Homepage / Technology / Meet the man whose job it is to reassure people that Google search isn’t evil
Asian stocks poised for slightly softer open as markets await China data Elon Musk courts new controversy after tweeting, then deleting, an attack on a British cave explorer How a former eBay employee is inspiring kids to become tomorrow's problem solvers Here's what the DOJ needs to happen to win its appeal against AT&T The 2018 Hyundai Tucson is a good bargain crossover but skip the high-end model Trump suggests US and UK could strike a 'tremendous' trade deal after Brexit PlayVS wants to bring electronic sports gaming into high schools The unintentional winners of Prime Day: Amazon’s competitors Elon Musk insists he's neither Democrat nor Republican, as political contributions come under fire Amazon could make a big impact in health by helping people eat better Even without a GPS, here's why mobile phones are 'the best spying device you can imagine' How the Bee Gees plan to stay alive in the era of digital music Verizon, AT&T, Sprint and T-Mobile say they have unlimited data plans, but here's the fine print Elon Musk has a new interest group that could be added to his list of enemies: Cabbies Uber's troubled culture persists, as sensitivity 'blind spots' raise new questions Top VC Deals: Uber and Alphabet backed Lime, Larry Page invests in personal aircraft company Tesla rolled out a new attendance policy for hourly workers this month — read it here Elon Musk: Whatever pain Tesla factory workers felt, 'I wanted mine to be worse' Facebook, Google and Twitter will testify next week at a House Judiciary hearing on content moderation In ETFs, the bigger the stock, the more money goes into it and that could be costing regular investors Ex-Labor secretary: Cash handouts 'may seem like a pipe dream' but could be 'inevitable' Cisco, networking stocks drop on a report Amazon Web Services is developing its own network devices Microsoft's president says the government needs to step up regulation of face recognition technology Facebook admits it's not adding enough minority engineers, says the problem may lie with its roots The 2018 Cadillac ATS-V is one of the best sports sedans you can buy There’s one media stock that’s outperforming Netflix Trump's SCOTUS nominee thinks ISPs have First Amendment rights, which could hurt privacy laws The bond market is sounding an alarm on the economy as 'yield curve' spread hits narrowest in 11 years on Friday India execs raise concerns about potential trade war with US Watch out, retailers. This is just how big Amazon is becoming Jefferies raises Facebook price target, sees revenue topping expectations An Amazon Prime Day for health care? Here's what experts say it could look like Can money buy success at the World Cup? Children and PTSD: Health risks linger long after acute psychological trauma ends Netflix faces major risk heading into earnings, money manager says Morgan Stanley raises its price target on red hot WWE stock by nearly 70% to Street-high Trump walks back Brexit threat: 'Whatever you do is OK with us' 4,500 tech workers, 1 mission: get Democrats elected Watch: Trump holds news conference with UK Prime Minister Theresa May after he attacked Brexit plan Goldman Sachs says cybersecurity stocks could get a boost from fears of meddling in the midterm elections AT&T's Randall Stephenson says chances of a successful DOJ appeal are 'remote': 'This changes nothing' PNC shares gain after higher commercial lending leads to better-than-expected earnings report Amazon just hit a new high, and one trader sees more to come Stocks making the biggest moves premarket: JPM, DIS, BLK, T, JNJ, MCD & more Deutsche Bank warns Netflix may miss second-quarter subscriber expectations Wells Fargo shares fall after second-quarter revenue misses estimates Trump’s dream to meet the queen makes this trip a victory, former White House aide says In this earnings season, a volatile stew