Homepage / Technology / Why the alt-right can’t build an alt-internet
Menyelami Dunia Slot Thailand: Keseruan dan Peluang Kemenangan Besar Menyelami Dunia Slot Thailand: Pengalaman Bermain yang Tak Terlupakan What is the easiest way to get sluts around me? VDcasino’ýn Slot Oyunlarýnda En Büyük ve Çarpýcý Gelirler VDcasino’ýn En Popüler ve Tercih Edilen Makineleri Making initial move: tips for approaching an asian girl How discover local mature sex partners Enjoy fun and flirty conversations along with other gay men 58 Jazz Musicians Were Photographed for Harlem 1958 ‘ Only One Remains. The New York Times Working with a cheating date | Futurescopes Zakłady Bukmacherskie Legalny Polski Bukmacher Online Free Slots No Download No Registration: Free Slot Machines Instant Play | page 12 Find your perfect match now TRIZ Wikipedia 7 Slots Kazanl lk Admlar! Basaribet’da Kazandýran ve Eðlenceli Slot Oyunlarý Basaribet: Kazanmanýn Yolu ve Eðlencesi olan Eþsiz Slot Oyunlarý Где дают займы на карту МИР: ТОП-25 лучших и проверенных МФО без отказа TOPLIST на DTF Compare Today’s Current Mortgage Rates تنزيل تطبيق 1xbet قم بتثبيت تطبيق 1xbet للهاتف المحمول best free online pokies real m_1736111834 Slot Receh Hari Ini Terbaik dan Terpercaya 2025: Gampang Menang dan Menguntungkan قم بتنزيل 1xbet على Android ، تطبيق جوال 1xbet Apk Canlı Bahis, Slot Oyunları Daftar Situs Slot Gacor Hari Ini Gampang Jackpot Maxwin Vulkan Vegas: Führende Spiele und Boni für deutsche Benutzer! Strategi Mengelola Bankroll Saat Bermain di Royale168 Pin-Up Gambling Establishment Review Video pornografi anak: ‘Orang tua korban’ ikut menyaksikan, kata polisi BBC News Indonesia Australian Casino Hellspin Assessment 7 Slots Kazanl lk Admlar! Online Kasyno Vavada Honey money casino промокод на ЯНВАРЬ 2025 100 FS без депозита Meet senior singles searching for love and companionship Redaktorların Sight Pin-up Casino Saytı 7 Slots Kazancnza Hemen Balayn! Meet asian older women whom share your interests Find your perfect match and enjoy a night of passion Evaluación de 1Win Casino Argentina Tüm Para Yatırma Güvenli Web Casino Bonusları Vulkan Vegas: Elite-Spiele und -Aktionen für deutsche Spieler! Casino Bonusy 2024: Největší Přehled Bonusů” Bahis Yaparken Daha Güvenli ve Karlı İşlemler Yapın En İyi Bahis Siteleri: Yüksek Kazanç Sağlayacak Oyunlar Find the perfect match tonight Ini 10 Hal yang Harus Anda Ketahui Tentang Judi Slot Matchmaking For Older People: Why Admiration Is Very Much Alive After 50 7 Resortů Sixth Is V Turecku Které Musíte Navštívit Daftar Joker123: Panduan Mudah Bergabung dan Menikmati Permainan Slot Online Terbaik Slot Depo: Solusi Transaksi Mudah untuk Bermain Slot Online Gambling in Australia: Online Gambling Enterprises and the Duty of the Australian Buck How discover a local single milf inside area “Casino Online Cz Nejlepší Bonusy & Free Of Charge Spiny Zdarma what exactly is bi dating and just why in case you test it? Asian Dating Guide: Things to Know and Tips in 2022 – RomanceScams.org Online Casino Video Games Play Now And Win Bi ABRAMAK Bilgi Teknolojileri 7 Items That Bi Poly Folks Can Connect With what’s a shemale hook up site? 1WIN зеркало рабочее на сегодня: вход на официальный сайт и личный кабинет БК 1ВИН Meet the perfect lonely housewife for you Slot Oyunlarında Deneme Bonusları ile Maksimum Kazanç The Benefits of Learning a Second Language Онлайн Казино Адмирал X Pin Up On Line Casino Oyna Türkiye, Pinup’un Resmi Web Sitesi 7 Slots’n Sunduu Byk Avantajlar! Canlı Bahislerde Anında Kazanç Sağlama Teknikleri Discover the joys of crossdressing dating Chiesa Bisa Bela Liverpool Usai Pulih dari Cedera, Arne Slot: Ada Syaratnya! Maturesforfuck analysis UPDATED 2023 | casino milyon1’ýn En Kazançlý ve Cazip Slot Oyunlarý Chat with japanese women – find your perfect match now Enjoy enjoyable & exciting online conversations Pin Way Up Turkey Online Casino Resmi Sitesi Giriş Ve Kayıt Pin-up Casino Resmi Internet Sitesi Online Casinoda Gerçek Parayla Oynayın İstanbul’da Yeni Üyelere Free Spin Veren En Popüler Siteler Sanal Kumar Oyunları Nasıl Oynanır Adım Adım Rehber ile Kazanma Şansınızı Artırın Could It Possibly Be Smart To Pick Up Girls On Facebook? | Dating Logic Free Tarot Analysis for Today Opening Your Future: The Power of Free Card Reading Open the Tricks of Your Future with Free Tarot Card Pull Name Numerology: Unlocking the Keys of Your Name Numerology Graph: Recognizing the Power of Numbers Opening the Mysteries of 7 Card Tarot Reading free of charge The Art of Online Tarot Card Pull: A Comprehensive Guide The Art of Picking a Tarot Card Card Exactly How to Check Out Tarot Cards: A Comprehensive Guide Open the Mysteries with Free Tarot Readings Online The Ultimate Guide to Biddy Tarot The Power of Free Tarot Card Card Reading Opening the Mysteries of Psychic Card Analysis Discovering the Globe of Free Tarot Readings Comprehending Psychic Analyses: A Comprehensive Overview The Power of Daily Tarot Card Reading Opening the Mysteries of Online Tarot Card Readings: A Comprehensive Guide The Intriguing World of Free Lotus Tarot Card Reading Choose 6 The Remarkable Globe of Online Tarot Card Gamings The Ultimate Guide to Tarot Card Cards Online Tarot Online Free: Opening the Mysteries of the Cards Numerology Calculator Free: A Comprehensive Overview Unlocking the Mysteries of 7 Card Tarot Analysis Free Lotus Deep Dive into Lotus Free Tarot: A Comprehensive Guide The Ultimate Guide to Online Tarot Decks

