Homepage / Technology / US tech industry fought to keep ties to Russia spy service, despite hacking charges
Menyelami Dunia Slot Thailand: Keseruan dan Peluang Kemenangan Besar Menyelami Dunia Slot Thailand: Pengalaman Bermain yang Tak Terlupakan Стиль и Защита: Чехлы на Телефон и Планшет от Womux com NikaDate.com 2025: Trick Insights Before You Sign up with Elderly Sizzle: Come Across Great Hookups Over 40? | 1win APP: Descargar, Juegos, Casino, APK Chile cl 1win Punjab FC create history with historic 2-1 win against Everton FC SofiaDate Evaluation 2025: Is This Website Worth The Buzz And Cash? bets10’in Kazançlý Slot Oyunlarý Nv Casino: Przewodnik po Świecie Gier Hazardowych Casino Wazamba Online Summary Discover the best local hookup internet sites for meeting wives Leading Gay Dating Apps: My Personal Collection test Télécharger 1win Sénégal apk 1win Sénégal inscription popochka Hesap Açma Promosyonu Veren Siteler Xslot Kumar ve Güven Merkezi Get the absolute most out of your ebony bbw site source Leading Online Casino Rocketplay Evaluation Find the right partner on nymphomaniac dating website what exactly are local sex websites and exactly how can they assist you to? casino 643 Online Casino 7slots Grandpashabet 2217 Güncel Giriş Adresi Grandpashabet2217 com 5804 grandpashabet güncel Trezor Suite Official Desktop && Web Crypto Ledger Live App: Buy, Sell, Stake and Swap Crypto Hardware Wallet & Crypto Wallet Security for Crypto Shared: The 7 Things Men Want from Females What is Ledger Recover? New Feature Review 2024 What is Ledger Recover? New Feature Review 2024 Enjoy the thrill of meeting new individuals in web adult chat rooms sex 1Win Burkina Faso Parie en ligne chez le bookmaker en Afrique Grandpashabet Bahis Sitesi Güvenilirlik ve Eğlencenin Buluştuğu Adres 0053 Southern African Men – Meeting, Dating, and More (plenty of Pics) Silvana lee adult Grandpashabet Grandpashabet Resmi Güncel Giriş 7719 Enjoy a fun, protected, and unique dating experience Nuevos casinos en Argentina: expansión y regulación conforme al juego responsable Philadelphia Gay Dating: Get The Best Partners Lucky Jet официальный сайт игры от 1win games Join our community of bisexual women and discover your perfect match today Merdeka777: Daftar Situs Judi Slot Online Terpercaya Make buddies and discover love with local fetish chatroom Лучшие Онлайн Казино С Высокими Выплатами На Рулетке 2025 SecretBenefits Assessment: Prices, Characteristics and Buyer Critiques Website Resmi UIN SMH Banten Abebet Slot Sitelerinde Hoþgeldin Bonusunun Avantajlarý Maltcasino: Yeni Üyeler Ýçin Hoþgeldin Bonuslarý Opiniones sobre 1xSlots Lee las opiniones sobre el servicio de 1xslot com What you’ll want to know Take step one towards love and pleasure today Making Uses Of Prednisone Tablets Take control of your love life in order to find bbw mature lesbians today Bahis Sitelerinde Ücretsiz Deneme Bonusları Nasıl Kullanılır? Rulet