Homepage / Technology / The crisis over a diversity memo is forcing Google to uphold its values while fostering debate
North Korea's economy may not survive another year, defector says Trump is toying with Iran — and another US adversary is watching $100 billion is not enough — SoftBank is in talks to raise a second giant tech fund China and emerging markets must stay 'vigilant' to possible risks, says IMF deputy managing director North Korea says 'a nuclear war may break out any moment' Copper surges on positive China data, dollar edges up ahead of Asian trade Cramer Remix: The one theme dominating this market’s hottest stocks Cramer explains why General Motors' stock is back in style on Wall Street Cramer: Trump stock Cintas is a 'terrific' play on job growth and has more room to run Cramer: The action in Apple's stock is a lesson on buying into weakness Apple explored buying a medical-clinic start-up as part of a bigger push into health care Facebook acquires anonymous polling app targeted at teens Microsoft adding Marriott CEO, former Commerce Secretary to board Months after Cisco bought AppDynamics for $3.7 billion, its founder is building a new start-up Netflix just tacked on another $1 billion to its content budget for next year Fund manager Novogratz agrees to advise ethereum-based digital coin exchange Jamie Dimon is betting big on the technology behind 'fraud' bitcoin A startup funded by iPod creator Tony Fadell is suing Andy Rubin's new company over trade secrets Buy Nvidia due to ‘strong underlying trends’ in digital currency, gaming: Analyst Netflix to report earnings after the bell Elon Musk drops Harry Potter jokes during his SpaceX chat on Reddit In defense of private equity For some Americans, it may be cheaper to Uber everywhere than to buy a car Mobile-only customers are the key to the next wave of Netflix growth Big tech and big pharma are set to clash over patent crackdowns Citigroup downgraded on credit quality concerns, 'disappointing' margins This series of new iPhones will be Apple’s most successful ever, says analyst Ives Oil prices rise toward six-month high as new Iraq conflict threatens output This robot could one day help your child learn a language Man says the Apple Watch saved his life after detecting an irregular heartbeat Apple's new campus is nearly finished and now Apple is building basketball courts US and China pouring millions into a bike race speeding across the globe Italy's new 'Rosatellum' law could see early elections that favor the mainstream parties Shake Shack's CEO might write you a $10 million check if you can prove this Supreme Court will hear US-Microsoft battle over emails Analysts expect a strong quarter from Netflix bolstered by subscriber growth Cramer: Netflix should be worth way more than its $80 billion-plus market value Bitcoin is finally buying into US real estate The charts are pointing to a big breakout for one FANG stock: Technician Op-Ed: As the world tweets, social media chiefs remain tight-lipped If you want to make a fresh financial start in 2018, here are 10 steps you can start taking now London is still Europe’s fintech hub despite Brexit, study says Here's where investors have reaped nearly 50% stock gains so far this year RBC downgrades Ford, cuts earnings estimates: 'It is still very early in the turnaround' Strategist Jim Paulsen: The economy may soon lose its power to boost stocks 'Tax alpha' is much more than simple tax-efficiency Huawei launches first smartphone with its own AI chip to challenge Apple's iPhone X North Korea's Kim Jong Un permits racetrack gambling as international sanctions take hold Apple upgraded because $1,000 iPhone will ‘extract’ more profits from consumers Stocks making the biggest moves premarket: ARMK, AAPL, ULTA, VIAB, TSLA & more Lufthansa reportedly offers $590 million for Alitalia's planes and staff Why de-dollarize? The greenback serves China's economy well T-Mobile, Sprint aim to announce merger without asset divestitures Major Wi-Fi security flaw could allow hackers to listen in on any of your devices Oil prices could see prolonged rally on Iraqi and Kurdish tensions, expert says IBM has a new blockchain for banks to speed up cross-border payments Wayfair is betting cheap delivery will push the online retailer past furniture giants Here's how the White House wants the GOP to talk about tax reform Millennial in Austria set to become the world’s youngest leader Wikileaks made a 50,000% return on bitcoin thanks to the US government, Julian Assange claims China's Huawei could overtake Apple this year in smartphones, top analyst says US vs. Japan: Giant robots are about to face off, fighting for their country Catalonia still won't say whether it's declaring independence, but wants to meet with Spanish leader S.Korea police seek arrest warrant for Hanjin Group chief China stands at 'a new historic starting point,' Communist Party says European shares seen higher as political news takes center stage Tell us what you think: Where does Bitcoin go from here? Amazon isn't playing in 'our sandbox,' says Lululemon CEO Australia's household debt is rising — but its treasurer says the situation is under control Iraqi troops advance on oil-rich Kurdish area that declared independence, raising fears of fighting The IMF has a message for emerging markets: Take advantage of easy money while you can China's September Consumer Price Index rose 1.6%, meeting expectations Social Capital's Chamath Palihapitiya explains the beauty of a calculated risk Asia markets to focus on firmer Wall Street, China inflation data ahead This doorbell lets you see who's at your front door, even when you're not home Hillary Clinton warns Britain on potential trade deal with Trump Here's why the public isn't buying into an anti-tech campaign based on false premises Germany's Social Democrats beat Merkel's conservatives in state vote Initial results show Austria tilting right in national vote How Avis rental cars formed an unlikely friendship with Alphabet Yellen sounds upbeat on economy, signaling likely rate hike The 2017 Lexus GS200t is the best value in the luxury sedan segment Britain, Germany committed to Iran nuclear deal after US plans to scrap the agreement 'Weaponized' platforms make stricter regulation of tech giants likely, Greyfire Advisory CEO says China is getting rid of free haircuts and fruit at the upcoming party Congress in austerity drive Draghi: Commercial real estate valuations stretched, but no bubbles in stocks or bonds How to stop your iPhone from driving you bonkers with notifications 'Alexa, order my meds' — start-up NowRx pioneers prescription orders through Alexa and Google Home Euro zone wages are rising more slowly than the ECB had hoped, Draghi says China will amend the party constitution which could tighten President Xi Jinping's grip on power Russian cargo ship launched to International Space Station Tesla fires hundreds of employees while trying to ramp up vehicle production, says report Cramer Remix: The FANG that won’t bite back Cramer: If you want to own tech and sleep at night, buy Texas Instruments HP Inc. CEO: We got into 3-D printing to get ahead of the inevitable manufacturing disruption Cramer's game plan: A pivotal earnings week These charts show how quickly bitcoin is growing Top tech investor: Cryptocurrency is going to make money transmission free Exclusive PRO Talks: Tech investor Cathie Wood says bitcoin is already changing how we live EU finance chief says name calling not helpful after 'enemy' jibe from UK

