Homepage / Technology / Here's why the public isn't buying into an anti-tech campaign based on false premises
Лучшие тайтлы онлайн казино леон: топ новинок Picking a gaming platform 7Slots in the virtual space for real cash gaming: essential characteristics Meet other lesbianas and discover your perfect match Аркада Казино (Arkada Casino) Игровой Онлайн Клуб How To Locate The Very Best Transgender Online Dating Sites – Hookup Guide Find your perfect match: bi ladies seeking couples SLOT PULSA SITUS SLOT DEPOSIT PULSA 10 RIBU TANPA POTONGAN SEKALI SPIN MAXWIN Sports Betting Bet on Sports Online in South Africa Slot Entertainment Without Funding an Account in a Trusted Virtual Club Составление обзора казино в виртуальном формате Le Jeu en Ligne en France: Casinos en Ligne et leur Rфle dans l’Industrie Moderne des Jeux d’Argent Mostbet App A Convenient And Reliable Way To Place Bets Masjid Al-Huda Mranggen Demak Lemon Casino recenzja nowego polskiego kasyna Atrakcyjne bonusy i wysoki RTP! MostBet Bangladesh BD ᐉ Official Site Most Bet Casino and Sport Betting Lil Nas X calls out the BET Awards in his new single He has a point : NPR Most readily useful Adult Internet Dating Sites | FreeHookupsSites Unlocking the secrets of craigslist m4m green bay dating Just what comes in 66 sizes and vegan latex? Brand new generation of condoms | Sex | 8 Brands & Generics Human Growth Hormone HGH Injections Find local black hookups near you what’s ssbbw chat? About Japanese Dating society and also the west Guy who would like to Date a Japanese woman – MeetKing Blog 9 Guidelines On How To Hook-up On College Gameday (At Any College) Leading Live Casino Games Provider Leading Live Casino Games Provider Pin Up Slotlarýyla Eðlence ve Para Kazanma Bir Arada The core concept of digital entertainment hub AbeBet: signature points and groups Live-сессии с дилерами в онлайн-казино azino777 How Online Gambling Enterprises Operate Around the World Meet compatible single mothers and exchange ideas official site Play airplane online Ritalin: Jak legálně zakoupit bez receptu v České republice Connect with suitable asian singles in your area How-to Date A Pornstar While Making It Operate (The Ultimate Guide) Buy Bitcoin with Credit Card or Debit Card Instantly Buy Bitcoin How to buy BTC Finding trans girls near you – the simplest way to hookup Connect with like-minded singles on a mennonite dating website Assortment of in-demand games respected casino platform abe bet casino in cyberspace Connect with girls from round the world Alexander Gambling establishment: Dйcouvrez une Nouvelle Expйrience de Jeu en Ligne Le meilleur Extra casino en ligne pour jouer BLACK SEO LINKS, BACKLINKS, SOFTWARE FOR MASS BACKLINKING BLACK SEO LINKS, BACKLINKS, SOFTWARE FOR MASS BACKLINKING BLACK SEO LINKS, BACKLINKS, SOFTWARE FOR MASS BACKLINKING BLACK SEO LINKS, BACKLINKS, SOFTWARE FOR MASS BACKLINKING The simplest way to get a local hookup what’s millionairess dating? Get prepared to connect to latinas whom share your interests Estonian Chat place – an ideal Place for Dating Estonian Singles Join our bisexual chat room now and commence connecting Discover the advantages of dating a mature mom latina How to discover the best bbw hookup app for you Title: Juega en 1Win Casino Argentina Bonos y Apuestas 5 Best BBW Lesbian Dating Apps/Sites In 2022 Online Gambling Review submissions dia govt.nz Разыгрываемые джекпоты в виртуальном клубе Вулкан казино 30 Of The Greatest Adult Sex Toys For Males | Men’s Room Health Mag Australian Continent Cazino 7 slots cyberspace: conditions and rules for betting with real cash 1Win: ¡el mejor lugar de casino y apuestas deportivas de Argentina! Aufcasino Kde zakoupit Stromectol online: Kompletní průvodce ????Mature Dating Evaluation 2023 – Whatever You Need To Know About It! ???? Take the first step towards fulfilling your ebony lesbian bbw match now Ideas on how to come-out: Tips to keep in mind > Taimi Meet your perfect match – granny hookup site Türkiye-Çin İşbirliği Derinleşiyor GuGi Mobil Yükleme Seçenekleri Hizmet İçi Eğitim Sona Erdi Dooball tv ดูบอล ออนไลน์ สด 66 ลิงค์ บนมือถือ ฟรี ภาพชัด HD ทั่วโลก Find your rich cougar date in the most useful dating site Find your dream fat girl hookup today Slot Thailand Daftar Link Situs Slot Gacor Maxwin x500 Terbaru Hari Ini Resmi Auto Jackpot! Konsultasi ke Dewan Pers, Komisi I DPRD Jambi Pertanyakan Indeks Kemerdekaan Pers Jambi yang Turun Akses News Cerita Korban Judol di Balikpapan yang Nekat Gelapkan Uang How to get local horney women in your area 3 Cara Hapus Akun Judi Online Slot : Okezone Economy SITUS TOTO > Sering Kalah Main Di Situs Slot Gacor Terbaru Mudah Maxwin Situs Slot Gacor Maxwin Main Tanpa Pola Modal 5ribu Terbaik Melhores cassinos online de Novembro 2024: Confira o top 10! Enjoy amazing gay sex experiences using the top sites on the web Make the absolute most of one’s big butt dating adventure here 9 circumstances this means when a person avoids eye contact with a lady – Hack Spirit Top Greatest M4M Personals Sites in 2022 ◉ BLACK SEO LINKS, BACKLINKS, SOFTWARE FOR MASS BACKLINKING BLACK SEO LINKS, BACKLINKS, SOFTWARE FOR MASS BACKLINKING BLACK SEO LINKS, BACKLINKS, SOFTWARE FOR MASS BACKLINKING BLACK SEO LINKS, BACKLINKS, SOFTWARE FOR MASS BACKLINKING Лотерейные розыгрыши в kasino on-line Лев казино: условия осуществления и доступа Main features of playing in machines at online-club Karavan Connect with like-minded females making new friends Comment accéder à des jeux gratuits avec Space fortuna bonus ? PUCUK4D⭐ Bandar Toto Togel Online & Situs Toto 4d Terpercaya #1 Betting site Karavan bet Gates of Olympus internet-based: benefits of playing for real money Discover an environment of opportunities with lesbian and bisexual dating Aprovecha Los Códigos Promocionales De Bbrbet ¡más Bonos, Más Juegos 1xbet Giriş Yeni Adresi 2024 ⭐️ 1xbahis Güncel Adres » 1x Guess Mobil Casino How to get started with sext room BLACK SEO LINKS, BACKLINKS, SOFTWARE FOR MASS BACKLINKING BLACK SEO LINKS, BACKLINKS, SOFTWARE FOR MASS BACKLINKING

