Homepage / Technology / MongoDB had 'tremendous uncertainty' about going public, letter reveals
Asian shares look set to follow Wall Street's soft lead as US tax worries rise Putin and Trump talked on the phone, may have discussed Korean Peninsula Top drone maker will sell $16,500 drone for farmers on Amazon, CEO says 'Most obvious path' for leading US digital currency platform Coinbase is going public, COO says Eating junk and losing sleep: How Uber became a huge headache for Bill Gurley, a top tech investor Uber's purchase of Otto looks like it was much cheaper than originally reported The 5 biggest misconceptions about the Disney-Fox deal Oracle falls despite earnings beat Ripple surges 89% in single day, briefly becomes third biggest digital currency FCC's net neutrality reversal is denounced by Silicon Valley, Democrats Chanos looking at possible bet against Netflix and other streaming services Jim Chanos: We think Tesla is worth zero Wall Street analysts are missing the mark on some red-hot chip stocks Bitcoin investors could see bigger bills thanks to the GOP's tax plan New York attorney general will sue to stop the FCC's 'illegal rollback of net neutrality' Mark Zuckerberg, Priscilla Chan share tips to work with a spouse—and how they'll spend their wealth Mark Zuckerberg and Priscilla Chan: U.S. schools need more technology and one-on-one instruction Amazon Prime growth is slowing down in the U.S., says Morgan Stanley The FCC has reversed a 2015 rule that could change how you access and pay for internet service Cramer: The Disney-21st Century Fox deal gets rid of 'the ESPN problem' Facebook will put ads before videos as part of a new advertising strategy early next year Twitter shares soar to highest level since October 2016 Overstock.com CEO aims to sell or reorganize e-commerce business so he can focus on blockchain Tiffany shares jump after Citi upgrades, citing new leadership and acquisition speculation Bitcoin may now be the biggest financial bubble of all time Spotify's valuation has jumped as high as $19 billion in advance of US IPO, sources say UK's May 'disappointed' with defeat in parliament but says she's on course to deliver Brexit Art Cashin: The stock market rally on hopes for tax bill has more room to run America’s Public Company Accounting Oversight Board gets a new boss American business has concerns on tax reform Not even “The Last Jedi” will reverse Americans’ retreat from cinemas An accounting scandal sends Steinhoff plummeting Companies in the region vote with their feet against political uncertainty Billionaire media investor Mario Gabelli wonders whether Trump's like of Fox might help Disney deal CEO Bob Iger explains Disney's three-pronged approach to taking on Netflix The Murdochs wanted to sell to Disney—here are 4 reasons why Apple Maps now provides detailed maps of airports Disney deal with Fox to compete with Netflix and Amazon is a ‘lost cause,’ analyst says Deutsche Bank says fear of dying soda industry is overblown, recommends Coca-Cola, Pepsi Apple's most powerful computer ever is now available for purchase If the bitcoin boom goes bust, the stock market could see collateral damage, analyst Bob Doll says The FCC is making a landmark ruling Thursday about the future of the Internet ECB chief Draghi speaks following monetary policy decision Buy Lululemon for its ‘significant opportunities’ in international markets, Deutsche Bank says Stocks making the biggest moves premarket: FOXA, DIS, CBS, VZ, DAL, KO & more Here are five risks — including NAFTA and North Korea — that could get in this bull market's way Disney is better off not meddling with Hulu, despite bigger ownership share Disney to buy 21st Century Fox assets for $52.4 billion in stock; Bob Iger to stay on through 2021 Bank of England unanimously votes to hold interest rates, shifting focus to inflation Bitcoin futures could be coming to Germany soon: Report Putin abandons United Russia party, will run as an independent in 2018 election HSBC's currency expert gives his best trades for 2018 Tax reform should not hurt US trade partners, says top EU official All you need to know about the top 5 cryptocurrencies South Africa's Sibanye-Stillwater to buy troubled platinum producer Lonmin IBM teams up with Samsung, JPMorgan to develop quantum computing Greece should only get a debt deal after its bailout is finished, new Eurogroup president says Europe markets set to open lower after Fed meeting; investors await ECB decision Germany’s in the middle of a deep political crisis, but it won't affect the euro Meet the new euro zone finance chief, who’s promising a fresh response for the embattled region Brexit will be a key challenge for 2018, says next euro zone finance chief South Korea's President Moon heads to China to mend ties. Beijing needs a few favors too Australia accused China of political interference, and Beijing isn't happy China just released a bunch of economic data that was in line with expectations China lifts market rates, following move by Fed China and India are fiercely competing to control an airport that basically nobody uses Chinese state press slams Western 'paranoia' for suspicions of infiltration Microsoft doesn't have a flashy assistant like Alexa, but its A.I. is trying to change how you work Cramer says Fox deal will give Disney the scale it desperately needs Just Capital's Dan Hesse: Companies that do good things have roughly 33 percent higher returns Asian markets to focus on Fed's third rate hike of the year; US dollar slides Cramer: Bull markets 'die on euphoria,' and we're one step away There's a one-bedroom condo for sale in Miami — and the seller will only accept bitcoin Apple co-founder, ‘father of the internet’ to FCC: ‘You don’t understand how the internet works’ Satya Nadella wishes Microsoft had got into the public cloud business sooner This elevator goes up, down and sideways, and could be the key to taller skyscrapers Apple has a $1 billion fund for US manufacturers, but it could invest more, said COO Jeff Williams Fed raises rates a quarter point, hikes growth outlook for economy You should update your iPhone now, as the new software fixes a pretty big bug Ivanka Trump’s brand repositions at home, soars in Asia 'Nobody has built a money-printing machine like Apple,' VC Jason Calacanis says These 90 private companies are reshaping the space industry, says Morgan Stanley Gundlach says if you bet against bitcoin today 'you'll make money' Uber's culture issues can be blamed on Silicon Valley's hunger for fast growth: Arianna Huffington Google, Facebook founders were naive about propaganda, extremist content, say Silicon Valley titans Gundlach: Tax plan could have some' unintended consequences,' hurt junk bond market Cramer: People will fight it, but Apple's investment in Finisar is a 'fantastic' deal Facebook found just three Russian-bought Brexit ads, amounting to less than $1 Overstock.com shares spike after blockchain unit announces for-profit property registry Dow stock Boeing is on track for best year in nearly 4 decades, but the charts point to trouble Another bitcoin rival leaps to a record high, surpassing litecoin's market value Martin Sorrell: Finalized Disney-Fox deal would be a top media investment for us What to expect in Yellen's swan song: 'She's not a showboater' Target to buy grocery delivery service Shipt for $550 million When politicians and executives get caught out Some of Facebook’s early friends now its sharpest critics US says hacker to plead guilty for role in 2016 cyber attacks Laser chip maker Finisar jumps 25% on news that Apple's investing $390 million in the company The Amazon Echo now lets you play Spotify across all of your Echos Citi has 5 reasons — including tax reform and global growth — why Apple can keep crushing market