Technology

The crisis over a diversity memo is forcing Google to uphold its values while fostering debate

As a crisis unfurled at Google over an employee memo that argued biological factors helped explain the shortage of female engineers and leaders in Silicon Valley, some of the most pointed critiques of the company’s handing of the issue were posted to its own message boards.

Memegen, an internal forum that uses images overlaid with funny captions, was filled with irreverent posts that openly mocked how an email discussing the memo from Sundar Pichai, Google’s chief executive, had leaked to the media so quickly. Other posts, seen in screenshots of Memegen that were shared with The New York Times by a Google employee, questioned why Google seemed to be taking cues from outsiders.

Memegen is one of many outlets provided by Google to allow employees to express themselves, argue, criticize products or policies, and even protest decisions by management.

Google’s liberal stance toward self-expression, enabled by those online forums, was created in part to show that it is not bound by the conventions that stifle more stodgy companies.

Read more from The New York Times:
How to watch a solar eclipse
If missiles are headed to Guam, here is what could stop them
Taking your data plan to a new iPad

Google has prided itself on its openness. Employees can search documents for information about different divisions within the company on its internal network. They can make announcements and share information on the employee-only version of the social media service Google Plus. They can use Memegen to criticize management and openly challenge executives with questions voted on by employees at weekly companywide meetings.

And Google employees typically have a lot to say. There are about 87,000 Google groups — essentially email lists formed around a central theme — and more than 8,000 discussion groups like “misc” — short for miscellaneous — where employees debate and disagree on topics ranging from the optimal temperature in the office to the brand of laundry detergent the company should use for washing employee towels.