Technology

Here's why the public isn't buying into an anti-tech campaign based on false premises

If you read the popular press today, you’d think that people are about to march on Silicon Valley and Washington D.C., with pitchforks, demanding that legislators pass laws that restrict big tech from destroying the world.

The New York Times is publishing op-eds with gobsmacked titles like “Silicon Valley is Not Your Friend,” in which the author argues tech companies are about to “smash the foundations of our society,” while its columnist Farhad Manjoo frequently invokes the “Frightful Five” — the five biggest tech companies by market cap, Apple, Alphabet (formerly Google), Amazon, Facebook, and Microsoft.

Meanwhile, congressional committees are calling Facebook and Google to testify about how Russia bought advertisements seeking to influence the 2016 presidential election. Tech is being blamed for everything from spreading fake news to making teenagers miserable.

But the public still loves these companies.

As Wired reported on Thursday, public sentiment towards these so-called scourges hasn’t wavered at all in the past year, according to multiple polls. According to Morning Consult, Wired reports, 88 percent of respondents view Google favorably, with slightly lower numbers for Amazon (72 percent) and Facebook (60 percent).

What gives?

The campaign against big tech isn’t resonating, because it’s based on false premises that most people see right through.

A lot of the arguments against these companies hinge on the idea that people are being unfairly forced, or even coerced, to use them.

