to sow dissension inside the United States and other democracies, but it is nonetheless disturbing to learn about the mix of sophistication and crudity in Moscow’s efforts. Yet this story doesn’t do much to back up the idea that a coherent Russian conspiracy of some sort aiming at electing Trump was a major factor in the outcome. Vladimir Putin may have preferred Trump to Hillary Clinton as his American protagonist. But what we now know about the Russian campaign is that it was not only far more diffuse than a mere pro-Trump effort but that their efforts were also merely a faint echo of broader trends that were being far more successfully exploited by Americans.

More from National Review:
The legal resistance to President Trump
Flag protests and the power of symbols
The grave-hunter, hunted

Outrage over a foreign power’s engaging in such activities is entirely justified. But in order to believe that it was the Russians who were, as the Times claims, reshaping American politics, you’d have to ignore the fact that Trump was sowing dissension with divisive statements and taking advantage of existing cultural and political fault lines in American society long before the Russians were investing in Facebook accounts.

The first problem with the notion of the Facebook accounts’ constituting proof of a stolen election is that not all of what was being promoted on them was aimed at helping Trump. As the Times reports, some of the material was devoted to exposing discriminatory treatment of American Muslims, a topic that would, in theory, make voters more inclined to back Hillary Clinton or at least to despise Trump.

This is a crucial point because it shows that what the Russians did in 2016 was more or less in line with tactics they’ve been using since the Kremlin was run by Communists rather than an autocrat like Putin. The common denominator in all of the Russian posts — whether aimed at whipping up resentment on the right or the left — was to discredit Western democracy. The Russian/Soviet intention was never so much to favor one candidate over the other — though prior to 2016, they certainly preferred, as a general rule, Democrats to Republicans. Their main goal was to undermine the idea that representative democracy was inherently superior to their own tyrannical system.

Russian accounts were happy to fuel all sorts of anger, no matter what its source or target, so long as it promoted the notion that American democracy was a fraud. That’s the same pattern their destabilization efforts have followed whether ordered by Soviet bureaucrats or Putin’s underlings in democracies across the globe.

Yet this behavior never generated much interest from the mainstream media prior to the Trump–Clinton matchup.

Part of the explanation for this stems from the recent rise of social media as a pervasive force in American society. The Russians were always trying to persuade Americans that their own country was a terrible place, but the Internet and social media provide the sort of widely accessible forums that make it easier to peddle lies and fake news on a mass scale.

But just as important is the fact that the American Left and the liberal media never felt particularly threatened by Russian destabilization campaigns until Trump arrived on the national scene. Four years earlier, Democrats chortled heartily when President Obama mocked Mitt Romney in their foreign-policy debate for describing Russia as the chief geostrategic foe of the United States. That year, it was Obama who told Putin underling Dmitri Medvedev in a hot mic moment that he should tell “Vladimir” that he (Obama) would have “more flexibility” to accommodate his demands after he got re-elected. That’s exactly the kind of quid pro quo smoking gun Democrats would take as proof of collusion between Trump and Putin. But it didn’t bother them when it was Obama doing the colluding.

The real question to ask about this story is what exactly the Russians were doing to expose the seamy side of American politics that wasn’t already being done by Republican and Democratic operatives, not to mention the presidential candidates? Trump and everyone else dragging the 2016 election into the sewer needed no lessons in divisiveness from Russians who were merely recycling popular memes and sometimes doing so without properly translating them into English. That the Russians figured out how to use Facebook to promote their goals isn’t shocking. But the claim that these ads altered the results of the election to any degree is shocking because they were no better or worse than the flood of negative attacks that was already deluging Americans.

Social media helps exacerbate the bifurcated nature of American society since most users insulate themselves from those with different beliefs and loyalties. That’s why it’s not clear that the Russian ads reached many people who weren’t already receptive to those messages.

Americans should prod their government to take measures to better monitor foreign interference in the future. But, as with everything else we’ve learned about the 2016 campaign, there’s still no reason to believe liberal conspiracy theories about a stolen election or to even think the troubling Russian efforts were actually effective in aiding Trump. Democrats looking for reasons to explain his victory other than Trump’s ability to reflect the discontent of the voters and Hillary Clinton’s lack of credibility are doing the country and themselves a disservice.

Commentary by Jonathan S. Tobin, an opinion editor of JNS.org and a contributor at National Review. Follow him on Twitter @jonathans_tobin.

For more insight from CNBC contributors, follow @CNBCopinion on Twitter.

©2017 National Review. Used with permission.

Source: Tech CNBC
What Russia's Facebook war didn't do

Comments are closed.