Homepage / Technology / The crisis over a diversity memo is forcing Google to uphold its values while fostering debate
Overstock.com shares spike after blockchain unit announces for-profit property registry Dow stock Boeing is on track for best year in nearly 4 decades, but the charts point to trouble Another bitcoin rival leaps to a record high, surpassing litecoin's market value Martin Sorrell: Finalized Disney-Fox deal would be a top media investment for us What to expect in Yellen's swan song: 'She's not a showboater' Target to buy grocery delivery service Shipt for $550 million When politicians and executives get caught out Some of Facebook’s early friends now its sharpest critics US says hacker to plead guilty for role in 2016 cyber attacks Laser chip maker Finisar jumps 25% on news that Apple's investing $390 million in the company The Amazon Echo now lets you play Spotify across all of your Echos Citi has 5 reasons — including tax reform and global growth — why Apple can keep crushing market Facebook will start streaming WWE professional wrestling next month Deregulation, global stock rally to 'propel' Morgan Stanley higher in 2018: KBW analyst A new law bans Kaspersky software from use in the US government Bitcoin 'dwarfs' nearly all bubbles, including 1929 crash: Investor Ken Fisher How 2017 became a turning point for tech giants The biggest risk you face when choosing between a human and a robo-advisor Disney deal with Fox would be a ‘home run’ in its battle against Netflix, Amazon, analyst Ives says Stocks making the biggest moves premarket: HON, LLY, AMGN, TM, HD & more Apple's 'innovation complacency' could see it lag Google, Amazon in post-smartphone world, study says Cryptocurrency market now worth $500 billion, more than Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway Tesla stock is up 12 percent in a week — but it could be time to pump the brakes Why Donald Trump's Jerusalem move might have made Russia a lot stronger Weekly mortgage applications fall 2.3% as rates rise Apple invests $390 million into Finisar, which makes laser chips for iPhone X and AirPods Leuthold's Doug Ramsey reveals top sector picks, bullish market predictions Tillerson says the US is ready to begin direct talks with North Korea German stock exchange operator Deutsche Boerse experiences trading disruption Russian court freezes $1.7 billion of Sistema assets at request of Rosneft A top Facebook exec is jumping on the bitcoin bandwagon ECB set to lift its growth outlook as massive bond-buying slowly winds down Swedish fintech start-up iZettle raises $47 million; CEO says 'time will tell' for IPO plans Google's top searches in 2017: Hurricanes, Matt Lauer and Tom Petty Google is blocked in China, but that's not stopping it from opening an AI center there UAE oil giant must build regional 'credibility' ahead of Saudi Aramco IPO next year European markets set to tread water ahead of Fed's decision Founder of a would-be tech powerhouse is blacklisted by China for allegedly disobeying court order Japanese start-up ispace just secured funds for first two lunar missions starting in 2019 China's GDP growth set to plunge to near 30-year low in 2018, ADB warns FBI agents called Trump an 'idiot' during presidential race South Korea may tax capital gains from cryptocurrency trading Japanese e-commerce firm to launch program for tech startups in Singapore I was wrong about bitcoin. Here's why Free money from China comes with strings — as one country's learning the hard way This power couple bought bitcoin in 2013, donated gains to cancer hospital Cramer Remix: What being young and broke taught me about the stock market Companies must have 'a culture of security' to prevent cyberattacks, McAfee CEO says Cramer's charts predict full speed ahead for industrial stocks like Caterpillar, Honeywell Asia markets take cues from a mixed US trading day ahead of Fed decision Cramer finds value-creating, investment-worthy CEOs across industries Novogratz says he would sell litecoin after its surge, sees bitcoin hitting $40k within a few months Here's why bitcoin prices are different on each exchange This start-up is making remote-controlled robots that can do surgery in space Apple’s up 43,000 percent since its IPO, and could soon surpass $1 trillion in market cap MongoDB falls despite earnings beat Why investors should beware stocks getting the bitcoin boost Billionaire investor Druckenmiller: ‘I love Amazon' more than Apple Facebook's accounting shift shows it expects a higher European tax bill next year Coinbase suspends ethereum buys and sells twice in one day Tesla shares pop after PepsiCo orders biggest fleet of Semi trucks so far San Francisco's mayor oversaw tax break that helped spark a new tech boom in the city Net neutrality protests have moved online, but big tech is keeping quiet My kids get 'no screen time whatsoever,' says Silicon Valley investor Chamath Palihapitiya I owned bitcoin for a weekend and here's what I learned NYU's Scott Galloway on bitcoin: It shows young people 'have no faith in our institutions' Some Ryanair pilots in Ireland to strike, German union steps up pressure Companies are already paying a tax rate as low as 13%, economist Yardeni estimates Facebook slams former exec Palihapitiya, saying it 'was a very different company back then' 80% of Wall Street economists, strategists believe bitcoin is a bubble: Survey Facebook to book advertising revenue locally amid political pressure Strategist Tom Lee: Young people will drive bitcoin gains just as boomers boosted stocks in the '80s This founder started in his parents' garage—now his company does over $100 million a year Activision shares to get a boost from Overwatch, Diablo sequels, Goldman says Bank of England to meet amid UK inflation surge: What to look out for Verizon will launch over-the-top service before year-end with NFL as key piece, analyst predicts Chamath Palihapitiya: Apple is 'no different than Louis Vuitton or any other luxury good' Passport's flagship fund to close after 'unacceptable' returns Apple's powerful new computer launches December 14 Despite a deluge of criticism, Mark Zuckerberg had a bountiful year Chamath Palihapitiya says Elon Musk is the 'most important entrepreneur of our generation' Senior Australian politician resigns over China ties scandal Forget bitcoin, one of its biggest cryptocurrency rivals is up nearly 5,800 percent this year Bitcoin futures fall on second day of trading on very low volume as interest wanes Bitcoin millionaire: Don't buy bitcoin Stocks making the biggest moves premarket: PEP, MAT, VZ, MYL & more Tech high flyers could soar 10% or more next year, investor Paul Meeks says Goldman Sachs predicts bumper returns for commodities next year Amazon is not a monopoly but there's no question why it's so dominant, tech investor Palihapitiya says Starbucks customer laptops hacked to mine cryptocurrency Fed Survey: Tax cuts and rate hikes on the way Social Capital's Palihapitiya says bitcoin is going to $1 million in the next 20 years Bitcoin bulls looking to diversify can now put money in a crypto-index fund Ex-Facebook executive Chamath Palihapitiya: Social media is creating a society that confuses 'truth and popularity' More American jobs? Broadcom deal might mean the opposite The bull case for gold as bitcoin captivates America One person reported dead after Austrian gas hub explosion Bitcoin bubble could lead to 'destructive' consequences, UBS says While you were watching bitcoin, the world’s second-largest cryptocurrency hit a big milestone French retail giant to buy mall operator Westfield in the biggest takeover of an Australian company ever