Technology

Why the alt-right can’t build an alt-internet

After the August 12th hate rally in Charlottesville, online platforms that have long tolerated or ignored white supremacists are very publicly kicking them off. The crackdown spans a broad range of sites and apps, some of which are household names, like Uber, Facebook, and Spotify. But some of the most notable companies to purge their ranks are those we don’t often consider: the web hosts, domain registrars, and other services that you need to put a website on the internet. Over the past week, GoDaddy, Cloudflare, and Google — to name a few — have been playing hot potato with the major neo-Nazi news site Daily Stormer, taking it offline several times as it’s moved around the internet.

After being booted from Namecheap over the weekend, the Daily Stormer’s status remains uncertain. But the white nationalist alt-right movement has experience running a “shadow economy” of sympathetic platforms, including crowdfunding sites like Rootbocks and social networks like Gab. Now, some have started discussing alternatives for basic web services too. Entrepreneur Pax Dickinson, a former Business Insider CTO who recently founded far-right crowdfunding site CounterFund, called for a “full-blown Amazon-style infrastructure company” amid the bans. But running a series of independent services that are immune to outside political pressure is far harder and less rewarding than replacing GoFundMe or Twitter. In 2017, is it possible to build what is essentially a functioning, effective, alternative internet?

One of the biggest pressure points for anti-racist activists right now is domain registrars like GoDaddy, which sell addresses that point web users toward a site. While anyone can hook up a server to the internet, domain name sales are regulated by the multinational organization ICANN, which hands off management of generic top-level domains (gTLDs) to organizations called registries. Registries can then sign contracts with ICANN-accredited registrars, which act as middlemen and sell domain names to the public.