of expectations London mayor says the UK is not afraid to call out Trump: ‘We think you’re wrong’ ‘Trump Baby’ balloon takes flight in central London amid protests Even May's UK opponents are backing her against Trump Theresa May had a plan in place for Brexit. Then Donald Trump landed Jack Dorsey loses 200,000 followers on Twitter after fake user purge Trump to have tea with the queen at Windsor Castle The US is trying to nail down terms with Pyongyang, while 'South Koreans aren't wasting time' Trump is likely to ask Putin for help with his North Korea problem European markets seen higher amid global trade war fears; Trump visits the UK History shows the US-UK special relationship is increasingly one-sided New tariffs threatened by the US would be more harmful to China than the first batch, says bank CEO Chinese imports fall short of expectations, while exports top estimates China says both its imports and exports with the US rose in the first half of the year Asian stocks extend gains amid relief over lack of trade escalation, tracking US rally Nvidia and Netflix produced top shareholder returns over past five years, BCG study shows Apple announces $300 million clean energy fund in China Broadcom has a new strategy after failing to buy Qualcomm: Roll up enterprise software companies Justice Department appeals Time Warner-AT&T merger approval Women in private Facebook group for cancer gene carriers found marketers could get their names How to avoid overshopping on the longest Amazon Prime Day yet Microsoft challenges Slack with a free tier for Teams Amazon, Xealth working on pilot program to deliver products to patients after hospital discharge Trump's tariffs are unlikely to cause a recession because they are leaving the most important part of the economy alone There are a lot of misconceptions about browsing the web in 'incognito' mode, researchers say How an obscure British rule — the 'chain principle' is changing Comcast's strategy for Fox and Sky Netflix just beat out HBO in Emmy nods, snapping HBO's 18-year streak John McCain blasts Trump’s NATO performance and warns that 'Putin is America’s enemy' Two Dow stocks to buy and one to fade in a volatile market Uber will let riders pay with a Venmo balance Cramer: Pizza execs say Papa John’s is ‘falling apart’ when compared with Domino’s This 23-year-old founded a company with self-driving car tech that's giving Tesla some competition NBA Commissioner Silver ‘rooting’ for Disney in the battle against Comcast for Fox L Brands tumbles after weak sales at 'broken' brand Victoria's Secret Law firms climb aboard the AI wagon A welcome upgrade to apprenticeships A Chinese music-video app is making WeChat sweat Development-impact bonds are costly, cumbersome—and good Big corporates’ quest to be hip is helping WeWork What the UK’s top politicians have said about Trump — and it's not always nice Kim Kardashian West and Warren Buffett agree that this is the best investment you can make Tesla factory workers reportedly drank Red Bull, walked through raw sewage to meet Model 3 quotas Amazon is 'the most robust and durable' among the FANG stocks, Canaccord says As Trump’s UK visit faces backlash, here are some of his most high-profile friends in the country Hackers are selling access to law firm secrets on dark web sites Mega-chip stock Broadcom loses $17 billion in value after Wall Street demolishes company's software acquisition strategy Trading app Robinhood adds two new cryptocurrencies despite bear market Apple just updated its MacBook Pro with new processors and better keyboards The UK government wants a 'new arrangement' for its banks after Brexit Consumer prices rise at the fastest pace in 6 years An under-the-radar defensive stock is quietly surging as safety plays make a comeback Twitter shares jump after Goldman Sachs says account purge good for business, raises price target Earnings will turn the market positive even after tariffs: Market analyst


