Homepage / Currency / The financial markets are not the whole economy
Deneme Bonusu Veren Siteler Deneme Bonusu 2024 Explore the Magic of WildCardCity Güvenilir Bahis Siteleri En İyi Kumar Siteleri Balıkesir Triatlonuna Avrupadan Ödül Tricks of the Aviator gambling establishment game by Spribe Çevrim Içi Kumar Siteleri “bonus” Yalanıyla Kandırıyor En Güvenilir Canlı On Line Casino Siteleri Xbetting-tips Com Uncovering the Abundant Tapestry of Ozwin Gambling establishment Evaluating Board Portal Providers Uncovering the Wealthy Tapestry of Ozwin On line casino Electronic Data Area Providers Evaluation Cobra Internet casino: Raising the Australian On the internet Video gaming Practical experience 4 Things to Search for in Safeguarded Cloud Safe-keeping Fastpay On line casino Australia – Simple and No-Taxation Wagering Web page officielle franзaise de Joka Gambling establishment The Software Development Universe Game Woo Internet casino – Enjoy Slot machine games around australia Ostdeutsche Biersorten What Are Virtual Data Rooms? Vitamin D Receptor Polymorphisms Revue du Casino BlackLabel Faktory, kterй ovlivnujн hodnocenн ceskэch online kasin How to Make the Most of Your Web Development Organization and Advertising Efforts L’essor des casinos en ligne en France Boost Meeting Efficiency With Boardroom Technology Developments WildJoker Casino WildCardCity On line casino – Guaranteed Australian Gambling Portal WildCardCity Casino – The Ideal On the internet Gambling establishment within australia Modern Technologies Produce Sharing Documents Online Faster and More Protect Free Virtual Info Room pertaining to Speedy Due Diligence A Review of Data Area Software For people who do buiness Five Board Bedroom Features Which will help You Acquire a More Productive Boardroom Electronic Systems To your Business Understanding Legal Terms and Laws in Today’s World The Laws and Contracts of Hollywood: A Sunset Blvd. Tale Legal Discussion Between Johnny Cash and Antonin Scalia Legal Insights: What Teens Should Know Legal Issues and Exceptions: What You Need to Know Legal Insights and Expert Analysis Celebrity Dialogue: Legal Matters in the 21st Century Famous Personalities Discuss Legal Issues The Boys in the Boat: Legal Advisors and The Quest for Legal Knowledge Understanding Legal Matters: Q&A on Criminal Law, Joint Ventures, and More Enticing Title The Departed: Understanding Basic Work Requirements and Legal Rights Youth Slang Blog Article Legal Insights: A Journey into the World of Law The Ins and Outs of Legal Matters: Everything You Need to Know Legal Insights and Trends: A Rap Guide Mysterious Legal Matters Unveiled Insights and Information: Understanding Various Laws and Regulations Famous People of the 21st Century The Circle of Legal Life The Intersection of Fashion Law, Legal Translation, and THC Oil: A Modern Legal Guide Legal Q&A: Understanding Joinder Federal Rules and More Understanding Legal Terms and Conditions: A Comprehensive Guide Understanding Legal Documentation in a Fun Way! Understanding Legal Aspects: From Islamic Law of Inheritance to Farm Law Protests Understanding Legal Rights: A Guide to Legal Regulations and Requirements Understanding Legal Guidelines and Agreements Famous 21st Century People in Conversation Mysterious Legal Matters Unveiled Legal Matters and Real Estate: A Conversation Between Cameron Boyce and Donald Trump Understanding Legal Expertise and Why It Matters Legal FAQs and Expert Services Understanding Legal Ramifications: Common Law Ontario Health Benefits and More The Ins and Outs of Legal Requirements: From FBI Academy Physical Requirements to Silver Lake Fishing Rules The Legal Underworld: Understanding the Significance of Laws and Rights Legal Conversations: A Dialogue Between Jon Jones and Chadwick Boseman Legal Beats: Bobcats, Real Estate, Babysitting, and More Legal Matters and Netflix VPN Diabolique: Legal Affairs and Deception Ben Shapiro and Eddie Van Halen Discuss Legal Matters Legal Aid and Other Legal Issues Q&A Famous 21st Century Personalities in Dialogue Youthful Blog Post Expert Legal Insights: Top 8 Law Firms in Australia, Quasi Contracts, and More! Youth Slang in Legal Matters Steps to make Your Mother board Room Even more Productive and Meaningful Choosing Data Rooms for Homework The Enigmatic World of Legal Affairs and Contracting The Mystery of Legal Matters Understanding Legal Mandates and Guidelines in the Business World Celebrity Dialogue: Legal Matters and Personal Names Legal Questions: Answered! Mysterious Legal Insights and Tips The Mysterious World of Legal Agreements Legal Lingo: Reviews, Agreements, and More Exploring Legal Education and Responsibilities: A Comprehensive Guide Unconventional Wisdom: A Dialog Between 21st Century Icons Mysterious Legal Matters Unraveled The Legal Maze: Navigating the Legal Landscape Dialogue between Jared Kushner and Vasyl Lomachenko Legal Matters: A Conversation Between Prince and Lionel Messi Get Clued In: The Legal Lowdown for Gen Z Famous People of the 21st Century Talk About Legal Matters The Enigmatic World of Legal Agreements and Terms Are You Breaking the Law? Unusual Legal Questions Answered Understanding Legal Services, Parental Responsibility Laws, and More Understanding Legal Agreements and Requirements