More from The Verge:
Sonic Mania is good because it’s simple
This artist’s new landscape studies are of melting glaciers
The first Shenmue III trailer is here, and the characters look as deadpan as ever

If registrars refuse to serve a site, the seemingly obvious solution — which several people have mentioned online — is to found your own “free speech” registrar. However, obvious isn’t the same thing as practical.

Registrars need to be established companies that can demonstrate technical capability and financial stability. If they want to offer recognized domains extensions, they have to work with companies like Verisign, which controls the coveted .com TLD. Establishing a registry for a new TLD, meanwhile, is pretty much a non-starter right now: the last application period was in 2012, when applicants paid $185,000 just to be evaluated. The next application period is tentatively slated for 2020. “It’s not a situation where someone can just set up shop overnight and start selling domain names,” says Annemarie Bridy, a University of Idaho law school professor who recently published a paper on ICANN’s content regulation policies.

ICANN usually takes a hands-off approach to moderating registrars’ content, and some registrars play host to unsavory spam and malware domains. But even if an alt-right registrar could get accredited, it probably wouldn’t be a profitable business. M. Barry Branagh of the Spamhaus Project, which maintains a list of the most frequently abused services, says that spammers sometimes run their own registrars just to mass-generate domain names. Niche political content would be much less lucrative, and the vast majority of people — even ones with far-right sympathies — would have little reason to choose a small “free speech” registrar over more established alternatives. Even if such a registrar could ignore bad PR, activists could still lodge complaints with the registries, which ultimately control access to domains.

There are ways to bypass ICANN entirely. A site could use an alternative domain name system like Namecoin, for instance. It could advertise a numerical IP address rather than a link. The Daily Stormer set up shop on the free and decentralized Tor network, operating on the so-called dark web. But at that point, you’re not just independent, you’re effectively walled off from the normal internet. There are plenty of technological ways to run a shadow net, says Nathan Freitas, a fellow at Harvard’s Berkman Klein Center and leader of the open-source Guardian Project. “The question is, how willing is the audience to get to it? And is the point to allow their community to get to it, or the whole internet?”

Far-right sites and services want to be real alternatives to their mainstream counterparts, not just enclaves for true believers. After the Daily Stormer went down, founder Andrew Anglin gloated over the “massive amount of publicity” it had gotten. But that popularity is worth much more if it translates to people seeking out the Daily Stormer — and that can’t happen if they can’t find it. While supporters of the parallel economy predict that restrictive policies will drive people into the arms of “free speech”-friendly services, convenience is a powerful force.

Since Squarespace and other hosting services have started banning white supremacist sites, it’s also possible that we’ll see parallel companies running their own alternatives. And starting a web hosting service could certainly insulate sites from the kind of public pressure that’s taken the Daily Stormer offline.

But if the goal is immunity from all regulation, it’s very difficult to truly operate outside the law. The offshore data center HavenCo, for example, fell apart after technical problems and disputes with its hosts on the micronation of Sealand. And American copyright cops routinely police platforms located across the world, thanks to agreements with local governments.

Even if a far-right site were able to secure hosting, other layers of internet infrastructure can pose an existential threat. One of last week’s biggest surprises came when Cloudflare — a web services company known for never banning anything — dropped the Daily Stormer in a fit of pique. Among other things, Cloudflare offers protection against DDoS attacks, which hacktivists can use to batter a controversial site completely offline. Without Cloudflare’s support, the Daily Stormerwas periodically inaccessible even on the dark web.

There are ways to bypass ICANN entirely. A site could use an alternative domain name system like Namecoin, for instance. It could advertise a numerical IP address rather than a link. The Daily Stormer set up shop on the free and decentralized Tor network, operating on the so-called dark web. But at that point, you’re not just independent, you’re effectively walled off from the normal internet. There are plenty of technological ways to run a shadow net, says Nathan Freitas, a fellow at Harvard’s Berkman Klein Center and leader of the open-source Guardian Project. “The question is, how willing is the audience to get to it? And is the point to allow their community to get to it, or the whole internet?”