Masalarında Bonuslarla Daha Fazla Kazanın Player women online dating| discover single video games women at Masalbet: En Çok Kazandýran Casino Sitesi Gambling in Australia and Modern Settlement Methods: The Rise of PayID TUAN88 Situs Main Game Online dengan Aman dan Nyaman Brit Cam Place — Singles From British Look For Pleasant Companions And Dating 1xbet Registration ᐉ 1xbet Sign Up برنامج المراهنات الرياضية تحميل التطبيق العميل Eg 1xbet Com Cassino Kto Jogos Para Cassino Online No Brasil” 1xbet Apk 1xbet للموبايل حمل تطبيق 1xbet لأنظمة أيفون و أندرويد 1xbet مصر Eg 1xbet Com Melhores Casas Sobre Apostas No País Brasileiro 2024 Casa-apostas Apresentando” قم بتنزيل 1xbet على جهاز الكمبيوتر ، وكيفية تنزيل تطبيق سطح المكتب على جهاز الكمبيوتر برنامج المراهنات الرياضية تحميل التطبيق العميل 1xbet Com How To Try Out Roulette Rules & Guide How To Win From Slots: Top Ideas To Boost Your Own Chances How To Win The Car In Gta 5 Casino Win The Particular Gta Online Scène Vehicle How To Win The Car In Gta 5 Casino Win The Particular Gta Online Scène Vehicle How To Perform Slot Machines Najlepsze kasyna bez depozytu 2025 The Best Different Roulette Games Strategy Tips In Order To Win At Roulette Promozioni effettive di 22Bet in Italia Отзывы о казино Stake от реальных игроков 2025 о выплатах и игре The Best Different Roulette Games Strategy Tips To Win At Roulette Cassinos legais no Brasil: novas regras e melhores sites Top 10 Biggest Casinos In The Usa 1xbet 보너스 받는법 및 출금 롤링조건 등 사용법 총정리 온라인카지노 Kr Your Current Reliable Partner Regarding Tent Manufacturing Online Kaszinó Játékok És Élő Kaszinó Játékok History Of Las Vegas Casinos Who Else Built It & How Sin City Emerged To Be En Güvenilir Canlı Bahis Empieza Casino Sitesi Игровые Автоматы На мнимые Деньги Играть Онлайн В Лучшие Слоты How To Available A Casino: A Detailed Six-steps Guide Gaming Paradise Is Just Around The Corner: Top Ten Casinos Throughout Las Vegas Find the right person: tips for effective singles dating over 60 10 Regarding The World’s Largest Casinos: The Greatest Casinos Ever! Gamification : la limite entre jeu vidéo et casino en ligne se brouille Ufc 302 Gdzie Oglądać Za Darmo I Na Żywo? 2 06 24 ‎Casino ua online casino club on the App Store 1xbet تسجيل الدخول للجوال قم بتسجيل الدخول إلى حساب 1xbet الخاص بك “원엑스벳1xbet 프로모션 코드 2024: Jbmax Vip! Sweet Bonanza Ücretsiz Demonstration İle Oyun Deneyimi Verde Kaszinó: Új Kaszinó Oldal Rendkívüli Bónuszokkal! Türkiye Casino Sitelerinin Adresi 2024 En Iyi Türk Online Casino En Güncel Ve Güvenilir On Line Casino Ve Bahis Sitelerinin Adresi 2024 Listesi 1xbet 모바일 앱-어플 2024, 버전, 다운로드, 설치, Ios, 안 Diocesan Development Services To The Particular North Karamoja Dds-n Sai Dwaraka In Nessun Caso Tours & Travels Pin-up On Line Casino Türkiye En İyi Canlı Casino Oyunları Ve Slot Makineleri Strategies for making a bisexual woman feel very special and loved Diamond Casino Heist The Big Disadvantage Walkthrough

