Homepage / Technology / Russian Twitter robots are blasting out angry NFL-national anthem messages, research shows
Лучшие тайтлы онлайн казино леон: топ новинок Meet other lesbianas and discover your perfect match Аркада Казино (Arkada Casino) Игровой Онлайн Клуб How To Locate The Very Best Transgender Online Dating Sites – Hookup Guide Find your perfect match: bi ladies seeking couples SLOT PULSA SITUS SLOT DEPOSIT PULSA 10 RIBU TANPA POTONGAN SEKALI SPIN MAXWIN Sports Betting Bet on Sports Online in South Africa Slot Entertainment Without Funding an Account in a Trusted Virtual Club Составление обзора казино в виртуальном формате Le Jeu en Ligne en France: Casinos en Ligne et leur Rфle dans l’Industrie Moderne des Jeux d’Argent Mostbet App A Convenient And Reliable Way To Place Bets Masjid Al-Huda Mranggen Demak Lemon Casino recenzja nowego polskiego kasyna Atrakcyjne bonusy i wysoki RTP! MostBet Bangladesh BD ᐉ Official Site Most Bet Casino and Sport Betting Lil Nas X calls out the BET Awards in his new single He has a point : NPR Most readily useful Adult Internet Dating Sites | FreeHookupsSites Unlocking the secrets of craigslist m4m green bay dating Just what comes in 66 sizes and vegan latex? Brand new generation of condoms | Sex | 8 Brands & Generics Human Growth Hormone HGH Injections Find local black hookups near you what’s ssbbw chat? About Japanese Dating society and also the west Guy who would like to Date a Japanese woman – MeetKing Blog 9 Guidelines On How To Hook-up On College Gameday (At Any College) Leading Live Casino Games Provider Leading Live Casino Games Provider Pin Up Slotlarýyla Eðlence ve Para Kazanma Bir Arada The core concept of digital entertainment hub AbeBet: signature points and groups Live-сессии с дилерами в онлайн-казино azino777 How Online Gambling Enterprises Operate Around the World Meet compatible single mothers and exchange ideas official site Play airplane online Ritalin: Jak legálně zakoupit bez receptu v České republice Connect with suitable asian singles in your area How-to Date A Pornstar While Making It Operate (The Ultimate Guide) Buy Bitcoin with Credit Card or Debit Card Instantly Buy Bitcoin How to buy BTC Finding trans girls near you – the simplest way to hookup Connect with like-minded singles on a mennonite dating website Assortment of in-demand games respected casino platform abe bet casino in cyberspace Connect with girls from round the world Alexander Gambling establishment: Dйcouvrez une Nouvelle Expйrience de Jeu en Ligne Le meilleur Extra casino en ligne pour jouer BLACK SEO LINKS, BACKLINKS, SOFTWARE FOR MASS BACKLINKING BLACK SEO LINKS, BACKLINKS, SOFTWARE FOR MASS BACKLINKING BLACK SEO LINKS, BACKLINKS, SOFTWARE FOR MASS BACKLINKING BLACK SEO LINKS, BACKLINKS, SOFTWARE FOR MASS BACKLINKING The simplest way to get a local hookup what’s millionairess dating? Get prepared to connect to latinas whom share your interests Estonian Chat place – an ideal Place for Dating Estonian Singles Join our bisexual chat room now and commence connecting Discover the advantages of dating a mature mom latina How to discover the best bbw hookup app for you Title: Juega en 1Win Casino Argentina Bonos y Apuestas 5 Best BBW Lesbian Dating Apps/Sites In 2022 Online Gambling Review submissions dia govt.nz Разыгрываемые джекпоты в виртуальном клубе Вулкан казино 30 Of The Greatest Adult Sex Toys For Males | Men’s Room Health Mag Australian Continent Cazino 7 slots cyberspace: conditions and rules for betting with real cash 1Win: ¡el mejor lugar de casino y apuestas deportivas de Argentina! Aufcasino Kde zakoupit Stromectol online: Kompletní průvodce ????Mature Dating Evaluation 2023 – Whatever You Need To Know About It! ???? Take the first step towards fulfilling your ebony lesbian bbw match now Ideas on how to come-out: Tips to keep in mind > Taimi Meet your perfect match – granny hookup site Türkiye-Çin İşbirliği Derinleşiyor GuGi Mobil Yükleme Seçenekleri Hizmet İçi Eğitim Sona Erdi Dooball tv ดูบอล ออนไลน์ สด 66 ลิงค์ บนมือถือ ฟรี ภาพชัด HD ทั่วโลก Find your rich cougar date in the most useful dating site Find your dream fat girl hookup today Slot Thailand Daftar Link Situs Slot Gacor Maxwin x500 Terbaru Hari Ini Resmi Auto Jackpot! Konsultasi ke Dewan Pers, Komisi I DPRD Jambi Pertanyakan Indeks Kemerdekaan Pers Jambi yang Turun Akses News Cerita Korban Judol di Balikpapan yang Nekat Gelapkan Uang How to get local horney women in your area 3 Cara Hapus Akun Judi Online Slot : Okezone Economy SITUS TOTO > Sering Kalah Main Di Situs Slot Gacor Terbaru Mudah Maxwin Situs Slot Gacor Maxwin Main Tanpa Pola Modal 5ribu Terbaik Melhores cassinos online de Novembro 2024: Confira o top 10! Enjoy amazing gay sex experiences using the top sites on the web Make the absolute most of one’s big butt dating adventure here 9 circumstances this means when a person avoids eye contact with a lady – Hack Spirit Top Greatest M4M Personals Sites in 2022 ◉ BLACK SEO LINKS, BACKLINKS, SOFTWARE FOR MASS BACKLINKING BLACK SEO LINKS, BACKLINKS, SOFTWARE FOR MASS BACKLINKING BLACK SEO LINKS, BACKLINKS, SOFTWARE FOR MASS BACKLINKING BLACK SEO LINKS, BACKLINKS, SOFTWARE FOR MASS BACKLINKING Лотерейные розыгрыши в kasino on-line Лев казино: условия осуществления и доступа Main features of playing in machines at online-club Karavan Connect with like-minded females making new friends Comment accéder à des jeux gratuits avec Space fortuna bonus ? PUCUK4D⭐ Bandar Toto Togel Online & Situs Toto 4d Terpercaya #1 Betting site Karavan bet Gates of Olympus internet-based: benefits of playing for real money Discover an environment of opportunities with lesbian and bisexual dating Aprovecha Los Códigos Promocionales De Bbrbet ¡más Bonos, Más Juegos 1xbet Giriş Yeni Adresi 2024 ⭐️ 1xbahis Güncel Adres » 1x Guess Mobil Casino How to get started with sext room BLACK SEO LINKS, BACKLINKS, SOFTWARE FOR MASS BACKLINKING BLACK SEO LINKS, BACKLINKS, SOFTWARE FOR MASS BACKLINKING BLACK SEO LINKS, BACKLINKS, SOFTWARE FOR MASS BACKLINKING

