Homepage / Currency / The hedge-fund delusion that grips pension-fund managers
Cramer: I believe former Trump advisor Gary Cohn 'would've liked' this trade framework Critics say big tech is 'mostly useless' —but here's some tech that has changed my life drastically As Google falls under renewed criticism, Treasury Secretary Mnuchin says 'you have to look at the power they have' Hot stock Micron surging again after chipmaker raises its guidance due to ‘healthy’ semiconductor industry Here's why your computer has a mouse, according to Steve Jobs in 1985 These tech stocks — including Skyworks, Qualcomm — have the most to gain on a US-China trade truce US-China trade agreements are ‘face-saving’ and ‘lose-lose,’ says Moody’s chief economist Investors seem to forget that markets can and will go down. It's called risk amnesia Snap shares rise after prominent bearish analyst says the worst may be over Apple shares to struggle over the next 12 months on weak iPhone X demand, Instinet says Zuckerberg's meeting with EU officials will now be livestreamed following criticism As consumer staples get slammed, one name looks primed for a breakout, Piper Jaffray says China reportedly considers scrapping two-child limit per family Tesla shares to soar more than 80% on strong Model 3 profitability: Analyst US likely to slap tough oil sanctions on Venezuela — and that's a 'game changer' for Maduro Stocks making the biggest moves premarket: GOOGL, GE, MBFI, TSLA, FOXA & more Google seems to have removed most mentions of ‘Don’t be evil’ from its code of conduct Deadly virus identified as a potential epidemic kills nine in India This is the impact the Italian populist government could have on the euro As the payment wars heat up, PayPal could have a leg above Square FCC is investigating a website flaw that exposed mobile phone locations Microsoft buys a start-up that wants A.I. to make conversation with humans Malaysia sets up new 1MDB criminal taskforce The EU’s support for the Iran deal is ‘not sufficient,’ Tehran says London is a 'laundromat' for Russia's dirty money, UK report warns Be careful if China cuts you a check, says former US trade official Ryanair CEO says some airlines will not 'survive' the winter due to elevated oil prices China-style state-led growth won't work in Africa, former Nigeria finance minister warns Italy's next prime minister could be a mostly unknown law professor European markets seen higher as trade war concerns ease The Fed is an open book, but foreign trade and security are the wild cards Everything you need to know about a new EU data law called GDPR One in five 'initial coin offerings' may be frauds — but investors are bullish on them anyway China's space ambitions continue with reported launch of satellite to explore far side of the moon US-China trade developments are in focus for Asia markets The 2018 Hyundai Elantra GT Sport is a bargain hatchback that lacks performance How to record the screen on your Mac Tips from pro gamers on mastering Fortnite, the hottest game on the internet South Korea's LG Group chairman dies from illness at 73 South Korea, US to work closely on summit after Pyongyang's about-face EU could compensate firms hit by US sanctions over Iran – French minister Elon Musk teases new specifications for Tesla's embattled Model 3, calling it 'amazing' Virtual reality is finally ready for normal people, and the $200 Facebook Oculus Go is your ticket Social media was supposed to 'bring the world closer together.' Instead it's making us pettier A royal wedding, in pictures: Britain's Prince Harry marries Meghan Markle Tech investors take a Warren Buffett approach to raising money for blood cancer research Germany uses its past to try and police hate speech on Facebook Inside the training camp where Google shares its A.I. secrets with Alphabet-invested companies A longtime Google investor drew a simple chart on a napkin to explain everything in health tech Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey: Here are some surprising facts about the billionaire China lands bomber on South China Sea island for first time Prince Harry, Meghan Markle wed in Windsor as millions watch ISS sides against two Tesla directors, backs split of Musk's roles China says opening up of financial sector will need reciprocity iPhone app makers are forming a 'union' to demand improvements from Apple That Facebook royal wedding quiz? It could put you at risk for identity theft Banks will trade cryptocurrency sooner than people think, says fmr. JPMorgan blockchain executive Square stumbles into the banking business Amazon briefly hit session low after report that Trump pushed the USPS to double shipping rates Former Microsoft executive Qi Lu steps down as Baidu COO Netflix is reportedly turning the Michael Lewis book 'Flash Boys' into a movie Dell remains focused on a VMware merger, and now it's getting feedback from tracking stock holders CBS fight is 'the beginning of the end' of dual-share structures, says former NBCUniversal CEO Emerging markets are trading in correction territory — but some call the stocks a buy Bitcoin rally this week fails to materialize as New York conference brings more hype than substance Boeing’s antics at the World Trade Organisation risk a trade war Commodities are posting their best returns in a decade and Goldman thinks there's more to come US reportedly cancels B-52 bomber exercise with South Korea amid threats from North Korea Semiconductor company NXP jumps on report Qualcomm deal is 'looking more optimistic' Cell phones thrown in the trash are exploding, causing 5-alarm fires in garbage trucks Israel keeps Gazans ‘caged in a toxic slum,’ UN human rights chief says Netflix will nearly triple its subscriber base to 360 million by 2030: Bank of America Shares of Applied Materials, barometer for chip industry, drop the most in 9 years An ETF that made a big winning bet on bitcoin has now sold most of it David Tepper gets US approval to take activist stance on Allergan, if he wants it Putin, Merkel discuss U.S. withdrawal from Iran nuclear deal Putin favours status quo with new government lineup Grammy-winning Fugees founder bringing blockchain to your smartphone Square slips the day after PayPal-iZettle merger announcement Spotify subscribers to double to 150 million by 2020, Raymond James predicts Why PayPal bought a European start-up with IPO plans for $2.2 billion Amazon’s growing India business alone is likely worth more than all of Macy's Stocks making the biggest moves premarket: DE, CPB, AMAT, MAT, JWN, UAL, PYPL & more Energy stocks are on their longest winning streak in 12 years, and there's more room to run Cambridge Analytica files for bankruptcy in US following Facebook debacle Italy’s incoming government wants to lift Russia sanctions and rewrite EU rules AMD, Nvidia shares jump after Cowen says shares to soar on new growth markets Vietnam trade ministry says formally launched investigation into Uber-Grab merger Prince Charles to walk Meghan down the aisle at royal wedding Uber chief product officer to leave in latest executive departure Elon Musk says a ride on the Boring Company's tunnels beneath Los Angeles will cost $1 Ex-Russian spy Sergei Skripal discharged from UK hospital Egypt's Sisi orders Gaza border opened for Ramadan A floating Pacific island is in the works with its own government, cryptocurrency and 300 houses A ‘double whammy’ is staring Asian markets in the face this year China says it hasn't offered Trump a $200 billion trade surplus cut Bill Gates: Trump asked me the difference between HIV and HPV If it's America First, then Europe will respond in kind, German minister says AstraZeneca hit by falling Crestor sales, higher costs How Malaysia's new government could test ties with Singapore