That openness has gone hand-in-hand with the expectation that what was said at Google would stay within Google. That’s a big challenge when Google’s parent company, Alphabet, now employs 76,000 employees around the world.

The company’s decision to fire James Damore, a software engineer who wrote the contentious memo, has angered some employees who view his dismissal as a betrayal of this open-discourse culture. Google said he had crossed the line “by advancing harmful gender stereotypes” and many employees were upset about the views outlined in the memo.

Mr. Damore asserts that he was “fired for telling the truth” — a point he reinforced with his recently opened Twitter account @fired4truth.

Mr. Damore said he shared the missive, titled “Google’s Ideological Echo Chamber,” about a month ago with specific individuals and groups focused on diversity before posting it to a mailing list called “skeptics” on Aug. 2. Then, Mr. Damore created a companywide discussion group for the document. As more employees took notice, Mr. Damore’s words soon spilled out onto the internet.

He was fired on Monday, and the situation quickly escalated. Someone with access to an employee-only version of Google Plus made screenshots of messages written by Google employees pledging to create blacklists of colleagues not supportive of the company’s diversity measures.

The screenshots appeared on Breitbart News, which has celebrated Mr. Damore’s memo as an example of Silicon Valley’s intolerance of conservative views. A number of Google employees who had been outspoken on the matter started facing harassment on the internet.

On Thursday, as Google prepared to hold a companywide meeting to discuss the memo, questions submitted by employees for the event on another internal system called Dory started to appear in the media. That reignited concerns that internal discussions would not stay private.

A number of employees sent emails to Mr. Pichai and told managers that they planned to skip the meeting because they were worried that they would face online reprisals for speaking out. A half-hour before the event was expected to begin, Mr. Pichai sent an email canceling the meeting.

“In recognition of Googlers’ concerns, we need to step back and create a better set of conditions for us to have the discussion,” Mr. Pichai wrote.

In an essay published in The Wall Street Journal on Friday, Mr. Damore said “there was no outcry or charge of misogyny” when he shared the memo initially. Only after the memo spread quickly online did the company take action, he wrote. Many Google employees recoiled at the document after he shared it more widely last week.

Last year, a Google security official sent a companywide email imploring employees not to leak information. Introduced as evidence in a lawsuit brought by a former employee alleging that Google’s confidentiality agreements were illegal, the email was telling because it highlighted the importance of open discussion at the company as well as its potential perils.

“Some of the recent discourse on Memegen and elsewhere within the company has been, shall we say, less than civil. Memegen, Misc, Internal G+ and our many discussion groups are a big part of our culture — they keep us honest — but like any conversation amongst colleagues, we should keep it respectful,” wrote Brian Katz, a Google director of protective services, investigations and intelligence.

Google’s embrace of openness was tested a few years ago when an engineer created a spreadsheet for employees to share salary information. As salary information flooded in, the spreadsheet became the most searched item on the internal network.

Erica Baker, the engineer who created the document and has since left the company, said she was reprimanded by her manager for the spreadsheet and was denied bonuses awarded to her peers. Google employees said the spreadsheet caused some headaches for human resources, but the company did not take down the document.

In his memo, Mr. Damore suggested that Google wasn’t quite so open. He said the company’s political biases created “a politically correct monoculture that maintains its hold by shaming dissenters into silence.” He said that if Google couldn’t have an honest discussion about the gender gap at the company, it could never truly solve the problem.

Perhaps not surprisingly, his memo was also mocked on Memegen.

Shortly after Mr. Pichai canceled the companywide meeting, he spoke at a coding event for young women being held on Google’s campus in Mountain View, Calif. He stressed the importance of women in the technology and urged them to build things that will be used widely in the future.

“I know the journey won’t always be easy,” he said. “But to the girls who dream of being an engineer or an entrepreneur, and who dream of creating amazing things: I want you to know that there’s a place for you in this industry, there’s a place for you at Google. Don’t let anyone tell you otherwise. You belong here and we need you.”

Source: Tech CNBC
The crisis over a diversity memo is forcing Google to uphold its values while fostering debate

Comments are closed.