Technology

The crisis over a diversity memo is forcing Google to uphold its values while fostering debate

As a crisis unfurled at Google over an employee memo that argued biological factors helped explain the shortage of female engineers and leaders in Silicon Valley, some of the most pointed critiques of the company’s handing of the issue were posted to its own message boards.

Memegen, an internal forum that uses images overlaid with funny captions, was filled with irreverent posts that openly mocked how an email discussing the memo from Sundar Pichai, Google’s chief executive, had leaked to the media so quickly. Other posts, seen in screenshots of Memegen that were shared with The New York Times by a Google employee, questioned why Google seemed to be taking cues from outsiders.

Memegen is one of many outlets provided by Google to allow employees to express themselves, argue, criticize products or policies, and even protest decisions by management.

Google’s liberal stance toward self-expression, enabled by those online forums, was created in part to show that it is not bound by the conventions that stifle more stodgy companies.

Read more from The New York Times:
How to watch a solar eclipse
If missiles are headed to Guam, here is what could stop them
Taking your data plan to a new iPad

Google has prided itself on its openness. Employees can search documents for information about different divisions within the company on its internal network. They can make announcements and share information on the employee-only version of the social media service Google Plus. They can use Memegen to criticize management and openly challenge executives with questions voted on by employees at weekly companywide meetings.

And Google employees typically have a lot to say. There are about 87,000 Google groups — essentially email lists formed around a central theme — and more than 8,000 discussion groups like “misc” — short for miscellaneous — where employees debate and disagree on topics ranging from the optimal temperature in the office to the brand of laundry detergent the company should use for washing employee towels.

