Homepage / Currency / Trump wants to reproduce Reagan's tax reform win, but he's missing all the key ingredients
States are so eager to win Amazon's HQ2 they're offering the company as much as $7 billion A new bill would require Facebook and Google to publicly archive ads purchased around elections A scientific breakthrough offers hope for an AIDS vaccine One of the hottest smart home start-ups in Silicon Valley was just acquired A new Tencent game lets users virtually clap for a leader of the Chinese communist party Verizon meets earnings expectations and beats Wall Street's forecast for revenue Elon Musk says his second tunnel digging machine for The Boring Company is 'almost ready' Private jets are getting cheaper Cryptocurrencies like bitcoin are not 'mature' enough to regulate, ECB chief Mario Draghi says Companies that burn up $1bn a year are sexy, dangerous, and statistically doomed Viral Chinese video game measures which players can clap fastest for President Xi Jinping On NAFTA, America, Canada and Mexico are miles apart Spain to suspend Catalonia's autonomy after regional leader fails to drop independence bid Bitcoin is not the new gold, Goldman Sachs says New Zealand Labour to form next government with support of small nationalist party Here are the best cities to claim your pension — but all fall short of a relaxing retirement Unilever blames poor weather for slowing growth Want to learn about fintech? There's a course for that Backroom battle imperils $230 million cryptocurrency venture LSE CEO Rolet to step down by end of 2018 Roche third-quarter sales beat forecasts with boost from new multiple sclerosis medicine London is the European hotspot for venture capitalists when it comes to fintech SAP third-quarter growth slows with dip in cloud subscriptions Europe set for mixed open as investors look to earnings, Catalonia deadline China's central bank is warning about a sudden collapse in asset prices China's central bank governor says he's likely to retire soon This ex-Googler is bringing self-driving excavators to construction sites India's high-flying start-ups are getting a dose of harsh reality Here comes Chinese GDP data at a pivotal time for the country MongoDB will raise $192 million in IPO, making it worth $1.2 billion Asia markets await China data after Dow closes above 23,000 for the first time Blue Apron layoffs hit office hardest, warehouse workers mostly spared, say sources Lawmakers urge US to craft targeted sanctions on Myanmar military Cramer Remix: Johnson & Johnson is out of battleground territory Cramer: Facebook's latest acquisition is a 'terrific insurance bet' against Snap Firm says it was wrong about Snap and slashes key estimate in half — but still no 'sell' rating IBM will get a strong tailwind from the weak dollar, CFO Martin Schroeter says Cramer sees great buying opportunities in 'Washington's shenanigans' Bids for Amazon's second headquarters are due Thursday – here are all the cities in the running Blue Apron cuts 6 percent of its workforce Amazon is spreading itself thin and getting into the ‘danger zone,’ analyst says Adobe shares jump more than 5 percent on 2018 profit forecast Snap's newest product is a 'dancing hot dog' costume Wall Street veterans are trickling into digital asset management State pension funds continue to fall behind. Here's how much you owe Senators are pushing to curb election meddling on social media Here are 4 top chip stock ideas for the next year: Barclays Russians used Facebook Messenger to interfere with election, top executive says Samsung is playing catch-up with Apple's Siri and the Google Assistant The federal lawmakers who regulate Amazon are begging the company to move to their home states Warren Buffett just made nearly $800 million in IBM, a stock he doesn’t even like that much The 2017 chart of the stock market looks 'eerily similar' to the one that crashed 30 years ago Google's AI subsidiary made a game-playing program that's entirely self-taught Xi sees US retreating on world stage and seeks to fill void as 'most powerful' Chinese leader in 45 years Tech companies are suddenly spending much more on lobbying as NAFTA negotiations loom Shares of IBM just did something they haven’t done in 15 years 'It's very hard not to give tax cuts to the wealthy,' Steven Mnuchin now says Bond market flashing warning sign even as stocks rally to new highs Mohawk Tribe sues Microsoft, Amazon for patent infringement Bitcoin plunges nearly 9% on fears of greater oversight from US regulators US 10-year yield flashes possible warning: Dallas Fed's Kaplan Chinese fintech company Qudian spikes more than 40 percent in IPO 'The housing market can't take the shock of a natural event,' real estate economist warns The Apple Watch is finally taking off, says analyst By selling now, investors risk missing an additional 'melt-up' in the market Amazon's next big bet is letting you communicate without a smartphone, says Alexa's chief scientist Cramer: IBM is not a Warren Buffett story anymore but about 'reignition of earnings' IBM sees biggest jump in 8 years after earnings beat Rising seas threaten nearly $1 trillion worth of US homes, says Zillow Germany's Hochtief confirms $20 billion bid for Spain's Abertis Amazon's $13.7 billion bet on online grocery ordering hasn't convinced shoppers to stay home The same federal lawmakers who regulate Amazon are wooing the company in the race for HQ2 OPEC reportedly favors 9-month extension to output cut deal in bid to boost oil prices Stephen Curry’s new shoe will spark an Under Armour turnaround: Analyst Apple and GE are writing software to help detect when jet engines could fail Merck shares jump after Citi upgrade on stronger cancer drug sales US investors should get some international exposure Elon Musk is 'fixated on Mars' but Bezos and I want space to better Earth, says Richard Branson Hurricanes Harvey and Irma drive housing starts down to a one-year low When the revolution eats itself Stocks making the biggest moves premarket: CVX, MGM, ANTM, IBM, CREE, AMZN & more Hillary Clinton says US threats of war with North Korea are 'dangerous' and 'short-sighted' Twitter’s new user rules crack down on nudity and 'unwanted sexual advances' The only thing scary about the Dow is that nothing seems to scare it Economist lays out a ‘concerning’ trend for Apple stock 1 billion users could be using 5G by 2023 with China set to dominate, study says The big question for US cities: Is Amazon’s HQ2 worth the price? Google and Goldman Sachs are two of the most active investors in blockchain firms Iraq calls on BP to 'quickly' develop disputed oilfields after seizing areas of Kirkuk Amazon, eBay accused of ‘profiting’ from tax fraud in UK JPMorgan buys fintech start-up WePay WhatsApp is blocked in China and VPNs are being hit as the Communist Party Congress begins Xi Jinping makes big promises for China's economic future Akzo Nobel issues profit warning after third-quarter earnings miss Boeing says Bombardier jets could still face hefty duties even if they are assembled in Alabama European shares expected to open on a positive note as earnings season picks up the pace InterContinental is bringing two new hotel brands to Asia India's troubled banks desperately need more money — but government help just isn't coming An upcoming fintech IPO is set to be 2017's largest Chinese listing in the US Amazon has brought benefits—and disruption—to Seattle