Technology

US tech industry fought to keep ties to Russia spy service, despite hacking charges

As U.S. officials investigated in January the FSB’s alleged role in election cyberattacks, U.S. technology firms were quietly lobbying the government to soften a ban on dealing with the Russian spy agency, people with direct knowledge of the effort told Reuters.

New U.S. sanctions put in place by former President Barack Obama last December – part of a broad suite of actions taken in response to Russia’s alleged meddling in the 2016 presidential election – had made it a crime for American companies to have any business relationship with the FSB, or Federal Security Service.

U.S. authorities had accused the FSB, along with the GRU, Russia’s military intelligence agency, of orchestrating cyberattacks on the campaign of Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton, a charge Moscow denies.

But the sanctions also threatened to imperil the Russian sales operations of Western tech companies. Under a little-understood arrangement, the FSB doubles as a regulator charged with approving the import to Russia of almost all technology that contains encryption, which is used in both sophisticated hardware as well as products like cellphones and laptops.

Worried about the sales impact, business industry groups, including the U.S.-Russia Business Council and the American Chamber of Commerce in Russia, contacted U.S. officials at the American embassy in Moscow and the Treasury, State and Commerce departments, according to five people with direct knowledge of the lobbying effort.

The campaign, which began in January and proved successful in a matter of weeks, has not been previously reported.

In recent years, Western technology companies have acceded to increasing demands by Moscow for access to closely guarded product security secrets, including source code, Reuters reported last week.[nL1N1JK1ZF] Russia’s information technology market is expected to reach $18.4 billion this year, according to market researcher International Data Corporation.

The sanctions would have meant the Russian market was “dead for U.S. electronics” said Alexis Rodzianko, president of the American Chamber of Commerce in Russia, who argued against the new restrictions. “Every second Russian has an iPhone, iPad, so they would all switch to Samsungs,” he said.

A spokesman for the U.S. Commerce Department Bureau of Industry and Security declined to comment. A State Department official said Washington considered a range of factors before amending the FSB sanction and regularly works with U.S. companies to assess the impact of such policies.

The lobbyists argued the sanction could have stopped the sale of cars, medical devices, and heavy equipment, all of which also often contain encrypted software, according to a person involved in the lobbying effort. The goal of the sanctions was to sever U.S. business dealings with the FSB – not end American technology exports to Russia entirely, the industry groups argued.

“The sanction was against a government agency that has many functions, only one of them being hacking the U.S. elections,” said Rodzianko.

The lobbyists assembled representatives from the tech, automotive and manufacturing sectors to make the case to the U.S. Treasury Department, said the person involved in the lobbying effort.

The industry groups did not argue against the intent of the sanction but asked for a narrow exception that would allow them to continue to seek regulatory approvals from the FSB while still keeping in place the broader ban on doing business with the spy agency.

The industry groups represent a number of technology firms with a large presence in Russia, including Cisco and Microsoft.

Reuters was unable to determine which companies were directly involved in the lobbying. Microsoft said it did not ask for changes to the sanctions. In a statement, Cisco said it also did not seek any changes to the sanction but had asked the Treasury Department for clarification on how it applied.

In order to get encrypted technology into Russia, companies need to obtain the blessing of the FSB, a process that can sometimes take months or even years of negotiation. Before granting that approval, the agency can demand sensitive security data about the product, including source code – instructions that control the basic operations of computer equipment.

The United States has accused Russia of a growing number of cyberattacks against the West. U.S. officials say they are concerned that Moscow’s reviews of product secrets could be used to find vulnerabilities to hack into the products.

Some U.S. government officials rejected the industry groups’ arguments. They openly embraced the prospect of any ripple effect that cut further trade with Russia.

Kevin Wolf was assistant secretary at the Commerce Department and oversaw export control policy when the FSB sanction was put in place. Wolf said within days of the sanction taking effect, Commerce received numerous calls from industry groups and companies warning of the unintended consequences.

But for Wolf, who was “furious” with Moscow over the alleged cyberattacks, any additional curbs on trade with Russia was a bonus rather than an unintended downside.

“I said, ‘Great, terrific, f__k ’em … The whole point is to interfere with trade’,” recounted Wolf. “The sanction was meant to impose pain (on Russia) and send a signal as punishment for very bad acts.”

Wolf left the Commerce Department when President Donald Trump took office on Jan. 20.

Other officials felt that the impact on legitimate trade was too great. “The intention of the sanction was not to cut off tech trade with Russia,” said a U.S. official with direct knowledge of the process.

The lobbyists had also argued that since the sanctions only applied to U.S. technology makers, it would put them at a disadvantage to European and Asian companies who would still be able to interact with the FSB and sell products in Russia.

“We were asking for a narrow technical fix that would give a fair deal for American companies,” Dan Russell, CEO of the U.S.-Russia Business Council, said in an interview.

The advocacy worked. State and Treasury officials began working to tweak the sanction in January before Obama left office, according to people involved in the process.

On Feb. 2, the Treasury Department created an exception to the sanction, about two weeks after Trump took office, to allow tech companies to continue to obtain approvals from the FSB.

Source: Tech CNBC
US tech industry fought to keep ties to Russia spy service, despite hacking charges

Comments are closed.