Technology

Russian Twitter robots are blasting out angry NFL-national anthem messages, research shows

After a weekend when Americans took to social media to debate President Trump’s admonishment of N.F.L. players who do not stand for the national anthem, a network of Twitter accounts suspected of links to Russia seized on both sides of the issue with hashtags such as #boycottnfl, #standforouranthem and #takeaknee.

As Twitter prepared to brief staff members of the Senate and House intelligence committees on Thursday for their investigation of Russian interference in the 2016 election, researchers from a public policy group have been following hundreds of accounts to track the continuing Russian operations to influence social media discourse and foment division in the United States.

For three weeks, a harsh spotlight has been trained on Facebook over its disclosure that Russians used fake pages and ads, designed to look like the work of American activists, to spread inflammatory messages during and since the presidential campaign.

But there is evidence that Twitter may have been used even more extensively than Facebook in the Russian influence campaign last year. In addition to Russia-linked Twitter accounts that posed as Americans, the platform was also used for large-scale automated messaging, using “bot” accounts to spread false stories and promote news articles about emails from Democratic operatives that had been obtained by Russian hackers.

Twitter has struggled for years to rein in the fake accounts overrunning its platform. Unlike Facebook, the service does not require its users to provide their real name (or at least a facsimile of one) and allows automated accounts — arguing that they are a useful tool for tasks such as customer service.

Beyond those restrictions, there is also an online black market for services that can allow for the creation of large numbers of Twitter bots, which can be controlled by a single person while still being difficult to distinguish from real accounts.

Since last month, researchers at the Alliance for Securing Democracy, a bipartisan initiative of the German Marshall Fund, a public policy research group in Washington, have been publicly tracking 600 Twitter accounts — human users and suspected bots alike — they have linked to Russian influence operations. Those were the accounts pushing the opposing messages on the N.F.L. and the national anthem.