With the possible exception of Microsoft in some workplaces, this is nonsense.

Posting a new picture on Facebook or Instagram from your Apple iPhone and waiting for responses may indeed give you a hit of pleasurable brain chemicals, nudging you to use these products more and more. But so does watching an exciting TV show or movie, playing with your dog, seeing a crush on the street, and on and on. Calling for restrictions on a product because it offers pleasure to the people who use it is absurd.

What about critics like former Googler Tristan Harris, who argues that “our minds are being hijacked” by clever product designers at big tech companies?

That’s correct: Companies are designing their products to get you to take actions that help their businesses.

This is part of modern capitalism and it’s been around forever. Tech companies making notification buttons red instead of blue because red evokes a more urgent response are not fundamentally different from an advertisement that features happy beautiful people using a product, or the way grocery stores display products to guide you to the more profitable ones.

Criticize modern marketing or free markets, but this is not anything specific to tech. (Except that they hire really smart people who are quite good at what they do.)

This is a harder one to argue because it relies on subjective opinions about what society is and should be, and how individuals should relate to it.

Two big criticisms that come up often are fake news and Amazon hurting the retail industry.

Facebook and Google allowed fake news stories to circulate during the presidential election, and it was effective. According to one Buzzfeed study, toward the end of the election cycle, the top 20 fake news stories reached more Facebook users than the top 20 real news stories.

The problem is still going on: Just last week, several sites spread false information about the Las Vegas mass shooting, and Facebook and Google did not screen it out. These are serious product flaws, and both companies need to fix them.

But the societal features that encouraged people to believe and spread these fake news stories have been building for decades now.

Political rhetoric and voters have become steadily more extreme and partisan since the 1980s, and traditional news sites have echoed that partisanship in their coverage. The motivations for this are complex, but the Washington Post offered 10 reasons for this growing partisanship back in January 2015.

Facebook was built to make the spread of ideas as frictionless as possible. If those ideas are angry, polarizing, ill-informed, ignorant (call them whatever you want) it reflects the people who are spreading them, not the platform on which they’re spread.

In other words, social media is holding a mirror up to ourselves, and we don’t like what we see.

It’s the same with the criticism of Amazon. The company is relentless about providing low costs and convenient access to goods in the form of ever-faster delivery. Along the way, it plays hardball with suppliers, is sometimes sloppy about policing goods sold through its marketplace, and makes aggressive and surprising strategic moves like buying grocery store chains.

But overall, the criticisms of Amazon sound a lot like the salvos leveled at Wal-Mart a decade or two ago, when its convenient massive selection and low prices drove small-town retailers out of business.

Many Americans like buying stuff. They want that stuff as fast and as cheap as possible. Amazon is riding that wave, not creating it.

The loudest voices against tech right now come from two places: Democrats in Washington — like Virginia Senator Mark Warner, who has been among the loudest critics of Facebook — and the mainstream press.

These are, perhaps not coincidentally, two groups that were among the most surprised by the election of Donald Trump as president. In their continuing quest to figure out what went wrong, they’ve set upon the one sector of society that enjoyed almost universal praise during the Obama years. Remember how social media was once lauded for driving pro-democracy demonstrations, and allowing the distribution of unfiltered video of police killing unarmed citizens?

It’s particularly ironic for Democrats to attack the tech industry, given that Silicon Valley billionaires are among their largest and most reliable contributors, and that employees at tech companies vote overwhelmingly Democratic.

Attacking tech is also convenient for media companies as they realize that Google and Facebook are winning the war for attention and advertising dollars online, and there’s no change on the horizon.

The tech industry and its products are far from perfect. Tech companies and leaders often talk in ways that make them sound dishonest and out of touch. The gains created are not spread equally. There are some questionable and perhaps unethical decisions being made by people working in the industry (as is the case in every industry).

But overall, tech has given us more access to information and knowledge, more ways to communicate and easier access to goods and services than we did decades ago. You can use the tech industry as a scapegoat for an election result you didn’t like, or for driving your favorite bike shop out of business, but I’m not buying it.

Neither are most other Americans, if the polls are to be believed.

Source: Tech CNBC
Here's why the public isn't buying into an anti-tech campaign based on false premises

Comments are closed.