Currency

Trump wants to reproduce Reagan's tax reform win, but he's missing all the key ingredients

Tax reform is never easy, which is why it hasn’t happened since 1986. But it’s harder in 2017 for two fundamental reasons.

The political foundation for the current GOP effort is weaker than it was three decades ago. And so is the economic foundation.

In 1986, President Ronald Reagan governed with an approval rating of at least 60 percent, a Republican Senate and a Democratic House. He needed bipartisan support and got it, because proponents such as Democratic Sen. Bill Bradley and Republican Rep. Jack Kemp had paved the way with years of advocacy.

They produced genuine tax reform, designed to raise the same amount of money without widening budget deficits. It reflected broad consensus among economists that lower tax rates, applied to a broader tax base, would make the economy grow more efficiently.

The law they enacted also had guaranteed crowdpleasers for American voters. It cut taxes on individuals, while raising them an equivalent amount on corporations. It taxed laborers at lower rates than shareholders.

Today’s push by the Trump White House and GOP-controlled Congress enjoys none of those advantages. That helps explain why Goldman Sachs analysts put the chances that it will collapse at 1 in 3, “and recent developments lean slightly further in that direction.”

President Donald Trump suffers from sub-40 percent approval ratings. GOP leaders seek to pass their plan with only Republican votes, even as the party wages fierce internal battles. They don’t seek compromise with Democrats.