Far-right sites and services want to be real alternatives to their mainstream counterparts, not just enclaves for true believers. After the Daily Stormer went down, founder Andrew Anglin gloated over the “massive amount of publicity” it had gotten. But that popularity is worth much more if it translates to people seeking out the Daily Stormer — and that can’t happen if they can’t find it. While supporters of the parallel economy predict that restrictive policies will drive people into the arms of “free speech”-friendly services, convenience is a powerful force.

Since Squarespace and other hosting services have started banning white supremacist sites, it’s also possible that we’ll see parallel companies running their own alternatives. And starting a web hosting service could certainly insulate sites from the kind of public pressure that’s taken the Daily Stormer offline.

But if the goal is immunity from all regulation, it’s very difficult to truly operate outside the law. The offshore data center HavenCo, for example, fell apart after technical problems and disputes with its hosts on the micronation of Sealand. And American copyright cops routinely police platforms located across the world, thanks to agreements with local governments.

Even if a far-right site were able to secure hosting, other layers of internet infrastructure can pose an existential threat. One of last week’s biggest surprises came when Cloudflare — a web services company known for never banning anything — dropped the Daily Stormer in a fit of pique. Among other things, Cloudflare offers protection against DDoS attacks, which hacktivists can use to batter a controversial site completely offline. Without Cloudflare’s support, the Daily Stormerwas periodically inaccessible even on the dark web.

And just like there’s no independent ICANN, an upstart company — especially one that’s deliberately isolated and adversarial — would have trouble competing with providing the type of service that Cloudflare, or its similarly massive competitor like Akamai, can. “There’s a couple companies that have a scary amount of control over the internet,” says Freitas. “The more that [a site is] shunned by the big players, the less resistant they would be to DDoS.”

Currently, the Daily Stormer is using DDoS protection from the small startup BitMitigate. Hacker and site contributor Andrew “weev” Auernheimer also talked about building his own alternative to Cloudflare’s protective services, but it’s hard to evaluate how well that might work. Meanwhile, aggressive DDoS attacks are easy to spin up — and the alt-right has made a lot of enemies.

The effort necessary to create a parallel net would likely outweigh the benefit. Branagh points out that a more viable alternative may be to turn to small non-English-speaking domain registrars — or the managers of certain country-specific top-level domains — who would be largely immune to bad PR.

“At this point, it is now really difficult to be off on your own online,” says Molly Sauter, a Berkman Klein Center affiliate and author of The Coming Swarm: DDOS Actions, Hacktivism, and Civil Disobedience on the Internet. That’s good news for the people pressuring web companies to crack down on hate content. But for anyone who worries about internet monopolies and walled gardens, it could be a canary in a coal mine. “It’s hard for quote-unquote true social deviants, people who are really way out on the fringe, to maintain a solid presence. But it’s also really easy for a handful of large corporate hosting companies to sort of dictate what is happening.”

The EFF also expressed its own concerns about the Daily Stormer ban last week. In a piece titled “Fighting neo-Nazis and the future of free expression,” members warned that opening the door to regulating speech with the domain name system could create a new tool for oppressive regimes to take websites offline. It called for registrars to take a hard line against suspending site domains, and for other services to follow the Manila Principles, a framework of safeguards and transparency rules for web platforms.

Adopting these measures would make it easier for all groups, not just the alt-right, to secure a place within existing web infrastructure. It wouldn’t, however, make it easier to step outside that infrastructure — which may be why Daily Stormer founder Andrew Anglin recently calledfor the US government to regulate ICANN, saying that frankly, he did not have the option to create his own internet. “It’s very hard to roll your own stuff online,” says Sauter.

In an ideal world, Sauter would like to see a mechanism that would bring more real democracy — not just anarchy or corporate dominance — to the online world. For now, there’s really only one internet. In order to operate there, you’ve got to play by its rules. But after last week, those rules aren’t as clear as they once seemed.

Source: Tech CNBC
Why the alt-right can’t build an alt-internet

Comments are closed.