Technology

MongoDB had 'tremendous uncertainty' about going public, letter reveals

Two and a half months before MongoDB revealed plans to go public, its board members still faced “tremendous uncertainty” about going public, and weren’t sure if the company would go public this year or later, according to a newly posted regulatory filing.

The disclosure came on Oct. 3, two weeks after the database software company’s S-1 document appeared online. An official at the U.S. Securities and Regulatory Commission was asking questions about the fair value of the company’s stock earlier in 2017, and a lawyer representing the company responded with a fascinating explanation about what was going on inside the company in the run-up to the IPO.

As late as July 13, 2017, “there was still tremendous uncertainty as to whether the Company would complete an IPO in 2017, in 2018 or beyond,” Babak Yaghmaie, a partner with law firm Cooley LLP, wrote in the letter.

Part of that uncertainty stemmed from not knowing the company’s financial results for the quarter that would end on July 31, Yaghmaie noted.

The company ended up filing to go public on September 21, and started trading on October 19.

Timing an IPO is hard enough for a technology company, and it’s more difficult given the market where MongoDB does business — open-source infrastructure software. The fourth risk factor of the company’s S-1 filing — entitled “We currently face significant competition” — addresses this point, citing IBM, Microsoft and Oracle, as well as cloud infrastructure providers like Amazon and Google.

Plus, public markets don’t always value companies the way that venture capitalists do. On Thursday the company’s market cap stood at $1.5 billion, which was the company’s valuation as a private company almost three years ago, according to PitchBook data.

On Thursday afternoon, MongoDB’s stock was trading below $30 per share, putting it 10 percent below the $33 price at which the stock started trading on Oct. 19.

Here’s Yaghmaie’s complete response about MongoDB’s IPO timing:

The Company respectfully advises the Staff that on April 5 and April 19, 2017, June 6, 2017, and July 13, 2017, there was still tremendous uncertainty as to whether the Company would complete an IPO in 2017, in 2018 or beyond. The Company’s organizational meeting for the IPO took place on April 28, 2017. The April 30, 2017, valuation took into consideration the fact that the IPO organizational meeting had occurred and that the initial DRS [draft registration statement] had been submitted by the time the report was issued on July 13, 2017.

To reflect the potential for an IPO, the April 30, 2017, valuation introduced the IPO Scenario to the hybrid valuation model. When the Company’s board of directors granted stock awards in June 2017 and July 2017, whether the Company would elect to pursue an IPO in 2017 was still uncertain. The Company’s board of directors wanted to evaluate the Company’s upcoming quarterly financial results and assess achievement against certain operational milestones before making any firm decision regarding the ultimate timing of the Company’s IPO.

The Company’s board of directors did not know the results for the Company’s second fiscal quarter and was still weighing the possible timing of an IPO when it granted the June 2017 and July 2017 awards. Given this uncertainty, and the lack of other intervening events, the Company’s board of directors determined that it was still appropriate to rely on the Company’s April 30, 2017, valuation for purposes of determining the fair market value of such awards on July 13, 2017, and appropriate to apply a 25 percent weighting to the IPO scenario in the hybrid model.

The business continued to execute in late July and August against operational milestones laid out by the Company’s board of directors and, therefore, once the Company’s second fiscal quarter of 2017 were known, the Company had better visibility into its possible IPO timing.

While significant uncertainty still remained as to the timing and likelihood of the Company’s IPO, the Company increased the IPO scenario weighting in the July 31, 2017, valuation to 50 percent of the hybrid model, which was issued by the third party valuation firm on September 6, 2017, taking into consideration the progress towards an IPO up to that date and the results of the second quarter.

Source: Tech CNBC
MongoDB had 'tremendous uncertainty' about going public, letter reveals

Comments are closed.