Of 80 news stories promoted last week by those accounts, more than 25 percent “had a primary theme of anti-Americanism,” the researchers found. About 15 percent were critical of Hillary Clinton, falsely accusing her of funding left-wing antifa — short for anti-fascist — protesters, tying her to the lethal terrorist attack in Benghazi, Libya, in 2012 and discussing her daughter Chelsea’s use of Twitter. Eleven percent focused on wiretapping in the federal investigation into Paul Manafort, President Trump’s former campaign chairman, with most of them treated the news as a vindication for President Trump’s earlier wiretapping claims.

In the face of such public scrutiny, Twitter has said almost nothing about what it knows about Russia’s use of its platform. But Representative Adam Schiff of California, the top Democrat on the House Intelligence Committee, said he would like to know exactly what the company has done to find covert Russian activity and what it has discovered so far about fake accounts — including their reach and impact.

“I think right now the public is aware of only a subset of a subset of Russian activity online,” Mr. Schiff said in an interview. He said Facebook long denied that there had been Russian exploitation of its system, before reversing course on Sept. 6.

Mr. Schiff said the tech companies have asked for assistance from American intelligence agencies in trying to find and stop illicit interference from other countries, a request he said he supports.

The House Intelligence Committee announced on Wednesday that it would hold a public hearing on the matter of Russian influence next month, and a Senate aide said Facebook, Twitter and Google have been invited to testify at a Senate Intelligence Committee hearing on Nov. 1.

This month, The New York Times reported on evidence of Russian operators creating hundreds or thousands of fake Twitter accounts to flood the network with anti-Clinton messages during the campaign. The cybersecurity company FireEye identified what it called “warlists” of accounts linked to Russian intelligence that sometimes spewed messages like #WarAgainstDemocrats several times a minute.

Both DCLeaks and Guccifer 2.0, which spread the leaked emails and documents and were identified as having been created by Russian intelligence, used accounts that Twitter has not suspended, though they have been dormant for months. In some cases, the Russian exploitation of Facebook and Twitter was linked: “Heart of Texas,” a Facebook page advocating the secession of Texas that was identified as one of 470 fake profiles and pages linked to Russia, also had a Twitter feed — now suspended — called @itstimetosecede.

Experts on Russia inside and outside the government say President Vladimir V. Putin had multiple goals in last year’s campaign of hacking, leaking and stealth propaganda. He hoped to damage, if not defeat, Mrs. Clinton, whom he blamed for encouraging pro-democracy protests in Russia and neighboring states.

But Mr. Putin also sought to darken the image of the United States, making it a less attractive model for other countries and reducing its international influence, said Mark R. Jacobson, a Georgetown professor and co-author of a new report on Russian influence operations.

Last week, Facebook said it was turning over more than 3,000 Russia-linked ads to Congress. Many of those ads, like the opposing Twitter hashtags on the N.F.L. anthem issue, targeted divisions in American society by simultaneously sending conflicting messages to different users segmented by political and racial characteristics.

“What we see over and over again is that a lot of the messaging isn’t about politics, a specific politician, or political parties,” said Laura Rosenberger, director of the Alliance for Securing Democracy. “It’s about creating societal division, identifying divisive issues and fanning the flames.”

Her group’s web “dashboard” is called Hamilton 68. It is named for No. 68 of the Federalist Papers, believed to have been written by Alexander Hamilton, which warns of foreign meddling in American elections. The tool does not identify the activity of specific Twitter users but highlights the activity of the 600 accounts that researchers believe are either tied to the Russian government or repeat the themes of its propaganda.

For its part, Twitter has not said much about what it plans to say in the Congressional briefing.

“Twitter deeply respects the integrity of the election process, a cornerstone of all democracies, and will continue to strengthen our platform against bots and other forms of manipulation that violate our Terms of Service,” Twitter said in a statement.

Twitter has also said it was working to crack down on bots that distribute tweets en masse or that attempt to manipulate the platform’s trending topics.

Colin Crowell, Twitter’s vice president of public policy, government and philanthropy, said in a blog post in June that the company should not be an arbiter of whether a tweet is truthful or not.

Because Twitter is open and real-time, he said the platform is the best antidote to misinformation, when “journalists, experts and engaged citizens Tweet side-by-side correcting and challenging public discourse in seconds.”

Karen North, a social media professor at the University of Southern California’s Annenberg School for Communication and Journalism, said the company’s defense has some merit.

“Twitter functions more like a broadcast network,” she said. “People say things and everyone can hear it. When false information is stated, people can jump on false statements and challenge it.”

Source: Tech CNBC
Russian Twitter robots are blasting out angry NFL-national anthem messages, research shows

Comments are closed.