Currency

The hedge-fund delusion that grips pension-fund managers

HEDGE-FUND managers may be feeling quietly smug about their performance in 2017. They returned 6.5% on average, according to Hedge Fund Research, a data provider, their best year since 2013.

But those returns do not really suggest that they are masters of the investing universe. The S&P 500 index, America’s main equity benchmark, returned 21.8%, including dividends, last year. More tellingly, a portfolio split 60-40 between the S&P 500 and a mixture of government and corporate bonds (an oft-used benchmark for institutional portfolios) would have returned 14.8%. Last year was the fifth in a row when hedge funds underperformed the 60/40 split (see chart).

  • Are programs better than people at predicting reoffending?

  • How gender is (mis)represented in economics textbooks

  • Sri Lanka’s president is struggling to keep his promises of reform

  • Chechnya moves to silence Oyub Titiev, a courageous critic

  • The Bayeux tapestry is an intriguing symbol of post-Brexit co-operation

  • The rise and fall of bitcoin

That ought to be a salutary lesson for those institutions who think that backing hedge funds is the answer to their prayers. Despite the highs recorded by stockmarkets, many employers are struggling to fund their final-salary pension promises. In 2016 the average American public-sector plan was just 68%-funded, according to the Centre for Retirement Research at Boston College. In the private sector, multi-employer pension plans, covering workers in industries like mining and transport, have liabilities of $67.3bn and assets of just $2.2bn. Worse still, the insurance scheme established to back those schemes is on course to run out of money by 2025, according to the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation.

It is hard to cut workers’ benefits and painful to increase contributions. Schemes hope to square the circle by earning a high return from their assets; 7.5% is a common target. But bond yields are very low and equities are trading at very high valuations by historical standards. The temptation is to turn to “alternative assets”—a category that includes property, private equity and hedge funds.

The first two offer a genuine alternative. Property generates a stream of rental income and the hope that capital values will keep pace with inflation. Private equity is, in part, a bet that unquoted firms can generate higher returns than listed ones because they have more freedom to invest for the long term.

But what about hedge funds? A lot of funds specialise in equities or corporate bonds—the same assets that institutions own already. In some other categories, such as macro funds or merger arbitrage, returns are entirely dependent on the manager’s skill. Recent years do not suggest that hedge-fund managers display enough skill, on average, to offset their high fees.

Clients may think they will be able to pick the best hedge-fund managers, not the average ones. But one group of professionals—fund-of-fund managers—tries to do just that. They did manage to pip the average asset-weighted return of hedge funds in 2017, but failed to do so in any of the previous four years. If the experts cannot manage to pick the winners, why should a pension fund or endowment be able to manage the feat?

Another justification for placing money with hedge funds is that they are less likely to lose lots of money in a downturn. That argument was somewhat dented in 2008, when the average hedge fund lost 19%. In any case, pension funds and endowments are investing for the long term; they ought not to be that bothered by short-term volatility.

The Centre for Retirement Research conducted a study* of the effect of investing in alternative-asset categories on state and local-government pension-plan returns in the 2005-15 period. It found that schemes that placed an extra 10% of their portfolio in private equity and property had marginally increased the return on their portfolios (by around a sixth of a percentage point). But investing in commodities or hedge funds had reduced returns, with the latter knocking half a percentage point off the total.

Some investors have seen the light. CalPERS, a public-pension fund in California, announced that it was pulling out of hedge funds in 2014. But Preqin, an information provider, estimated last year that pension funds accounted for 42% of all money flowing into the global hedge-fund industry. North America provided the bulk of the money, with 776 pension schemes investing from that region alone.

Who knows what those schemes are trying to achieve? A few of them may be lucky enough to pick the best performers in the industry. But if they think, in aggregate, that their strategy will reduce their funding deficits, then they are suffering from a delusion.

 

* “A First Look at Alternative Investments and Public Pensions” by Jean-Pierre Aubry, Anqi Chen and Alicia Munnell, July 2017

Source: economist
The hedge-fund delusion that grips pension-fund managers

Comments are closed.