Homepage / Technology / Universal basic income: A 'humane' idea whose time has come, or a $3 trillion black hole?
Bonver Casino Cz Hrací Automaty S Bonusem Zdarm Magazyn Żużel Speedway W Polsce I Na Świeci Zakłady Sportowe Online Autógrafo Bukmacherska 1xbe “Pin-up O Melhor Cassino Do Brasil Web Site Oficial ᐈ Jogar Caça-níquei Zakłady Sportowe Online Obstawiaj U Bukmachera Gg Be What Industries Use Virtual Data Room? Advantages of a Data Room What Does a Board Room Provider Do? Data Room Analysis for Venture Capital Funding The Importance of Board Reporting Software Safe Uploading and Downloading Business Files How to Select the Best Board Management Software How to Organize the Work of a Company “gerçek Parayla En Iyi Slot Makineleri Ve Spor Bahisler Which is the Best Podcast For Stock Market Beginners? Virtual Data Room Facts How to Protect Confidential Documents for Boards Advantages of Online Meetings Business Issues to Consider When Choosing a Data Room Provider What Is a Data Room? Virtual Board Room Software Due Diligence Risk Factors How to Choose a Reliable Tool for Data Exchange test Users535352253 Board Software and VDR Programs Business Operations Management Software Keep Data Safe and Protect Your Business Data How to Conduct a Board Self-Assessment Uncomplicated Ways to Simplify Daily Business Transactions Due Diligence Blog Digital Data Rooms for the Netherlands The New Era of Business Software and Reporting What Types of Businesses Use VDR Software? Ma Analysis Mistakes The Corporate Governance Role Board Room Apps Secure Board Management With Secure Board Portals What Happens at Board of Directors Meetings? Board Room Software Review How to Prepare Board Rooms for Effective Board Meetings Board Room Software Boosts Performance and Communication Selecting a Secure Data Room Review Local Data Room Service Review How to Find the Best Virtual Data Room Review What to Look for in a Data Room uk Provider Document Storage and Distribution Software Everything About VDRs Corporate Software Advantages How to Choose a Virtual Data Room Provider The Most Secure Way to Transfer Files How to Manage Online Board Meetings Benefits Virtual Data Room Solutions – Must-Haves for M&A and Due Diligence Best Data Room Functions for the Different Types of Industries How to Choose a VDR Software Provider How to Choose an Online Board Portal The Benefits of a Boardroom Review Board Room Online Solutions – How to Get the Most Out of Your Board Meetings Why You Need a Board Room How a Board Room Blog Can Transform Your Business Choosing the Best Board Room Format How to Have Productive and Engaging Board Directors Meetings Choosing the Right Virtual Data Room How to Keep Safe Documents Storage Teaching Kids About Online Safety Avoid Costly Mistakes With Free Data Room Services Corporate Virtual Data Unlimited Data Room Software For Due Diligence Leading Business Software Features to Look For Secure Online Data Rooms Solutions How to Keep Share, Edit and Delete Your Data Safe Virtual Data Room Software Secrets for M&A Due Diligence What to Look For in Boardroom Providers Board of Directors Blog Posts How to Deliver Value at Your Board Meetings How to Have Effective Board Meetings Responsibilities of Board Members Deal Management – How to Effectively Manage a Complex Sales Pipeline Data Rooms For Mergers And Acquisitions How to Have a Successful Board Room Meeting Choosing a Board Room Service Provider What is a Board Room Service? Board Room Software Review – Choosing the Best Portal for Mother Board Meetings Why a Board Room Providers Review Is Important What Is a Board Room Review? Venture Software for VC Firms What Is an Assessment Report? The Importance of a Tech Audit Popular Business Applications What to Look For in a Data Room App What Are Business Applications? How to Choose a Virtual Data Room How to Plan a Data Room Review Coronavirus Guide What is a Virtual Data Room? What Is Data Science? What Is an Operating System? Turbotax Small Business Review How Online VDRs Are Used in M&A Deals Why Choose VDR Software?

Technology

Universal basic income: A 'humane' idea whose time has come, or a $3 trillion black hole?

What if the federal government gave everyone a check, every month?

Tesla CEO Elon Musk and Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg are among those who say universal basic income, or UBI, is a good idea. With inequality widening, the idea of an unconditional, periodic cash payment that the government makes to everyone has suddenly become a hot topic.

The idea is whether a person is unemployed or wealthy, a $1,000 monthly government check could replace all current welfare programs, including Social Security.

“I think it would theoretically be superior to the existing social welfare system,” Michael Tanner, senior fellow at the Cato Institute, told CNBC’s “On The Money” in an interview. “It would be more efficient. It would be more humane and it would be a lot less paternalistic.”

The conversation about UBI has reached a crescendo as the workforce leans more heavily on technology. Nearly half of all U.S. jobs could be replaced by robots in the next decade or two, according to an Oxford University study.

Last November, Tesla’s Musk said there was “a pretty good chance we end up with a universal basic income, or something like that,” as a rising number of workers lose jobs due to automation.

UBI supporters say the cash from the government could fund basic needs, like food and housing, freeing people up to find new jobs in the digital economy.

“A lot of people when they first hear this idea really like it,” said Jason Furman, former chief economic advisor to President Obama. That is, until you read the fine print

“And then when you look at the details it turns out it just doesn’t work,” Furman explained to CNBC. “It costs two to three trillion dollars. You would need to double the current income tax to make it work.”

Furman, a professor at Harvard University’s Kennedy School of Government, added that “the premise underlying it is wrong too. There’s going to be a lot of automation but there’s also going to be a lot of jobs and our focus should be on making sure people can get those jobs not giving up. And universal basic income represents giving up in the face of that challenge.”

Yet Tanner took aim at the current social safety net. He argued the current “social welfare system spends nearly one trillion dollars a year fighting poverty, and it doesn’t do a very good job of enabling people to rise and get out of poverty and to be in control of their lives.”

He added: “Looking for some new alternative for that is not a bad idea.”

The debate has been heightened by Europe’s experiments in providing UBI to citizens, which have had mixed results. Those experiments have amplified calls to try a similar approach in the U.S.

“Our current system is certainly imperfect, I don’t want to be the defender of the status quo,” said Furman. He cited research where current government anti-welfare programs “that invest in children” providing food stamps, Medicaid and housing vouchers are successful and “increase their mobility.”

Yet Furman added that “it’s too simplistic to say, just write everyone a check, let’s spend trillions of dollars doing that, rather than doing the hard work of trying to get the (government) programs right.”

Tanner countered that it’s hard to determine which federal programs are effective and which aren’t. “We have over a hundred different welfare programs all with different rules and regulations. They’re overseen by dozens of different agencies. Simplifying, consolidating and moving to cash would make a great deal of difference I think.”

So might a UBI program work in America? “We don’t have a lot of wide scale evidence yet there are a number of ongoing experiments in places like Finland, the Netherlands and Canada,” Tanner acknowledged.

Still, Furman doesn’t see UBI or the “rise of the robots” as coming anytime soon.

“Maybe 50 or 100 years from now we have enough robots to make everything and they can just hand the proceeds over to us,” the academic said. “But I’m trying to think in the scale of the next 10, 20, 30 years, (robots) are not going to take our jobs on any time scale that I’m capable of envisioning.”

On the Money airs on CNBC Saturday at 5:30 am ET, or check listings for air times in local markets.

Source: Tech CNBC
Universal basic income: A 'humane' idea whose time has come, or a trillion black hole?

Comments are closed.