Meet the man whose job it is to reassure people that Google search isn’t evil

The week Danny Sullivan started working at Google’s headquarters, he felt like someone was going to throw him off campus in Mountain View, California.

He noticed a handful of double takes as he walked around unattended and would half-jokingly start meetings by assuring other participants of his good intentions.

The bafflement arose because before he joined Google last October, he was an outsider who had written critical stories about the company for nearly two decades. As a journalist, his trips to the Googleplex campus would include a prominent visitors badge and a public-relations handler at his side.

“It all felt very strange,” Sullivan told CNBC of his early days inside the company.

When Sullivan announced he was joining Google as a “search liaison” late last year, only a few months after retiring from his reporting job, it surprised industry observers and other writers alike.

In hindsight, his appointment seems well-timed: In the months since Sullivan took on his role, the tech industry has faced increased scrutiny over how its algorithms affect the public. Critics have lambasted Google, YouTube, Facebook, and Twitter for exacerbating filter bubbles, serving consumers fake news or conspiracy theories, and failing to adequately support the creators they rely on.

Google’s search algorithms, in particular, have produced a string of high-profile mistakes in recent months. Part of Sullivan’s job is to explain those errors. He’s responsible for bridging the gap between Google’s engineers and the outside world and, ultimately, using feedback from both sides to make its systems work better.

“I’m really part of trying to improve search now — a direct part of it,” he said. “That’s the most rewarding thing.”

Sullivan is credited with popularizing the term “search engine marketing” and has been described as the father of the industry.

His search career started in the mid-90s, when Yahoo owned the space and Google didn’t even exist. Sullivan was enthralled by the emerging web and quit his job in newspapers to join a friend’s web development company. He wrote his first guide to search engines in 1996.

The next year, he founded his own content and conference business, Search Engine Watch. At the first search marketing conference ever, in 1999, he hosted Google’s relatively unknown co-founders, and Sergey Brin infamously said that the company didn’t believe in — or even need to deal with — webspam. (In the following decades, this idea would be thoroughly disproven.)

Sullivan sold Search Engine Watch and eventually co-founded Third Door Media in 2006, where he continued to track industry changes and try to demystify search through the publication Search Engine Land.

His extensive experiences describing the nuances of Google’s ranking algorithms turned him into one of the greatest outside experts on how the company’s search works.

So, when he announced in June 2017 that he had decided to take some time off, it caught the attention of company higher-ups.

Less than two months later, he got a call from Ben Gomes, Google’s vice president of search, asking him if he was really retired.

Gomes had a pitch, Sullivan recalls: The company wanted him to come onboard to help Google be more transparent and better communicate with the public about search. Sullivan told Gomes he needed some time to think it over — he’d been fantasizing about starting a “Star Wars” blog — but, ultimately, Google won him over.

“My favorite thing to write about search were the issues of it and how it impacts people,” Sullivan said. “This was a great opportunity to do the kinds of things that I would have done as a journalist, but in a different way, while seeing things from the inside.”

Almost immediately, Sullivan had some glaring search failures to account for.

In the wake of a tragic shooting in Sutherland Springs, Texas, in early November, Google highlighted wrong information about the suspect, prominently promoting tweets with dubious claims about his background.

Sullivan responded to the situation on Twitter, outlining how it happened and promising that Google was taking the issue seriously and testing changes to how it ranked tweets. He responded frankly to questions about hiring human editors, winning points with those accustomed to slow, boilerplate responses from Google.


Since that first test of his position, Sullivan has dealt with errors related to incorrect search content, incomplete answers on Google’s smart speaker and offensive autocomplete predictions. Most recently, a Google search showing Nazism as an ideology of the California Republican Party whipped up conservative fervor, with GOP leaders accusing the search giant of bias.

In most of these cases, the problem wasn’t only Google’s failure to provide accurate information but the public’s distrust of how the process works. A big part of Sullivan’s job is convincing people that Google’s errors are due to algorithmic mistakes instead of purposeful meddling by employees.

“My personal mission statement is to provide reasonable explanations as issues come up,” Sullivan said. “Not as an excuse but to help people understand why something happened. If something has gone wrong, we explain why it went wrong. Otherwise, people assume things that didn’t happen. It’s about taking ownership over an issue that comes up, understanding how we’re going to improve it, and then actually improving it.”

It doesn’t always work.

Sullivan tweets about Google through his personal account as well as from the Search Liaison brand and quickly learned that his explanations sometimes fall on deaf ears. He tries not to get frustrated when users dismiss his attempts or cling to rebukes about Google being evil or biased against certain groups.