That openness has gone hand-in-hand with the expectation that what was said at Google would stay within Google. That’s a big challenge when Google’s parent company, Alphabet, now employs 76,000 employees around the world.

The company’s decision to fire James Damore, a software engineer who wrote the contentious memo, has angered some employees who view his dismissal as a betrayal of this open-discourse culture. Google said he had crossed the line “by advancing harmful gender stereotypes” and many employees were upset about the views outlined in the memo.

Mr. Damore asserts that he was “fired for telling the truth” — a point he reinforced with his recently opened Twitter account @fired4truth.

Mr. Damore said he shared the missive, titled “Google’s Ideological Echo Chamber,” about a month ago with specific individuals and groups focused on diversity before posting it to a mailing list called “skeptics” on Aug. 2. Then, Mr. Damore created a companywide discussion group for the document. As more employees took notice, Mr. Damore’s words soon spilled out onto the internet.

He was fired on Monday, and the situation quickly escalated. Someone with access to an employee-only version of Google Plus made screenshots of messages written by Google employees pledging to create blacklists of colleagues not supportive of the company’s diversity measures.

The screenshots appeared on Breitbart News, which has celebrated Mr. Damore’s memo as an example of Silicon Valley’s intolerance of conservative views. A number of Google employees who had been outspoken on the matter started facing harassment on the internet.

On Thursday, as Google prepared to hold a companywide meeting to discuss the memo, questions submitted by employees for the event on another internal system called Dory started to appear in the media. That reignited concerns that internal discussions would not stay private.

A number of employees sent emails to Mr. Pichai and told managers that they planned to skip the meeting because they were worried that they would face online reprisals for speaking out. A half-hour before the event was expected to begin, Mr. Pichai sent an email canceling the meeting.

“In recognition of Googlers’ concerns, we need to step back and create a better set of conditions for us to have the discussion,” Mr. Pichai wrote.

In an essay published in The Wall Street Journal on Friday, Mr. Damore said “there was no outcry or charge of misogyny” when he shared the memo initially. Only after the memo spread quickly online did the company take action, he wrote. Many Google employees recoiled at the document after he shared it more widely last week.

Last year, a Google security official sent a companywide email imploring employees not to leak information. Introduced as evidence in a lawsuit brought by a former employee alleging that Google’s confidentiality agreements were illegal, the email was telling because it highlighted the importance of open discussion at the company as well as its potential perils.

“Some of the recent discourse on Memegen and elsewhere within the company has been, shall we say, less than civil. Memegen, Misc, Internal G+ and our many discussion groups are a big part of our culture — they keep us honest — but like any conversation amongst colleagues, we should keep it respectful,” wrote Brian Katz, a Google director of protective services, investigations and intelligence.

Google’s embrace of openness was tested a few years ago when an engineer created a spreadsheet for employees to share salary information. As salary information flooded in, the spreadsheet became the most searched item on the internal network.

Erica Baker, the engineer who created the document and has since left the company, said she was reprimanded by her manager for the spreadsheet and was denied bonuses awarded to her peers. Google employees said the spreadsheet caused some headaches for human resources, but the company did not take down the document.

In his memo, Mr. Damore suggested that Google wasn’t quite so open. He said the company’s political biases created “a politically correct monoculture that maintains its hold by shaming dissenters into silence.” He said that if Google couldn’t have an honest discussion about the gender gap at the company, it could never truly solve the problem.

Perhaps not surprisingly, his memo was also mocked on Memegen.

Shortly after Mr. Pichai canceled the companywide meeting, he spoke at a coding event for young women being held on Google’s campus in Mountain View, Calif. He stressed the importance of women in the technology and urged them to build things that will be used widely in the future.

“I know the journey won’t always be easy,” he said. “But to the girls who dream of being an engineer or an entrepreneur, and who dream of creating amazing things: I want you to know that there’s a place for you in this industry, there’s a place for you at Google. Don’t let anyone tell you otherwise. You belong here and we need you.”

Source: Tech CNBC
The crisis over a diversity memo is forcing Google to uphold its values while fostering debate

Comments are closed.