The financial markets are not the whole economy

DONALD TRUMP is fond of pointing out that the stockmarket has reached many record highs under his Presidency. It is a capricious measure to boast about, and one that may not fully reflect the concerns of those who voted for him and probably care more about real wage growth. And a look at the ratio of stockmarket capitalisation relative to GDP shows that this measure is close to a record high. And that led me to reflect on a sentence I wrote a few years ago: we are better at creating new claims on wealth than at creating wealth itself.

That sentence was written in the context of the huge rise in debt in the 40 years leading up to the 2008 crisis, and on the multiplication of obscure financial instruments that preceded it. It reflected the huge rise in the economic role of  the finance sector, and the wages of those who work within it. But it also relates to the way that the authorities have helped economies recover from the crisis. One of the main tools was quantitative easing (QE), creating money (new claims on wealth) in order to buy assets. 

  • Zaryadye Park in Moscow is an architectural triumph

  • The financial markets are not the whole economy

  • Congestion in London is driving people off the buses

  • Scott Pruitt seeks to weaken independent scientific review at the EPA

  • South Korea’s soaring minimum wage

  • Jeff Flake says he will not seek re-election to the Senate

The motivation for QE was perfectly understandable. The financial pressure on banks was causing them to shrink their balance sheets, and thus the supply of credit to the rest of the economy; when that happened in the 1930s, the result was the Great Depression. Nevertheless, successive rounds of QE, accompanied by other forms of monetary stimulus, have resulted in very high asset values and ultra-low interest rates. What was initially sold as a short-term crisis expedient measure looks set to last longer than a decade.

Total debt levels in the economy have not fallen; the debt has been shifted away from the financial sector and onto the government (and via QE, on to the books of central banks). For as long as it stays on the books of central banks, the system is more stable but if QE is ever fully unwound, the system will be just as risky as before. 

Creating money is the solution to a particular problem; a shortage of demand. It is harder to make the case for this at the moment when economies have been growing for a significant period, and when unemployment in both America and Britain is under 4.5%. Back in 2013, Mervyn King, then the governor of the Bank of England, warned that

there are limits on the ability of domestic monetary policy to expand real demand in the face of the need for changes in the real equilibrium of the economy. I do not believe that the present problems in the United Kingdom stem only from a large negative shock to aggregate demand. In common with many other countries, our problems also reflect the underlying need to rebalance our economy, requiring a reallocation of resources both within and between nations. It is not simply a question of boosting aggregate demand, but of helping to bring about a shift to a new equilibrium. 

One of the great economic puzzles of recent years has been the slowdown in productivity growth across western nations. There are many potential explanations for this: the continued survival of zombie companies in a low rate era; mismeasurement of the gains from technology; new tech being less significant than older innovations (the Robert Gordon thesis); a preference among businesses to use extra labour when wages are low. And so on. Without productivity growth, long-term economic growth will be sluggish, especially given the ageing nature of western populations. And it is not clear how monetary policy can be much of a help.

The same goes for the frenzied activity of the financial sector. Finance has four important functions: operating the payments system; channelling funds from savers to the corporate sector; providing liquidity to the market by buying and selling assets; and helping the rest of society to manage risks, both financial and non-financial. So one can justify all the activity – the endless multiplication of funds and instruments or the frenetic trading activity – along these grounds. More liquid asset markets potentially lower the cost of capital; the creation of instruments such as derivatives allow risk to be allocated more efficiently, to those who have the appetites (and balance sheets) to handle it. 

But that argument is much harder to make in the wake of the 2008 crisis. It turned out that the banks had not kept the risk off their balance sheets and the apparent liquidity of many assets was an illusion. In the wake of the crisis, the banks have shored up their balance sheets, in part by reducing the capital they devote to trading activities, with the result that, in a crisis, markets may be even less liquid than before.

We know that every time a financial asset gets trade, someone in the industry take a cut – a commission, a fee or a bid-offer spread. It is hard to calculate whether the gains made by the rest of society in terms of a lower cost of capital etc are more, or less, than the finance sector’s take. Many within the industry will point to the falling cost of trading. But that is offset by the number of times assets are traded; Thomas Philippon’s study found that the proportionate cut taken by financial intermediaries is as large as it was in the 19th century. 

Winston Churchill famously said that he would “rather see finance less proud and industry more content.” A lot of people might be happier if the stockmarket was less buoyant and the average standard of living was more so.

NextWhen the revolution eats itself

Source: economist
The financial markets are not the whole economy

Comments are closed.