“I always lean towards trying to engage and be proactive if I can,” he says. “In some cases, people are going to have their beliefs and you just can’t change them.”

In other cases, he has to deal with a peculiar reverse deja vu: As a journalist, he occasionally railed against the company for vagueness, but now that he has all the inside information, he has found that he can only say so much publicly.

One of his long-time colleagues, Barry Schwartz, says that the new boundary can be funny.

“I’ll say something about Google doing something wrong or not being as transparent as it should be, and he has to say ‘Trust me — I know what’s going on on the inside. We’re doing this for good reasons, but I can’t tell you more,'” Schwartz said. “Of course, he would have pushed the same way if he was in my shoes.”

Sullivan says that pushing is still a big part of his job. Because he works directly within the search organization, engineers and product managers will ask him for input. In turn, he prods those teams for more information about their decision-making.

Before he joined Google, for example, he was a vocal critic of Google’s “featured snippets,” the answers that often appear in a box at the top of search, calling for the company to limit the feature’s use. Now, he says he has “a better understanding internally why they’re important” but has also advocated for improvements, like showing multiple snippets or indicating when Google is serving a near-match instead of an exact answer.

Google knows that featured snippets will never be 100 percent perfect but has been trying these new ways to improve them, Sullivan said.

“Everyone wants to see progress,” he said. “The people who are bothered by an issue do and we do. No one wants to have the same problems come up over and over again.”

When Sullivan announced his appointment, the search marketing industry drew comparisons to Matt Cutts, an outspoken engineer who used to run Google’s webspam team. Before Cutts took a leave from Google in 2014, he was both revered and slammed for his updates about the search engine’s ever-changing algorithms. (Cutts left permanently in 2016.)

The parallel isn’t exact: Cutts had a technical background, focused closely on search engine optimization issues, and corresponded more with industry experts than the general public.

Still, Sullivan says he hopes to bring the same kind of human touch and calm voice that Cutts was known for; a salve for people who are used to dealing with attribution-less statements or faceless forums.

“The saying I like to use is, it’s easy to hate a faceless monolith, but it’s harder to hate a person,” Cutts told CNBC. “And putting a human face on search — someone that you can talk to, complain to, ask questions of — I think that is critical.”

Cutts and Sullivan have known each other for years — Sullivan actually made Cutts’ Twitter account for him in 2007 as part of an April Fools’ joke about a fictitious conference celebrating “Mattness” called CuttsCon. Cutts, who permanently left Google in late 2016, is now hopeful that Sullivan’s hire is a signal of Google’s willingness to take feedback and listen to users.

Paul Edmondson, CEO of HubPages, echoes that idea. HubPages, which sold to another content company earlier this year, was something of a poster child for how tweaks to Google’s search rankings could tank a business. Edmondson says he respected Sullivan’s work as a journalist and hopes to see him help shape Google’s future policies.

“I think Danny always wanted to hold Google accountable in the right ways,” Edmonson said. “I would gladly trade a journalist covering search for someone inside of Google who has empathy for people creating content for the web and who has the greater good of the ecosystem in mind.”

After all, as publishers cede power to tech platforms, Google gains it. The search engine has 90 percent worldwide search engine market share, according to StatCounter. Increasingly, its algorithms decide what news we get, businesses we visit and people we vote for. There’s been a growing call for “algorithmic accountability” as people demand more transparency about the “black box” systems shape their lives.

To Sullivan, one of the biggest issues ahead may be trying to ensure that people understand Google’s strengths, but also its weaknesses.

“We’re not a truth engine. One of the big issues that we’re pondering is how to explain that our role is to get you authoritative, good information, but that ultimately people have to process that information themselves,” he said. “We can give you information, but we can’t tell you the truth of a thing.”

Sullivan will probably write a post about that someday. But if he does, the trick will be getting people to believe it.

Source: Tech CNBC
Meet the man whose job it is to reassure people that Google search isn’t evil

Comments are closed.