As Trump repeatedly proclaims, the GOP tax framework so far resembles a straightforward tax cut more than tax reform. It would slash government revenues just as millions of baby boomers enroll in Social Security and Medicare, which Trump vows not to cut, pointing to the need for more revenue.

A Tax Policy Center analysis shows it would actually raise taxes on individuals overall, while cutting them dramatically on businesses and the wealthiest Americans. It would tax individuals at a far higher top rate (35 percent) than corporations (20 percent).

That defies public opinion. A recent NBC News/Wall Street Journal poll shows solid majorities favoring higher taxes on corporations and the rich.

Republicans enjoy more public support for arguments about growth. In the NBC/WSJ poll, 54 percent say tax cuts would encourage corporations to expand and create jobs.

Yet the administration’s optimistic projections — on growth, deficits, and business investment — draw nothing close to consensus support among economists.

Top Trump advisor Kevin Hassett argues the plan would sustain a boost to economic growth of “much more than 1 percent.” That matches claims by Trump that he can produce annual growth of 3 percent or more, up from current 2 percent projections.

Other forecasters find that improbably rosy. Goldman Sachs, the former employer of Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin and National Economic Council Director Gary Cohn, projects a growth boost of no more than 0.2 percent in the next two years, and less after that.

The Penn-Wharton forecasting model, directed by former George W. Bush administration economist Kent Smetters, projected that an earlier outline of the GOP plan would actually reduce long-term growth. That’s because of adverse effects from the higher deficits it would create.

Mnuchin insists tax cuts would stimulate sufficient growth to more than replace potential revenue losses — shrinking deficits rather than increasing them. That level of “dynamic scoring” conflicts with mainstream economists in both parties.

Columbia’s Glenn Hubbard and Harvard’s Greg Mankiw, both of whom advised the elder Bush, say growth can recoup 25 percent to 30 percent of individual rate cuts and 50 percent of corporate rate cuts. The Republican-led Senate’s planned budget resolution contemplates a tax cut that could increase the deficit by $1.5 trillion over 10 years.

The Tax Policy Center calculates that the top 1 percent of earners would receive 80 percent of all benefits from the GOP plan through provisions reducing the top rate, ending the alternative minimum tax and abolishing the estate tax, among others.

Cohn maintains that the wealthy won’t benefit at all.

That’s partly because the administration contends lower corporate taxes benefit workers most of all. Some Republican economists, such as Hubbard and Mankiw, agree that corporate taxes cost workers more in lost wages and jobs than corporate shareholders in lost profits.

But other economists dispute that view. Jane Gravelle of the Congressional Research Service recently concluded workers bear 40 percent or less of the corporate tax burden.

In 2012, career Treasury economists calculated that workers bear about a fifth of the burden. The Trump administration recently removed that analysis, which undercuts its argument, from the Treasury website.

Hassett contends provisions for repatriating corporate profits held overseas will benefit American workers by increasing domestic investment and wages. His argument is vulnerable on two counts.

One is current conditions. Companies already have plenty of domestically held cash and access to low-interest-rate borrowing. That casts doubt on whether sluggish corporate investment now has much to do with profits “stranded” overseas.

The other is recent history. A 2004 repatriation “holiday” increased payouts to shareholders rather than investment. At least one Bush administration veteran expects the same this time.

“In the short run, it would likely be more about accounting and profit-taking,” Smetters predicted.

He believes a well-designed repatriation plan could have big long-run benefits. But the current GOP proposal, he added, “does not create a real long-term plan.”

Economists ultimately concluded the 1986 tax reform made the economy more efficient, but had little effect on overall growth. Lawrence Summers, Treasury secretary under President Bill Clinton, says loopholes it closed helped subsequent 1991 and 1993 tax increases reduce budget deficits.

When Clinton sought the 1993 tax increase, Republicans warned it would kill jobs and tip the economy into recession. That did not happen.

Source: cnbc economy
Trump wants to reproduce Reagan's tax reform win, but he's missing all the key ingredients

Comments are closed.